Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!
You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!
This doesn't deconfirm him though. Like Fatman said, the only deconfirmations are assist trophies, Mii costumes, and Sakurai saying that the character won't be playable. Again, "only 1 SE rep" is a fanmade rule.
Well, let's not forget, he loves Dragon Quest 3 as well.
Yeah, this can be a case of SE, once again, assuming that he'd go for a more recent character, only for mashpotato samurai to prove otherwise.
No I mean straight up tweeting to SE, NoJ, and NoA about being dissatisfied with their decision to have Erdrick over Geno.
You know that Eddy being in doesn't mean that Geno is out, right?
I feel like just making larger big pushes for Geno is much more in our favor than singling out a character as problematic. That’s a good way to get people to take you less seriously when you say the existing choice is the problem with Smash at least...
I don't think that would workout to well, for a multitude of reasons. The biggest of which is this all being leaked info, not official.
That as well.
What system do you play SMRPG with?
Any of em.
Thinking that SE got 2 characters in a pack limited to 5 when third party devs are foaming at the mouth to get representation in smash whereas SE is notoriously hard to work with is a huge assumption. I’d love it if he were to get in Wave 1 but it would be unprecedented. I’d love it if he were in or got in a wave 2 (which I’m not as confident about as other people are) but it makes more sense to be loud about Geno right now than sit idly by as he doesn’t get in again.
Enjoying the game and being dissapointed that Geno isn’t on aren’t mutually exclusive, m8. I have over 70 hours put in so far and don’t see myself stopping anytime soon just because Erdrick is in. I don’t think anyone here is saying SSBU is ruined because Geno isn’t in. We would just really like it if Geno was in the game.
Oh....I was going to request that you use restore points in Super Mario RPG on the WiiU VC. Well, that's the only way I was able to do it lol
It isn't that much of a stretch when you take in the fact that Geno is a Mario character. He represents the bonding of Nintendo and Square Enix rather than Square Enix. SE might just want a character to represent them, like, in this case, Eddy. Again, a reminder of the possibility of 2 SE characters, Geno and Cloud, being planned for Smash 4 DLC. And another reminder of the possibility of Nintendo buying Geno from SE
i dont think im obligated to continue to support a game that only has one character in it that makes me prefer it to its predecessors (if you dont count simple quality of life changes)
Yeah Geno does represent that bond for sure. That’s why he made sense for a SE rep. But that doesn’t make it more likely for SE to get another rep.
Eddy being in doesn't mean that Geno is in too.
Geno is a Mario character. I say he represents the bond of Nintendo and Square Enix because he is a Mario character made by Square Enix. He doesn't represent Square Enix.
I never said Eddy being in means that Geno is in, I was just saying that Eddy being in doesn't mean Geno is out.
Where the heck are claims like these originating from???
I'm saying a possibility, not fact. It's been discussed in this thread before.
Yeah man I get that those are possibilities. But just because things are possible doesn’t mean they’re probable. I’m just saying that with the information we have at this point that if/when Erdrick is announced and people are disappointed by it they should make themselves heard. If people would have rather SE chose Geno over Erdrick they should say so. There’s nothing inherently problematic with doing so. You don’t have to be a **** about it and say SSBU is ruined or that we’re owed Geno. Just pointing out that Geno (or really most other big SE names) were actually voted for and requested.
And just because they aren't probable doesn't mean that they won't happen. I said this before, but even if a SE rep gets in before Geno, I'm not giving up.
There's been absolutely no evidence that suggests such.
Fatmanonice
cited earlier. Which would gracefully contradict the notion of PP being some bonus that was orginally base content that got cut.Which is, again, why I am saying it is a possibility. It hasn't been proven that this isn't the case. That means it is a possibility.There's been absolutely no evidence that suggests such.
Speaking of which, the datamine has stats for PP that contradict the stats on that website that
Where do you get all that optimism at?
Or maybe there was no cut character to begin with.
Well, after seeing the Ridley and K Rool fans get what they want, especially after Sakurai said that Ridley would be impossible to add to the game and all of Nintendo's neglects of K Rool, its just made me want to not give up. Cause, if we give up, that's when it's really over. So I ain't givin' up, no matter what happens.
True. If there was one, I think it will be included as DLC, or it was just PP. We'll just have to wait and see though
It's less Erdrick being cool or uncool; and more "hey Nintendo was just fine paying a homophobic, bigoted war crime denier for his ****ty MIDI music loops"
Not this again. Do you ever stop being a total buzzkill, dude? Put that infinite amount of energy you're currently using to whine about DQ and putting genuine fans of a series down, and direct it towards operation Starfall.
There's no real optimism to be had when dealing with Geno vs Dragon Quest. Clearly only one is getting in.
Stop.
I have optimism over this, so clearly I must be lying to myself according to you.
Why is only one getting in? Some fanmade rule?
That's a fanmade rule. And, if Geno isn't in, we make our voices heard only about why we want Geno in the game, rather than a character being chosen over him.
We aren't "passively taking him". We're accepting it's not Geno and moving forward.
Sakurai loves DQ3. It has an important legacy. It is an iconic series in Japan. That does not sound that corporate to me.