If it's only the 2nd highest roof, go to the 1st highest stage. The risk of suiciding in the water is so high because of her ****ty jump.
The first highest is New Pork City. >_>
And honestly the water is WAY more of a boon to Peach than it is a disadvantage. Her second jump does not play a factor if she falls in the water. She jumps, then floats back. It's simple.
ALL the other characters are going to have a harder time though - due to their lack of instant, and I mean
instant, horizontal recovery.
All Peach has to go is knock them off, float above the edge ready to insta-gimp, and the water will do the rest (unless they can come above of course). Every other character has to knock her off, and then reengage in ledge combat as usual.
The sides are so close that you can die from all the top tiers so easily:
Reverse MK Up - B,
Snake F-tilt on either end platform,
Falco Spikes (or anything horizontal)
GnW d / f -smash..
All these are going to kill Peach anywhere. She is light and will die on the edge of
Battlefield from these moves. So the boundaries are no more of a danger to Peach as they are elsewhere - but they do help Peach due to one of her weaknesses: she can't KO. Suddenly her fair can kill 30% earlier, and coupled with the water, the stage basically kills for her.
..and because it's Falco's best stage, you will run into him a lot on it. It's just a stupid counter pick. If I don't get Smashville randomly, I'll counter-pick to there.
I'm still trying to figure out her best stages but it's certainly not JJ.
Did I mention that Peach's usmash, one of the top 5 strongest in the cast, kills everybody even
with the sky roof? The same can't be said about MK, Snake, Falco, or Game & Watch.
A good player wouldn't counterpick another character's best stage, even if it's their own. That would be a poor counterpick choice.
So, let me summarize. Jungle Japes:
- Compliments the float tremendously - a completly exclusive technique I'll remind.
- Postpones vertical kills
at her, but Peach's own KO's are unaffected.
- and allows her to KO more easily, one of her major flaws.
zelda's best stage is battlefield because the platforms give you a greater chance to bair/fair or uair them
feel free to disagree with me meno, but i feel that peach's worst stage has to be LC because the tilting kills your instant float and the ledges don't help either.
Hanenbow used to be her agreed upon "worst stage" - but seeing as that got hit by the ban hammer, I removed it. A vote for Lylat you say?