Welcome, my fellow Doombros. Today I will be discussing the most fascinating leak from the last few months or so: the Cacomallow video and image leak! A leak that so far has not been debunked, and one which still remains a total mystery (for now). It is similar to the Grinch leak in that it not only includes hints for highly requested playable characters but also a scary amount of evidence going for it. One major difference between the two leaks, however, is that the Grinch leak was debunked almost the minute we saw those accursed furry eyes in the (let's be honest lads) extremely disappointing "final" Smash Direct from November 2018, yet Cacomallow still survives, despite neither of the two Smash presentations since it leaked helping its credibility (on a surface level at least).
Now, this mini-essay isn't going to discuss the credibility of the leak (if you want the quick version, I think it's still real), but rather a certain part of the leak, that being the Cacodemon hat/helmet itself. While most people would naturally jump the gun and assume this confirms that Doom Slayer is playable (which is very understandable), some people remained sceptical and came to the conclusion that either
- Doom Slayer would also be a Mii costume in addition to the Cacodemon, or
- The Cacodemon is the only piece of DOOM content that we'll be getting.
I'm here to tell you that options A and B are (most likely) not the case AT ALL. I say most likely because you can never truly know for sure, but I feel extremely confident in this, otherwise, I wouldn't be writing this.
To debunk option A, we have never gotten two BRAND NEW 3rd party Mii costumes from an unrepresented series in Smash, with two minor exceptions, those being the two Monster Hunter Mii costumes from Smash 4, as well as the Virtua Fighter costumes from Smash 4 which have also returned in Ultimate. I say those are minor exceptions because those costumes were from companies ALREADY WORKING ON/WORKING WITH SMASH, meaning negotiations for them were almost nonexistent and were likely already decided before the base game.
Before I get to my next point, I would like to bring up something that doesn't get talked about too much anymore, and that is the fact that the Cacodemon Mii hat in the leak is 100% ORIGINAL AND UNIQUE to any Cacodemon model we have seen before. This specific model hasn't been in any DOOM, Bethesda, or Id Software project before. Keep this in mind as we move into the second point, which is that some people assume that the Cacodemon Mii hat (if it is indeed real) will be the only piece of DOOM content coming to Smash. Watch as I destroy this silly little argument.
Picture this: you're Sakurai himself, or a representative of Nintendo (the ladder being more likely since Nintendo is calling the shots for Vol. 2, like with Vol. 1) who is going to negotiate with Bethesda/Id Software/Zenimax. You go to someone like Pete Hines and you say something along the lines of:
"Hello there Mr Bethesda man! We here at Nintendo would like to add content from your company in Smash. However despite having to travel all this way from Japan just to have this meeting, we do not want to add a character, but we just want to add a Cacodemon from Doom with a COMPLETELY ORIGINAL 3D MODEL. Not even the main protagonist of the game that people actually want as a playable character, but just a demon as a Mii helmet with (presumably) no music, and on top of all of that, it's not even a full costume, it's just a helmet".
I don't know about you, but that scenario sounds COMPLETELY RIDICULOUS! I know Sakurai and Nintendo may seem a bit tone-deaf at times (especially with Byleth's inclusion), but they still do listen to the fans quite often, and they know that a lot of fans want Doom Slayer, as he has been one of the most requested and talked about characters over the last two years, and support for him, as well as continued talk for him, along with the how the DOOM series has been growing to such a massive extent. Even if by some insane turn of events he did only add one DOOM Mii costume, it would be Doom Slayer himself, as that is the character that people want to play as, not the demon.
But even then, I highly doubt that will happen. We know that Sakurai has respect and is aware of DOOM's, as he literally mentioned John Carmack (DOOM series co-creator), and how said how he's the father of the FPS genre, and Sakurai himself is even into PC gaming, so the chances that he has played DOOM and is a fan of it are EXTREMELY HIGH. Even if Sakurai has no say in the process of choosing the characters at all, Nintendo would still recognize how big, and how important DOOM is, especially with the upcoming, and highly anticipated release of DOOM Eternal, arguably the biggest 3rd party game Nintendo has coming out this year, and surely Nintendo would want to capitalize on the game, and there's no better incentive for people to buy the game on Switch, other than adding Doom Slayer himself to Smash as part of the Fighters Pass Vol. 2!
So for that reason, and with the high requests as well as being one of the most talked-about characters, the only logical option for Nintendo and Sakurai is to add Doom Slayer as a playable character with a stage, music, Spirits, and a FULL set of Mii costumes, which is also what Bethesda would want, as they would make far more profit from a full-fledged challenger pack, as well as an inevitable Doom Slayer Amiibo. They would also definitely choose Doom Slayer as their rep in my opinion, since he is by far the most requested, has a new game coming out this year, as well having every DOOM game on Switch, which they would certainly want to capitalize on all that hype. They also would want something big to advertise DOOM Eternal on Switch, since it is coming out at a later date this year, and having Doom Slayer playable in Smash would certainly be insensitive for Switch players and Nintendo fans.
So in conclusion, I strongly believe that the Cacodemon Mii hat (and by extension the Mallow Mii hat) is most likely real, and is basically a dead giveaway that Doom Slayer will be a playable (possibly along with Geno) in one of the upcoming challenger packs, due to the reasons stated above. Thank for taking the time to read this Doombros, I really appreciate it.