Okay, first of all, I like people to please disregard both post
No 345 and post
No.346 from Gustave, mainly cause he was replacing out and yet decide to post his 'final opinion' before posting, thus not giving the replacee much of an opinion. =/
Second of all, I reread the thread from start to finish and I'm going to post my opinion on things right now
Third, Gheb and Meta Kirby are meanie heads. >:O
*ahem*
At the first few post, I couldn't make out what Vult was really saying. However, that uncertainly soon moved to him being scummy. I generally disliked how he has posted early game.
Nonono. My post 81 explains it, kind of. But to better explain: I voted him because he seemed to completely disregard a gambit. I'd expect a Town player to consider it or perhaps even look into it further [like Overswarm did when I meta'd me!]. Disregarding it entirely gave me the impression that it was Scum jumping on an easy wagon under the guise of "he's useless. period. off with his head."
Okay fine. Frozen is my Neighbor.
Him claiming didn't ease things at all. This puts Frozen and Vult at a bad spotlight, as many has said that neighbors are a nerfed masonary. Usually, I disregard any 'n00b card' whatsoever, cause I've seen several of those 'noobies' turn to maf. However, after futher post, I'm start to see that as a dumb mistake on his part, and as soon given me a slight town feel. People such as Seph and Adub putting such pressure on something stupid has further my disinterest of lynching Vult.
So far, I see a town read on Frozen. The only beef I see with both Vult and Frozen is the fact that Vult slipped with the neighbor thing and that isn't going to be enough to lynch either of them IMO. Seph and Adub's questions about their roles is useless IMO cause, no matter what, we can't deduct if either are town or mafia till further on in the game.
I don't understand why Adub (or anyone) thinks Gheb is scummy. Throughout all his posts, I'm seeing him as town.
Constant pressure on Frozen's and Vult's neighbor makes Adub look scummy, not to mention I don't see too much from him. I want to also say that useless play' isn't scummy. Town and Maf could evenly do this. Look at SSBF on Super Smash Bros. Mafia
Overswarm needs to stop activity policing, as it doesn't contribute to town's cause at all. In terms of activity, I don't expect people to be constantly active, but people. Aside from that, I don't see anything majorly bad about him.
Sephy is one of those people that needs to stop focusing on Vults and Frozen's role.
I'm talking about how he hasn't posted between RVS and now, yet there are others who haven't. I'm just saying that you said KevinM was a great mafia player, and him being inactive is just a little suspicious considering it's the end of the day. But that can be said about all of them.
Erm, okay? everyone has a life, just like everyone else. Also, it seems that a lot of people has been posting a lot of content, so I'm not too surprised that peeps like KevinM got left behind.
On that note of massive posting, I'd like to see Dark_Ermac, Xonar, and Blue Yoshi to post more. They've kinda been left behind and I'm interested to hear what they have to say.
Vult & Frozen both mafia: neighborhood faked
Vult mafia: less likely now, after rereading and finding the explanation.
Frozen mafia: Possible, frozen has been here a long time, so has had time to improve his mafia skills. If he's mafia, he's doing good enough to convince Vult at least.
Neither mafia: Potentially all-town neighborhood, potentially 3+ neighborhood with at least 1 mafia, unless the GM is sadistic enough to purposely orchestrate an implosion of an all-town neighborhood as those involved attempt to uncover their "traitor".
In my opinion, I wouldn't want to vote either of them today unless something really bleeds through.
"Derp, I'm going to deduct the possibility that either or both are mafia. However, I will note vote cause I want to cover my ***."
Rei is the most bothersome IMO. Not only some of his post looked like he skimmed, but that same post completely contradicts with his post
no. 285 Not to mention he doesn't do a good job adding pressure to those he feel so. So far, I'm fine with going with either Adub and Rei
vote: Rei
Got some questions for some of you.
Xonar, Dark, Summoner, Blue Yoshi - as soon as you guys catch up with the game, who do feel is scum/suspicious?
Meta Kirby/Gheb - Why do you two feel the need to rid of me? I can't help but feel Gheb's was just a joke, but I gotta make sure
