http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IC-GcS0qSwU
posting this again so hopefully i can get some feedback.
Something I'm very uncomfortable with vs sheik is the neutral game. I mostly play it by instinct but I want to understand it better.Is dash dancing grabbing tilts feasible? It seems incredibly hard. I usually resort to run in and cc the tilts if they're spamming them into a waveshine grab.
Also some comments on how to improve my edguarding vs sheik would be cool too if possible.
Any feedback is appreciated!
Just out of curiosity, what did you strike for the neutral? Normally I'd ban FoD and Dreamland, but I assume you banned Battlefield or something?
To be honest, in the neutral, there's no reason to go on the offensive; you have a gun, so you can keep your lead and force Sheik's average approach by just SHLering. Especially on Dreamland, you have lots of room to work with to tack on extra percent. You ate a lot of ftilts from just running in trying to SHFFL nair.
Your edgeguards vs Sheik seem solid; standard ledgehog into onstage upsmash is perfectly fine. You did miss the timing a few times and got hit by the poof, but you were fairly consistent with it.
There were a couple of missed opportunities for shinespikes (2:20 and 8:00, Sheik can't do much if you're coming in at her from above for the shine), but overall you're solid when it comes to Sheik's recovery on stage. 3:15 probably should've been a shine too LOL but it worked out for you.
In terms of your out of shield game, iirc I only ever saw you shieldgrab or wavedash out of shield. Shine OOS and upsmash OOS are good options you should try to use, especially if he's doing unsafe stuff like ftilts and dash attacks (shine will hit behind you so even if the dash attack goes through you it should hit unless they space it perfectly).
You don't seem to go for up airs a lot off of up throw, you go for bairs a lot, which is odd since it kills Sheik fairly quickly especially on Yoshi's.
Your approaches were kind of one-dimensional, revolving around nair planing and dashdance --> grab, to the point it kind of got predictable in the neutral. There's no need to force approaches if you're in the lead IMO, though I understand playing lame isn't to everyone's liking. Doing stuff like dash shine (which you did a couple of times but rarely) and drills are ok too, or simply dash dancing until they crack is also a favourite of mine.
Hope this helped, it's hard to keep all this in mind and fight your natural instinct when you're actually in the game. I play a lot less intellectually when there's pressure, so I know the feels.
Though this is preference, I would've CP'd to Stadium for the lower ceiling; upairs and upsmash kills retardedly fast, and the stage transformations give you wall infinites if you're feeling gimmicky