Yes there’s ALOT of revisionist history in the smash community, and it’s solely to justify the narrative that the community is always wrong in their predictions. it’s kinda weird imo bc smash reveals aren’t that difficult to predict if u pay attention:
for example the majority of ult newcomers were ballot picks, or sm4sh assist trophies. plus they literally told us chrom would be playable in the next installment
byleth and aegis were extremely obvious inclusions, same goes for an arms char lol everyone expected springman to be base roster
Lmao king boo is just another extremely obvious inclusion, but everyone is gonna say how “unexpected and unpredictable” it was right after he’s revealed
No see what you’re doing is exactly my point. Things are always obvious in
hindsight, but in the muck of it where dozens of characters have merit it’s hard to achieve the single-handed focus that hindsight hecklers demand of the community. Everyone had merit upfront, but once the first dozen of meritful characters are deconfirmed, the one that made it have the merit they had rewritten to be the most obvious ever.
Take King Boo. Yeah, sure, Luigi’s Mansion is a big deal and it didn’t have a Spirit Event, but what if the ball rolls the other way and we get one of the other dozen Mario characters who are similarly iconic?
Captain Toad was a huge deal during the ballot era and is a character that continues to persist, and is the acumulation of years of Toad appearances. Why did we miss him?
Paper Mario had a barebones Spirit Event, while none of the partners made it in as Spirits and only has a stage as noteworthy content despite being requested, having a subseries under his belt and loads of potential? Why didn’t we see him coming?
Waluigi is the star of the show right now, but even then the community isn‘t exactly banking on an AT promotion out of all the possible characters. That said, when it happens the question will be brought up: Why didn’t we see him coming?
Toadette and Pauline have been rising stars in the series. If you notice the pattern they follow in the series, how are they not considered the next Rosalina? How did we miss that? It’s just history repeating itself!
Every character is obvious when it makes it in,
after the cards are laid out and picked out of the deck of cards of even just its series, company or otherwise sub-grouping. Until then, forming a consensus on a not-too-big character group when there‘s thirteenhundred spirits alone? Not as obvious, predictable or easy as it seems.