Guilhe
Smash Ace
I would say this stage is a counterpick against opponents with tether recoveries. For Ike, the boat is fine, the ascending is bearable (get defensive!), the pendulum is bad and the side-scrolling part is fine too (if the opponent does not CG).
Mushroomy Kingdom: Chain grab!
Rumble Falls: The scrolling speed and the stage shape make this stage too intrusive;Also how is a stage like Rainbow Cruise legal, yet Rumble Falls and Mushroomy Kingdom aren't? Aren't all those mentioned stages all side-scrollers?
Mushroomy Kingdom: Chain grab!