Alright alright guys, quit jerkin off to your favorite characters. It's quite biased actually with the fanboys and their giant sigs of their favorite characters...ugh.
Actually, I haven't seen anyone do that for a couple of pages. What bothers me a lot more is people posting whole tier lists which they should REFRAIN from doing.
Also people, do not post anything if you don't back up your statements.
Okay how about we do this instead: Let's agree with who Top Tier is RIGHT NOW and just get Top Tier outta the way. After Top Tier, let's move to high, then medium, then low, then last, but least, bottom tier.
This approach is a lot better since tier lists are made from top to bottom, which is brings us to the areas we can speculate on at this point: Top and high tier. Anything below that is ridiculously stupid to even think about if we don't even know the first two.
Characters that imo COULD be top tier - if you think otherwise, state WHY. (also contains characters I consider high tier but for the sake of discussion, I'm not telling who)
In selection screen order:
Marth
good overall, no glaring weaknesses but gets camped easily, he's Marth
Mr. GaW
quick, versatile, has strong smashes, massive improvement
Pit
can spam his arrows, has some nice moves, good aggressive edgeguard, great bair, good recovery if not left open to gimping
Meta Knight
counters many characters, quick, great priority, insane recovery, lacks finishers, nice edgeguard game to compensate.
Snake
powerful, nice range, lots of options, great explosives
Dedede
strong, good range, has some quick moves that raise his speed, can edgeguard from off of the stage like pit and meta
Wolf
fast, powerful moves, good approach, does not like being gimped but has a couple of ways to get around it
Toon Link
aerials combo into each other, great recovery, good projectiles
Olimar
nice combos, strong, great range, gets gimped easily
Lucas
wavebounce and zap jump greatly improve his game, powerful, good priority, good control
I'm in no way saying any of these is definite top tier or that these are the only ones who can be considered top tier (half of them are asking for high tier anyway). I'm just contributing to the discussion.