I think Sakarai should abandon the hole "Apeal to all" thing he's got going and start thinking about who is really going to get in line on January 25 and Febuary 10. Us the true fans that have backed up the game through thick and thin. We who have played the previous instalments. Us the players of Smash Bros.
It's times like this I just want to sent angry letters to get whats best for us as a hole rather than people who are going to walk into BestBuy and ask whats the best game to get my son for the Wii, and come find out Super Smash Bros. Brawl is so non-violent that even five year olds can pick it up and say "Oooo.... this is easy." After beating Subspace Emisary on the hardest dificulty.
I posted this because I think Brawl is going to be too easy. And I think everyone will agree with me that hearing of a five year old Guitar Heroes expert, or an eight year old beating the legend of Zelda TP gives them fear of games becoming to easy.
Part of your post is good. Smash Bros already apeals alot to kids and newbies. Its a party game, it only contains kiddy violence, the controls are easy,(unless you go use all the advanced techniques) and most of all, alot of players that apeal to kids(especially Mario and Pokemon) make people buy the game for their children. But what Nintendo doesn't get is that most total moronic kids these days don't even know what they're doing. They keep looking at the controller to see where the dang jump button is, and have extreme trouble trying to hit their opponents, even if its a level 1 bot. They made it easier by making lots of similiar flat stages with platforms and of course more items that bring extra luck into the game. They also slowed down the game a bit and made it floatier, allowing for easier control AND for better air combos. But that was meant for newbies, not morons or total n00bs. N00bs and morons will try to jump of the cliff a hunderd times, and they get angry at the game for letting them lose even though they jumped off more than the rest. Then they destroy the game and ask their daddy's to buy a new one.
But newbies can adapt to the game easier like this, and can follow up. Owning your friends may be fun, but you should try to hold back a little bit and especially show of those advanced tricks to let them wonder "what did he do?". Don't tell them, but do try to make it obvious what it is and how you did it. If they know how to adapt to a fight, they will try the same, and get better that way too.
Remember, Brawl is extremely customizable, with as a main example the item switch. If its that slower than Melee, you can always make speed Brawl the default mode instead of regular Brawl. We don't have to worry a bit. In every game the one with more skill has an advantage over the ones with less. So it'll be with Brawl too. I'm even kinda glad wavedash is out.(coming from a wavedash user) It'll make games more fun to see. You saw alot of ground movements with the same animations in Melee, which made them boring to watch. Here you'll see things flying and see people making litterally *** kicking combos. And of course, its boring if people keep spamming stuff merely to win. I'll never understand the competive players, I guess, since its hard for me to stay serious longer than for 3 stocks. As soon as I'm front with 3 lives, I start to goof off, and I don't really care if that would cost me the match.