Eh, it feels really selfexplanatory, people only know Ice Climbers as the duo from Smash and unlike other characters this applies to, they have nothing outside of it in terms of popularity. F Zero and Mother are cult classics, Pit was actually a pretty popular request for Smash, Star Fox used to be huge, etc. Ice Climber doesn't have this as everyone is able to recognize it's a ****ty game, so Nintendo's mindset would be "How much would people buy this potential revival if we actually made it?"
While I completely get
why Nintendo does this, I really don't like it. It mostly kind of infuriates me how they refuse to double-dip in terms of genres.
"You want a new F-Zero? Cool, here's the Blue Falcon in Mario Kart, stop asking."
"You want a new Advance Wars? Why? There's plenty of Fire Emblem to go around!"
"How dare you beg for a new Golden Sun! You'll eat your Pokemon remakes and you'll
like them!"
"Paper Mario
and Mario & Luigi? Two critically acclaimed fan favorites that have consistently sold well, with one franchise exclusive to our home consoles and the other exclusive to our handhelds? I suppose on paper that sounds like a winning combination that pleases a multitude of our fans, but...they're both RPGs? We
really can't have that."
Like,
objectively I understand that they don't want one of their franchises to compete with the other. But there's
got to be a better option other than letting that franchise's mascot join Smash while everything else about it just rots in the dirt, right?
Donkey Kong was almost exclusively an arcade-style series that was quickly being overshadowed by Mario and Zelda before Rare completely reimagined it. Pit was the retro rep of Brawl that fans were excited for because they saw what a great job Sakurai did bringing back the ICs, and he put so much thought and TLC into that character that his next project was a full blown sequel/reboot. Xenoblade Chronicles wasn't even supposed to be localized until fans begged Nintendo so passionately that their rallying cry got its own Wikipedia page. Fire Emblem wouldn't be the juggernaut it is today (at least outside of Japan) if it weren't for Smash.
And I think that's where I'm frustrated. Nintendo isn't even giving us the chance to show them how much we want to see older games get revived or rebooted. You say a new Ice Climber game wouldn't sell because the only thing we have to go on is a bad NES game, but that's only because Nintendo refused to give us anything else. Their inclusion in Smash put them on a lot of peoples' radar, with a design and playstyle that people really latched onto. The idea of controlling two characters at once
could be a fascinating way to play a platformer. But we'll never know because if Nintendo
were to experiment with that gimmick, they'd do it with Mario or Kirby.
Don't get me wrong, I'm
over the moon that Nintendo is working hard on creating new ips. Shulk/Pyra/Mythra, Inkling, and Min Min are all so unique in and represent successful risks that I haven't seen Nintendo take since Luigi's Mansion and Pikmin. Knowing that Splatoon was almost based around Mario characters makes me breathe a huge sigh of relief and be thankful for the timeline we're living in. It's fantastic and I really hope that they continue.
But I
also wish that they'd allow developers with a vision the opportunity go all out on reviving older franchises. If nothing else, Smash has reinvigorated fan love for these forgotten characters. I know Mario, Zelda, and Pokemon will always sell on name alone, but...a 2.5D Ice Climber, an RPG-esque F-Zero, a genuine sequel to Uprising, another stab at an action/adventure Star Fox, a revival of Murasame Castle or Joy Mech Fight or Kururin or Custom Robo. Slap any of those into your summer Direct, push a marketing campaign with a bit of effort, and Nintendo fans would get hype. Put actual effort into it and make it fun? You've got a hit on your hands with both brand new
and built-in audiences.
Whew...sorry, I think I had a stroke there...so much text...what were we talking about? Cowboys in Smash? I vote for Rusty, SteamWorld Dig is tragically underrated.