Official Florida Melee Power Rankings Discussion

[LadyLegion]

yeah but mine is ready ladies

ewie.........

 

[yummynbeefy]

well id say DEFINATELY have an honorable mention section if we really do this pissed me off back when they stopped doing that for brawl (dont care anymore obviously lol) but i think its a good way to see who else is close

 

[harriettheguy]

no

it will actually be a paragraph.

it would be the honor roll they give below honor roll...



Roll

 

[Anomic_Punk]

Rice for Tier-B/Top 10

The man is SO GOOD. <3

 

[XIF]

Y'all know that y'all lucky that I ain't there to bust up the tier list cause it'd have to be something like this:

S+++: XIF
S++:
S+:
S: hungrybox, dashizwiz
A: colbol, linguini

something like that

ps: linguini you better step your game up because here you come with a head the size of a blimp talking bout how **** you were at pound 4 and this person you ***** and whatever then I come in after not playing for months and tear you out the god d*mn frame in like 3 best if 5's in a row.

How embarassing.

 

[BBQ°]

****nn xif on that ivan ooze tier.

 

[hungrybox]

Y'all know that y'all lucky that I ain't there to bust up the tier list cause it'd have to be something like this:

S+++: XIF
S++:
S+:
S: hungrybox, dashizwiz
A: colbol, linguini

something like that

ps: linguini you better step your game up because here you come with a head the size of a blimp talking bout how **** you were at pound 4 and this person you ***** and whatever then I come in after not playing for months and tear you out the god d*mn frame in like 3 best if 5's in a row.

How embarassing.

saaaaaaaaaaaaaaaalt

 

[Linguini]

Y'all know that y'all lucky that I ain't there to bust up the tier list cause it'd have to be something like this:

S+++: XIF
S++:
S+:
S: hungrybox, dashizwiz
A: colbol, linguini

something like that

ps: linguini you better step your game up because here you come with a head the size of a blimp talking bout how **** you were at pound 4 and this person you ***** and whatever then I come in after not playing for months and tear you out the god d*mn frame in like 3 best if 5's in a row.

How embarassing.

Poor XAF, still salty after the past 3 tourney sets ive ***** you in. Talking **** is a nono you big baby.

 

[VSC.D-Torr]

well id say DEFINATELY have an honorable mention section if we really do this pissed me off back when they stopped doing that for brawl (dont care anymore obviously lol) but i think its a good way to see who else is close

LOL NO

who plays for second fiddle

*sigh*

the goal is to be in the ACTUAL PR

not be below the PR




and I'm the reason why there is no honorable mentions in the Brawl PR

for saying exactly what I wrote above

 

[Scidadle]

Lol polmex is on top FL smashers list.

He's pretty good.... I guess.

 

[VSC.D-Torr]

u mad?

 

[Scidadle]

Nah man. I beat his *** with mah link son.

 

[VSC.D-Torr]

Good ****

like that means anything

 

[XIF]

First off you are using salt completely incorrectly you can't be salty about beating the sh*t out if someone

second off Emilio is that you are missing the point

I own you.

 

[Renth]

XIF angry

XIF yell at pasta man

XIF want people think he good

XIF RaGgGgeEEeE

XIF :sad:

XIF Cry

Linguini -- doesn't care.

 

[Life After Death]

Y'all know that y'all lucky that I ain't there to bust up the tier list cause it'd have to be something like this:

S+++: XIF
S++:
S+:
S: hungrybox, dashizwiz
A: colbol, linguini

something like that

ps: linguini you better step your game up because here you come with a head the size of a blimp talking bout how **** you were at pound 4 and this person you ***** and whatever then I come in after not playing for months and tear you out the god d*mn frame in like 3 best if 5's in a row.

How embarassing.

colin is in the same leage as shiz and hungry LOL

 

[Pi]

colin is in the same leage as shiz and hungry LOL

Pretty much

Last I remember shiz wasn't beating Hbox where as colin was
And now at the very least if you look at the recent tournaments colin is performing no worse than shiz has, if not better, and still is bringing Hbox to last match last stock last set.
Though I think that shiz has been beating col bol in tourney sets the last times they've played
But yea, colin isn't losing to anyone but shiz and hbox, if he loses.
though skrach is puttin in work, i've seen their matches, shield = broken

 

[Linguini]

colin is in the same leage as shiz and hungry LOL

what about me, eh, eh?

 

[Scidadle]

Colin is super underrated.

 

[QDVS]

Colin isn't underrated...he ***** in state...he just has less impressive performances out of state as Shiz and Hungry!!!

 

[Эикельманн [РУС]]

Lol Mark.

Colin is amazing, but he lost to Eddy D:

 

[yummynbeefy]

yeah colin just needs to not choke and stuff and he would be SOOOOO much bettah

 

[SLyNKee]

Tippman for #1

 

[nicaboy]

• The vast land mass of Florida and isolation between regions hinders the effectiveness and accuracy of a numbered ranking system. Instead, I propose the use of tiered ranking system, as it better accommodates the indiscernible skill difference between forthcoming players in distinct regions.
  [*]For example: Plup and Nicaboy are both prominent players who place reliably well in their respective regions. However, the absence of interaction between CFL players and SFL players allows for very little accuracy when grading them against one another.​
• A tiered system overcomes the limitations of a numbers list in other regards too. Let’s say that player X beat player Y three weeks ago. But then player Y beat player X last week. Is it fair to say that Y is noticeably better than X just because he had the more recent victory? Or is it more likely that they are probably comparable adversaries? What specific purpose does a numbered system really serve? Tier approximations allow for higher accuracy and still accomplish the same goal of ranking players.
  .
• Also, the tiered rankings need to be a collaborative effort. I have lots of trouble gauging players from other regions, and so should everyone else. In order for Florida’s power rankings to be accurate statewide, there must be interaction between regions. If players don’t travel, the list will become undependable.

My rough list:
A: Colbol, DaShizWiz, Hungrybox, Linguini
B: Blea Gelo, Dark Sonic, Dop, Green Mario, Harriettheguy, Nicaboy, Plup, QueenDVS, RockCrock, Skrach, UberIce, UUAA
C: Apollo, Legion, Nasty, Raistlin, Zoro

And like Chops said, if you really want the rankings to be unbiased, just create a point scale for tournament results.

Honestly, I think Florida could do without power rankings. Anyone worth a dam knows where they stand. Ranking is a difficult process that often makes players uneasy and instigates petty disagreements. No thanks.

Great list man i like your system seeing as we dont play often against one another(sfl,cfl,nfl)

Um i believe me blea and flamin roy can be top 15 hungrybox. Both myself and blea have beaten several people in your personal 15. Any way i wanna promote good discussion i believe rockcrock here has the 2010 pr right here. someone make official.

 

[shalom]

Florida doesn't really need this. As Rock said if you're good you know it, and most likely so do other people.

 

[harriettheguy]

we should make a fake one to trip up OOS players

 

[VSC.D-Torr]

we should make a fake one to trip up OOS players

LOL

yummynbeefy for top 10

 

[yummynbeefy]

lol @ harriet and dtorr

thats actually a good idea i kinda wanna do that now haha

 

[PolMex23]

I respect that danny even included me...

Soo good that this job let me have saturdays off so

guess whose showin up soon? an alot

 

[PolMex23]

Nah man. I beat his *** with mah link son.

ill see you saturday///been a while since i **** on you

 

[VSC.D-Torr]

when we gonna play polmex

top priority **** next time

 

[nicaboy]

I would like to play harriet the guy. I hear good things about him. Again we should have a power ranking. All the good states have one tri state,socal. even north Carolina so wtf doesnt Florida( one of the best states for melee) have one? Teirs for the win imo

 

[Эикельманн [РУС]]

We don't have one because we're unique, and we understand that having a power ranking is pointless up to now.

AKA: We're smarter than them.

 

[nicaboy]

It promotes healthy competition. I love pr.

 

[Эикельманн [РУС]]

It also promotes pointless arguments. "Healthy competition" can be acquired from other sources.

 

[PB&J]

power rankings..fl is prob the hardest state to do power rankings in..sfl,cfl,and where ever rice lives..huh..i like chops ' idea

 

[VGmasta]

Look at the big brain on Dennis.

I wanna be on the tier list too.

 

[harriettheguy]

vgmasta is getting focus training from me

FL's sandbaggiest doc

 

[Pi]

I would like to play harriet the guy. I hear good things about him. Again we should have a power ranking. All the good states have one tri state,socal. even north Carolina so wtf doesnt Florida( one of the best states for melee) have one? Teirs for the win imo

I think I enjoy playing HTG more so than most, if not all, other smashers.

I feel like we're both trying to get inside of each other

's heads.

 

[bladeofapollo]

I think I enjoy playing HTG more so than most, if not all, other smashers.

I feel like we're both trying to get inside of each other

No homo.

But I agree, playing harriettheguy is like playing chess (which is tough, cuz he's good at it)