Official MBR 2010 NTSC Tier List

[Bones0]

All of these characters are horrible vs Peach.

If the Peach player while falling asleep unconsciously holds on to the controller and starts techskill practice routines, he still has a decent shot.

Well yeah, but that's only because Peach players' techskill practice routines are composed entirely of holding down on both sticks.

 

[john!]

aaand this thread got ****ty again

all of your guys' peaches would get dumpstered by a decent kirby... but there's only like 3 decent kirby players total

but i guess having no experience in the matchup has never stopped most of you from posting before...

 

[Xyzz]

My Peach won't get dumpstered by Kirbys. Bring 'em on, imma **** 'em up! :D

 

[Shiny Mewtwo aka Jigglysir]

My official Useless Post Tier List:

1. Max
2. The Business
3. Shiny Mewtwo

Seriously, The Business, you know that you can just like a post if you don't want to say anything?

Why am I on there twice and how do you know my na-

o wait you're talking about OTG

So many callouts. I need to see documented MMs at Apex to settle this forum salt.

I would totally MM Purpletuce if I was going to Apex

and if I was actually good at the game

and if I actually cared about stupid **** that happens on forums

 

[Purpletuce]

Note: I forgot about The Hooded Informant. Glad that he isn't back.

It would be interesting to see the relative skills of different posters. . . Unfortunately I don't think I can afford to go to Apex. . . Although if you guys ever want to hit up an Oregon/Washington tourney, I might be there. Down to MM anyone (although probably for 1$ at a time).

 

[ShroudedOne]

aaand this thread got ****ty again

all of your guys' peaches would get dumpstered by a decent kirby... but there's only like 3 decent kirby players total

but i guess having no experience in the matchup has never stopped most of you from posting before...

Decent Kirby beating a Peach =/= the matchup not being terrible. I haven't yet said that player skill isn't a factor here. It's the most important factor, and a very good Kirby can very well beat a Peach. A very good Bowser can very well beat a Sheik. But that says way more about the skill level of the players than it does about the matchup. No one here is saying "I'd beat the best Kirby easy." We're saying, "This matchup is probably piss awful for Kirby." Jeez.

 

[Shiny Mewtwo aka Jigglysir]

It would be interesting to see the relative skills of different posters

I'm going to attempt a tier list of people who posted on the last page (page 361, 40 PPP)

This will probably be extremely inaccurate after the first couple people.


Top Tier:
KirbyKaze
Kage

High tier
Strong Bad
knightpraetor
Sveet

Mid Tier
Bones0

I haven't heard of these people from a tournament results standpoint tier
MaxwellMouse
Ezzee
john!
V
Xyzz
ShroudedOne
Alcoholicsementhrower
Fourstar
Deathconsciousness
The Business

Australia tier
Grim Tuesday

Plays a crappy character tier
Purpletuce
Shiny Mewtwo aka JIGGLYSIR

 

[Bones0]

Well if we base it off of results (Likes), I'm clearly top tier.

 

[Grim Tuesday]

I always get lumped into Australia tier. This bites.

 

[Shiny Mewtwo aka Jigglysir]

Well if we base it off of results (Likes), I'm clearly top tier.

However, I have half as many likes as you with 1/4 the amount of posts. So on a pure like : post basis, I win

 

[Max?]

My official Useless Post Tier List:

1. Max
2. The Business
3. Shiny Mewtwo

Seriously, The Business, you know that you can just like a post if you don't want to say anything?

Lol, coming from you that is hilarious. Your posts are ****ing ******** 99% of the time.

 

[Bones0]

However, I have half as many likes as you with 1/4 the amount of posts. So on a pure like : post basis, I win

Likes didn't exist for the first 7 years I was posting, broski. Assuming the liking system began in February 2013 (it was around that time since I got my first one in late February), I have posted 1,052 times since then (omg lol), and you have posted 555 times.

Me: 684 likes / 792 posts = 86.36%
You: 372 likes / 555 posts = 67.02%

If you're gonna come at me, you had better come correct.

 

[Archangel]

I was insane to think this thread would have progressed at all since last year. I just didn't think it would sink to this point either. I mean....are we really at the point where we are arguing that Ness and Kirby Go even with or beat Peach? Really? ok.

you got it jimmy.

 

[Shiny Mewtwo aka Jigglysir]

Likes didn't exist for the first 7 years I was posting, broski. Assuming the liking system began in February 2013 (it was around that time since I got my first one in late February), I have posted 1,052 times since then (omg lol), and you have posted 555 times.

Me: 684 likes / 792 posts = 86.36%
You: 372 likes / 555 posts = 67.02%

If you're gonna come at me, you had better come correct.

If you're going to try and make up data at least keep your numbers consistent.

Using your first number:
You: 684 likes / 1052 posts = 65.02% :O
Me: 372 likes / 555 posts = 67.02%

Looks like I win

 

[Grim Tuesday]

I was insane to think this thread would have progressed at all since last year. I just didn't think it would sink to this point either. I mean....are we really at the point where we are arguing that Ness and Kirby Go even with or beat Peach? Really? ok.

you got it jimmy.

With the power of basic reading comprehension, you may find that not a single person suggested that Ness/Kirby go even with or beat Peach.

 

[Archangel]

With the power of basic reading comprehension, you may find that not a single person suggested that Ness/Kirby go even with or beat Peach.

Implied. it's like the legendary "soft counter" debates....why do people even argue characters who might as well not exist anyway?

Would it really hurt melee if Ness, Kirby, Pichu were deleted? Nope

 

[Zyskyoto]

You people are the reason the rest of the general competitive fighting game scene laughs at us.

 

[Zyskyoto]

Lol, coming from you that is hilarious. Your posts are ****ing ******** 99% of the time.

Likes didn't exist for the first 7 years I was posting, broski. Assuming the liking system began in February 2013 (it was around that time since I got my first one in late February), I have posted 1,052 times since then (omg lol), and you have posted 555 times.

Me: 684 likes / 792 posts = 86.36%
You: 372 likes / 555 posts = 67.02%

If you're gonna come at me, you had better come correct.

If you're going to try and make up data at least keep your numbers consistent.

Using your first number:
You: 684 likes / 1052 posts = 65.02% :O
Me: 372 likes / 555 posts = 67.02%

Looks like I win

kill yourselves

 

[Bones0]

If you're going to try and make up data at least keep your numbers consistent.

Using your first number:
You: 684 likes / 1052 posts = 65.02% :O
Me: 372 likes / 555 posts = 67.02%

Looks like I win

LOL Whoops, I miscounted the posts the first time and forgot to change them. Guess I'll just have to step my game up.

kill yourselves

u mad?

 

[Ezzee]

kill yourselves

No, people saying things like "kill yourselves" is what makes the general fighting game scene laugh at us

 

[Shiny Mewtwo aka Jigglysir]

kill yourselves

If the three of us killed ourselves this thread would become so much more boring though. Since I believe the purpose of life is to entertain people, killing myself would go against my beliefs as only an extremely sick ******* would get entertained by my death.

So sorry to disappoint you, though

 

[Divinokage]

If the three of us killed ourselves this thread would become so much more boring though. Since I believe the purpose of life is to entertain people, killing myself would go against my beliefs as only an extremely sick ******* would get entertained by my death.

So sorry to disappoint you, though

You can't entertain anyone by going to their levels, that's for sure.

 

[knightpraetor]

this thread is as hilarious as always. There have been so few useful posts on smashboards in the last two weeks, but at least the comedy hasn't died.

on a random side note, if you're a peach main it can be fun to play ness and abuse his djc and nair to basically play as a peach in the air with inferior range and followups. Pretty good handicap while still letting you practice peach related skills. ness's nair is so god tier!!~

 

[Ziodyne]

on a random side note, if you're a peach main it can be fun to play ness and abuse his djc and nair to basically play as a peach in the air with inferior range and followups. Pretty good handicap while still letting you practice peach related skills. ness's nair is so god tier!!~

funnily enough, a peach player CP'd me with his Ness last tournament I went to

sadly, it did not work out well for him

 

[Xyzz]

this thread is as hilarious as always. There have been so few useful posts on smashboards in the last two weeks, but at least the comedy hasn't died.

Are there EVER useful posts in this thread? :D

Also: There have been so few posts in the last two weeks period. Considering that the boards have just been up for one week and there really wasn't a "ohhh i need to get back and post that"-rush-thing that kind of makes sense, tbh

 

[Shiny Mewtwo aka Jigglysir]

You can't entertain anyone by going to their levels, that's for sure.

I can entertain people however I want tyvm

this thread is as hilarious as always. There have been so few useful posts on smashboards in the last two weeks, but at least the comedy hasn't died.

You're welcome

 

[Divinokage]

Only a fool attempts the same thing hoping for a different results, Shiny. You really think by saying the same low level jokes with people understanding the same thing will entertain them? Pfttt.... You need talent! You need to open their eyes to something more.

Entertainment is watching high level play, who would want to watch some random dude play?

 

[KirbyKaze]

I think XiF said it best.

"Ness is somewhere around used-jockstrap tier. His recovery is worse."

 

[Deleted member]

to be fair, using ness to cover your holes as a peach player is about as good as using kirby to cover your holes as a sheik player.

except i'm pretty sure that kirby is better than ness at this point.

and more fun. since winning occasionally is fun.

 

[Shiny Mewtwo aka Jigglysir]

Only a fool attempts the same thing hoping for a different results, Shiny.

I don't quite see how this statement applies to me tbh

 

[Zyskyoto]

u mad?

epic meme dude xDDD

If the three of us killed ourselves this thread would become so much more boring though

Are you sure?

No, people saying things like "kill yourselves" is what makes the general fighting game scene laugh at us

you act like me saying "kill yourselves" wasn't justified :|

 

[Shiny Mewtwo aka Jigglysir]

you act like me saying "kill yourselves" wasn't justified :|

You act like anybody telling anyone to kill themselves over the internet can ever be justifiable.

 

[Zyskyoto]

You act like anybody telling anyone to kill themselves over the internet can ever be justifiable.

but it was

 

[Shiny Mewtwo aka Jigglysir]

but it was

I'd love to see your justification for telling someone to kill themselves. You know, if they did kill themselves you might be able to be charged for murder (I'm not too sure on this, my research proved inconclusive).

 

[Ziodyne]

except i'm pretty sure that kirby is better than ness at this point.

Really now? What makes you say so?

It's not a particularly imperative question, just my curiosity getting the better of me.

 

[Ezzee]

but it was

Congratulations, you've been awarded the title of "average Internet troll." Claim your trophy at the door and leave. Forever.

 

[Shiny Mewtwo aka Jigglysir]

Really now? What makes you say so?

That came off as so sarcastic I couldn't help but laugh!

And obviously Kirby is better than Ness because Kirby is a pink circle, which means Kirby is Jigglypuff which means Kirby is 3rd on the tier list!

 

[Deleted member]

Really now? What makes you say so?

It's not a particularly imperative question, just my curiosity getting the better of me.

idk just a feel thing. kirby's neutral game is just less terrible because crouch and WD back abuse makes life harder for the opponent than anything ness can do.

i also can't beat chu's ICs with ness no matter how many times i play the match so maybe i'm a biased whore lol

 

[KirbyKaze]

to be fair, using ness to cover your holes as a peach player is about as good as using kirby to cover your holes as a sheik player.

except i'm pretty sure that kirby is better than ness at this point.

and more fun. since winning occasionally is fun.

i agree but only because sheik can transform into zelda

 

[pidgezero_one]

i heard there was a weiner in here whose name rhymes with "hiney mewtwo"