Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!
You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!
I'm not a fan of his current "ride the wagon" mentality. After one person moves, he feels free to move. Overall agree w/ Xonar.
Also, I do have a theory for Cello's behavior, and I will reveal it when the list is complete. Feel free to lynch me if I fail to do so.
Knowing what a player thinks is crucial towards scumhunting. If someone is constantly withholding information on their opinion, they probably have a reason. That reason is usually that they're too cautious to give their opinion in fear of being attacked or that they don't have an opinion. Scum, even though they know that the player they're talking about is town (unless they're indy), have to choose whether they want to make the leap and call the person scum, or hold back. Nick only asked for opinions from people of a yes or no question on whether or not they think cello is scummy. I don't see the problem.
You're wrong. Your example information does nothing to help town. How could the information he asked for be harmful to town moreso than it would harm mafia? You're suggesting that we keep quiet about Cello opinions. That's what's going to harm town, since it will give us too little information to scumhunt with (not just on who people think are mafia, but also who people think are town, based on their opinions on the person's viewpoint of Cello), leading town in the wrong direction.
No. I think I was clear with why I put a FoS, and an overall agreement with Xonar that TPK is acting iffy.
Knowing what a player thinks is great and all, but information changes. Worse still, the only people that can be punished for this information would be... town. No one with half a brain is going to say "omg he's scum" this early on and be expected to stick to it. It's why making a scum list is dumb. It does nothing but give people targets and freak some people the hell out.
Not quiet, just not Nicholas making a list of his own interpretation of what we think.
Cool story bro. Way to say "I dunno" in a paragraph while simultaneously making an effort only to piggyback on things already said. You didn't like the idea of him holding on the dragonballs scummy? Welcome to the party.
I'm gonna go ahead and throw out the fact that I'm not exactly "flying under the radar"; if anyone is, its you. That's kinda what you DO in mafia gamesSee OS? How does that harm town? I know I'm town, so when it comes to who I think is scummy or not, I have nothing to hide. Why do you? If it were your opinions on every single person, that I can understand, as it gives mafia a better pool to work with. But this isn't the case. But no, you don't have to tell anyone what you think about anyone if you don't want to, haha. Or if you think there's a good reason for you not to. Just don't expect to pass under any radars if you keep to yourself too much
Good job voting for a replacement.
There are no hydras in the game. Ronike forbids it.
If you're gonna ask us our opinion about something, it's best if you just...you know, let us fill it in. Doing it yourself defeats the purpose, not to mention you could easily twist around the words later on.
There's a legitimate reason why he hasn't said a thing.
Just wanted to bring this up: Telling us how many times you've voted for him and how much you think his plan sucks doesn't exactly make you cleared. The only way to clear you (and not even fully then) would be if you were on a Cello wagon that ended in a lynch flip Mafia. V_V
That's completely different and not what he asked for at all. Yeah, what you said does hurt town. Also, yeah, it would be better of him if he asked a specific person individually what they think of Cello.
When someone asks fourteen people the same question, there are going to be repeated answers, but not everything in that part that I posted was a repeat. I was giving him my opinion on the situation, for his list. Way to look at one part of the paragraph and brush off the rest.
lol good way of saying "no u"I'm gonna go ahead and throw out the fact that I'm not exactly "flying under the radar"; if anyone is, its you. That's kinda what you DO in mafia games
This I agree with. More than just yours, he ended up turning his "list of people's opinions" into what he saw of their opinions, which in turn, forced them to answer to fix it. Didn't like that.
Probably. But it will give us a better read on him at least. I'd rather play along.
No, it wasn't clear. You contradicted yourself and you're trying to get out of it with an "I think we all know what I really meant."
You wanna explain how that isn't clear?me said:
wait what?
Haha, yeah you're right it is. Dropping it now
Sure can, here you go.
This is Exhibit A, where I point out how you contradicted yourself.
This is Exhibit B, where you vote me shortly afterwards.
Most of this is fine, but TPK has not mass buddied Cello. What he did was he called Cello scummy and backed up on it when I put it in my list.
TPK had FOS'd me before you moved against me. Also, in his voting post he brings up a reason that you didn't.
(MetaKirby then FOS's TPK in the next post.)
Rockin told us his opinion on Cello's idea, and hasn't yet decided on Cello. I'll ask him again in another day or two. Don't worry, I won't let him slide on that. I do however, need to fix that in my list.
