Top
Marth
Fox
Sheik
Falco
Jigglypuff
High
Captain Falcon
Peach
Ice Climbers
Ganondorf
Middle
Samus
Dr. Mario
Luigi
Donkey Kong
Mario
Link
low
Pikachu
Young Link
Roy
Zelda
Game and Watch
Bottom
Ness
Yoshi
Bowser
Mewtwo
Kirby
Pichu
a few things I noticed. I'll just brief through them for now, and get more in-depth later
1) Marth has power and range, sure, but I think he just doesn't have the tech skill and speed to be number one. he can't SHFFL quick combos and can't turn the tables on a faster Fox, Falco, Marth, Sheik, or even ICs getting close and pressuring him. his grabs are mediocre at best (his spacie grab is overrated; it only works until like 40%), and he gets ruined by a good ground game. I think he should be below Fox and Sheik., or at least Fox.
2) Captain Falcon is a combo beast. he can ruin any ground or air game. his nair is an amazing opener, and his knee is really the only move that can function as both an insane comboer and an amazing kill move. his Dair is great, and the nipple spike is a true spike. his recovery is underrated; not only does the down-B glitch save lives, but it is also worth mentioning that his recovery is a ***** to gimp or edgeguard. did I mention that he can also juggle Uairs, chaingrab with three different grabs (some of which are 0-death grabs on certain characters), and a range that is bigger than it looks? because of all of this, I think he should be above Jiggs.
3) I don't know what should say about Ganon being above Samus. Samus wrecks the lower tiers, and has a great projectile, air, ground, and crouch cancel game (and don't underestimate the windmill of death lol). still, after seeing linguine and some other great Ganons play, i'm keeping my mouth shut on this one for a while.
4) I like seeing DK above mario
5) I personally think that Pikachu is worse than Roy and Y. Link. but to not get this too annoying to others, I'm only going to argue for Y. Link. Young Link has an amazing hold on the low and bottom tiers. Young Link also has a fast camping and projectile game, as well as a whole arsenal of gimps.
6) most of the bottom tiers look good, except for Kirby being above Pichu. Seriously, Pichu has a good recovery, projectile, good grabs, attacks, and combos (relatively of course). Kirby has no good projectiles, terrible grabs, no kill moves that don't hit the foe upwards, weak attacks, and no good specials.