JOJONumber691
Smash Lord
- Joined
- Sep 28, 2020
- Messages
- 1,791
Woo boy! Strap in! No hate from me either, but I got a lot to say about this point of view.
After Byleth and Pyra, controversy is likely the last thing that would stop any series from getting into Smash.
Are we really doing this? Aw, come on... controversy really doesn't matter. GTA and the series I'll mention here are way more than the controversies they've gone through.
Some series I mentioned like Mortal Kombat and Doom were both also very controversial yet you didn't mention them? Whatever.
- Pokemon has a whole Bublapedia page on its controversies.
- Metal Gear has had a few too. Here's one about some content in Ground Zeroes. We have this GZ version of Big Boss as a spirit in Smash.
- We got the Fallout Mii Costume yet Fallout 3 drew harsh controversy over in Japan. It isn't even sold in India.
Even with the DLC we've just gotten:
- Minecraft has had plenty of controversies because it's so popular too. There's even a top 5 video about Minecraft controversies such as the game being too violent for Turkey, Minecraft being blamed for a school violence case, or the creator itself.
- Final Fantasy has faced controversy with characters like Barret being seen as being problematic.
- Xenoblade 2 has its own design controversies. Some like the Pyra thing came back with her reveal.
What does it matter if GTA has been controversial to a few out-of-touch people, bad parents, and Karens? If Bayonetta was even half as popular as GTA, people would've actually burned her at the stake like in the Salem trials. The GTA series is popular, iconic, critically acclaimed, revolutionary, and a staple of pop-culture that could bring a lot to Smash.
Is there a "Controversial Meter" for Smash that I'm not aware of where Sakurai or Nintendo would be too afraid to work with Rockstar Games at all? If there was, they wouldn't be afraid to work with the GTA series considering:
Nintendo clearly doesn't care. A lot of the controversy in this series has either come from ignorance or is barely done in good faith. A lot of it is also drummed up usually because of how huge it is, people needing a scapegoat, or wanting attention.
- Rockstar Games has been on Nintendo consoles multiple times including multiple GTA games.
- GTA Advance is the only GTA game to be exclusive to one system.
- GTA Chinatown Wars for DS was initially revealed at Nintendo's E3 in 2008. You'd think they wouldn't say that out loud if they were so worried about GTA's controversies.
- Reggie was perfectly fine with still working with Rockstar during the Wii U era too.
- We got LA Noire on Nintendo Switch. An incredibly graphic Rockstar game that was considered successful so there's nothing really stopping Rockstar from working with Nintendo as of right now. GTAV is getting re-released again in the second half of 2021, A Switch port could happen.
Red Dead Redemption is another Rockstar title and you can do everything that really made GTA controversial, yet since it isn't as popular, it doesn't get all that parent-type controversy you see even something like Spongebob or The Simpsons get. Red Dead Redemption 2 sold more than every GTA except GTAV, yet by this point, it barely got any of the same outrage something like GTAV did. The only controversy GTAV has gotten in the past few years has been that GTAVI isn't out yet.
I bet if we did get GTA in Smash by now, the parental-outrage would be minimal if it even is there at all. No outrage-parent really knows the main characters anyway. If Nintendo was ever worried about parents getting angry for stupid reasons, they would've never added Bayonetta.
GTA. Let’s just say it’s as influential as it is because of Controversy. Not only that, but there’s a ton of Ratings Issues that could be very problematic! More specifically:
- Realistic Fire Arms that are still being sold today.
- The general theming as a whole. Sure, Persona 5 does something similar, but that’s WAY easier to tone down. Same with the Guns by the way.
- How do you get Vehicles, most of which licensed, into a Smash Moveset effectively?
- Same with the Cops.
- Most of the Music is Licensed, which is ABSOLUTELY a no-go after Steve got no C418 Music.
- Moveset without the Vehicles, Swearing, and Cops would feel very generic, even for an Archetype not explored much in Smash.
So on and so forth you get the picture by now. And this is why I think Red Dead is far more likely to get a character than GTA. Considering: - Realistic Fire Arms, sure, but these are also Outdated Fire Arms no longer in production.
- Doesn’t deal with Crime nearly as upfront as GTA. Still there, but less in your face than GTA.
- Horses, while still hard to figure out moveset wise (my idea is a Shopkeeper selling John this stuff, including Horses), they don’t require any Special Licensing just to allow into Smash.
- Cops aren’t nearly as involved in Red Dead as they are in GTA.
- Mostly original score.
- Still feels unique because Smash has never had a Gun Toting Cowboy before.
And that’s on top of keeping the Positives of GTA! Overall, now you know why I view Red Dead as more likely than GTA. Thanks for coming to my TED Talk!
Last edited: