You are a hypocrite, Pieman. You say Toad shouldn't be given made-up moves and yet you support Mona and wants to make up moves for her based on microgames or her pets or something. You say Toad is not really a fighter... but Mona is not a fighter. At least Toad and Toads had some combat experience... something Mona severely lacks.
That's a different case, where the moves are based on their actions, as well as the contents of their games. In addition, I said the use of her animal helpers could be used too, who wouldn't need moves made up for them. The only way this type of borrowing from the series would really work for Toad though is if his moveset was based around the sports games, though that seems like something that would be done for Waluigi (Who for the record has less of a chance than Toad) Additionally, I must restate that I'm not saying that Toad can't get in, but rather that his chances aren't nearly as high as you state they are. Heck, Mona's chances are iffy at best.
If Toad was in Smash, he could throw Poison Mushrooms to shrink characters like he did in Super Mario Kart, use Golden Mushrooms from Mario Kart: Double Dash!! to charge to run and tackle down a character, pull out and throw vegetables from Super Mario Bros. 2, and even hover in the air with the Propeller Suit from New Super Mario Bros. Wii. He would be a speedy lightweight with incredible superstrength contrary to his small size and, if Sakurai wants to, have the ability to run up on walls like in Wario's Woods.
So he'd use a item, a move that's been done to death already (egg roll, withdraw, Wario Bike, Rollout. Take you pick) Peach's move, and one pottentially creative move that would still probably end up like Snake's' up special.
And not as a part of the debate whether Toad would get in or not, but wouldn't a small, fast, and super strong character not be a good idea?
Oh, I love how you argue that "if we let generic races join Smash, we should add Koopa or Shy guy" as an attempt to put down Toad. Toads are far more important than these generic races. You never play as Goomba, Koopa, Shy Guy, etc. in canonical games. They are only playable in spin-off games. But Yoshis and Toads have been playable outside spin-off games. Yoshis and Toads are the most important generic races in Mario canon. Also, Toad is next in line on the Melee poll with 27 votes after Bowser (169), Peach (66), and Wario (65).
How are Toads more important? Toad was only put into SMB2 as a filler character to take up Papa's space, and since then never was playable in the main games, though it seems two different colored Toads will show up in NSMBWii (Why they didn't just have the normal Toad, and use the 4th slot on Wario or Peach is beyond me) Yoshi wasn't really playable either, seeing as he was just a mount. (Though that did change when he got his own series, which he's represented under) Koopas, Shy Guys, and Goombas (Who I'm not really going to advocate due to the fact that they simply have no arms, but when you mention the other two, you kind of have to include them) are the main flunkies you see in like 90% of Mario games, and are actually active in said games, instead of sitting on the side giving information. Still I guess I shouldn't really comment on this whole thing until more info is given on NSMBWii, since that could be a turning point for Toad, depending on his technical role in it, in relation to the two playable Toads within the game.
Oh, and on the Geno debate that's been going on, Geno's not getting in. For established series, mostly all the newer characters who are added actually have some importance to the series, and don't upstage those who have more. There are several Mario characters who are better known, have contributed more to the series, and have actually had a role in more than one game (main series or not) including Toad, Bowser Jr, Paper Mario, Dr Mario, Baby friggen Mario, Waluigi, Daisy, Birdo, Koopa Troopa, Goomba, Shy Guy, the Hammer Brothers, King Boo, Petey Piranha, the Koopalings, and even Rosalina. On top of that, Geno's third party, and his last (and only) big role was from a game that came out over 10 years ago. Yes he has moveset pottential, and yes he has some noisy fans, but that doesn't change the fact that he's a old, nude, SE-owned-yet-still-part-of-the-Mario-franchise, undeserving character. The only way I could think of him getting in is if SE teamed up with Nintendo, and they decided to throw in Geno on top of the FF or DQ character that really is supposed to represent the company.
