• Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!

    You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!

Argue YOUR final roster!

Brawlmatt202

Smash Champion
Joined
Feb 6, 2007
Messages
2,997
Location
Pittsford
This is actually pretty hard. I mean, I know who I want in it, but I never actually thought of a final roster...

I guess it would go something like:

1. Mario
2. Luigi
3. Peach
4. Bowser
5. Toad
6. Bowser Jr.
7. Yoshi
8. Baby Mario Bros.
9. Donkey Kong
10. Diddy Kong
11. Link
12. Zelda (maybe with Sheik)
13. Ganondorf
14. Vaati
15. Tingle
16. Pikachu
17. Jigglypuff
18. Mewtwo
19. Deoxys
20. Lucario
21. Kirby
22. Meta Knight
23. King Dedede
24. Wario
25. Waluigi
26. Fox McCloud
27. Falco Lombardi
28. Kyrstal
29. Wolf O'Donnell
30. Samus/Zero-Suit Samus
31. Ripley
32. Marth
33. Ike
34. Ness
35. Ice Climbers
36. Pit
37. Mr. Game & Watch
38. Stafy
39. Solid Snake
40. Sonic the Hedgehog

That's how I see it, I think... Imean, I said this was hard for me.
 

Meta_Owns_Ur_Dad

Smash Ace
Joined
Mar 1, 2007
Messages
697
Location
Pennsylvania
this is GOING to be the final roster (well, if ninendo wants brawl to own.) lol j/k

1. Mario
2. Fox
3. Pickachu
4. Kirby
5. Link
6. Samus/Zamus
7. Metaknight
8. Wario
9. Snake
10. Pit
11. Captain Olimar
12. Sonic
13. Geno
14. King Dedede
15. Mii
16. Luigi
17. Bowser
18. Peach
19. Toad
20. Zelda/Sheik
21. Ganondorf
22. Ridley
23. Vaati
24. Jigglypuff
25. Megaman
26. Deoxys
27. Some Pokemon from Diamond and Pearl or whatever.
28. DK
29. Diddykong
30. Wolf
31. Yoshi
32. Marth
33. Ike
34. Petey Phirana
35. Captain Falcon
36. Ice Climbers
37. Mr. Game & Watch
38. Zant
39. Krystal
40. King K. Rool

That is the BEST roster... IMO lol.

EDIT: oops, i didnt mean to type best moveset lol srry.
 

DJ Napps

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Mar 7, 2007
Messages
291
Location
Howard U
Everyone confirmed and Melee except the clones. Dr. Mario will be costume for Mario.

Boo (ghost)
Bowser Jr.

Bomberman!!
Sonic (including Knuckles/Tails as partners)(Shadow as costume)
Rayman
Captain Olimar


I would list others but i know only 2-4 will make it.
 

ClarkJables

Smash Lord
Joined
Mar 17, 2007
Messages
1,669
Location
Texas
my list is this, it's 41 characters total-
- the 26 characters from melee minus roy, pichu, and dr. mario
-the confirmed new characters (wario, metaknight, Zamus, snake, and pit)
-the nintendo characters i want (Fawful, diddy kong, king dedede, gooey, samurai Goroh, stafy, little mac, balloon fighter, kamek with yoshi symbol, deoxys, and a FE character that doesn't use a sword, preferably one with an axe or spear/lance.)
-third party characters i want (bomberman OR master higgins)
-third party characters that i don't care if they make it or not (sonic OR geno)
 

Luminitrium

Smash Cadet
Joined
Mar 18, 2007
Messages
54
Location
Reading, MA. ._.
1. Mario
2. Fox
3. Pickachu
4. Kirby
5. Link
6. Samus
7. Metaknight
8. Wario
9. Snake
10. Pit
11. Vaati
12. Zelda
13. Ganondorf
14. Roy
15. Marth
16. Luigi
17. Peach
18. Bowser
19. Ike
20. Sonic
21. Megaman
22. Ridley
23. Jigglypuff
24. Ice Climbers
25. Krystals
26. King Dedede
27. Captain Falcon
28. DK
29. Pikachu
30. Wolf
31. Yoshi
32. Falco
33. Ike
34. Zant
35. Geno
36. Bomberman
37. Ephraim
38. Y. Link
39. Joshua (FE)
40. Captain Olimar

~Whistles innocently~
 

LostAddict

Smash Apprentice
Joined
Oct 14, 2006
Messages
109
No one's arguing their rosters, they're just listing them. =(
Anyways firstly, remove Roy, Pichu, Dr. Mario and Young Link. They just didn't provide enough, nor were they interesting enough characters to be included in my opinion.


1. Mario
2. Luigi
3. Peach
4. Bowser
5. Toad -Yes, Toad. I just reallly love him. He's one of the "Big 8" and I think he deserves it.
6. Bowser Jr. - Also Bowser Jr. I think he would be a really interesting character to play as, with paint-staff based combat.
7. Yoshi
8. Wario
9. Geno - I think he would rock a lot as well. Plus everyone's like begging for him.
10. Donkey Kong
11. Diddy Kong - He deserves it. The Donkey Kong franchise needs more rep, and he's the perfect person to fill it.
12. Dixie Kong - I think the Donkey Kong franchise needs at least three people to represent it, so she's the next in line. Plus more female characters are always great!
13. Link
14. Ganondorf - totally revamped, whole new moveset
15. Midna - She'd be a cool character, and she was incredibly awesome in Twilight Princess. She would come without wolf Link cause I think she could hold her own.
16. Zelda with Sheik - Why take away a great aspect of her? If anything, nerf Sheik a little, and bump Zelda a little so they're closer matched. That way her transformation would be used a lot mroe often.
17. Pikachu
18. Jigglypuff
19. Mewtwo - revamped to be a lot better. He's supposed to be the ultimate pokemon, so he should be better.
20. Munchlax - I like this pokemon? My ultiamte pokemon would be exploud, but I know that will never happen so I'll settle for this.
21. Kirby
22. Meta Knight
23. King Dedede
24. Captain Olimar - His pikmin based combat would prove entertaining, to say the least.
25. Ice Climbers
26. Fox McCloud
27. Falco Lombardi
28. Kyrstal - Her staff-based combat would probably rock a lot.
29. Wolf O'Donnell
30. Samus/Zero-Suit Samus
31. Ridley
32. Marth
33. Ike
34. Mikaya - (FE10) If not her then Sothe. I think both of them would prove interesting because she would use magic as a primary weapon, which is a bit different than all other characters (excpet for Zelda) where as Sothe would use knives, therefore closer combat.
35. Pit
36. Mr. Game & Watch
37. Tom Nook- I think one of his moves should be furniture throw, he throws one of those bitten leafs, and then it turns into a piece of furniture in midair. Imagine trying to recover only to be hit by a couch. It would rock.
38. Solid Snake
39. Bomberman - I think throwing bombs around would be wiked fun. And really chaotic. Imagine a free for all with four bombermans, explosions everywhere!
40. Sonic the Hedgehog - C'mon. Mario vs. Sonic? Who doesn't want this?
 

martyrofevil

Smash Cadet
Joined
Feb 25, 2007
Messages
31
Location
Hamilton, Ontario
1. Mario
2. Link
3. Kirby
4. Pikachu
5. Samus
6. Metaknight
7. Wario
8. Snake
9. Fox
10. Z. Samus
11. Pit
12. DK
13. Luigi
14. C. Falcon
15. Ganondorf
16. Doc. Mario
17. Marth
18. Bowser
19. Jigglypuff
20. Ness
21. Game & Watch
22. Zelda/Shiek
23. Roy
24. Peach
25. Yoshi
26. Earthworm Jim
27. Balloon Fighter
28. Waluigi
29. Hammer Bros.
30. Megaman
31. Banjo & Kazooie
32. Pacman
33. Cloud or Sephiroth - now I'm just taking up space
34. Baby Mario/Baby Luigi (1. char.)
35. Diddy Kong
36. Lanky Kong
37. King Dedede
38. Birdo
39. Parakoopa
40. Waddle Doo
41. Ice Climbers
42. Knuckles
43. Marowak
44. Mii
45. Ridley
46. Rayman - I hate Rayman with a passion but he would probably be good
47. Simon Belmont - Castlevania sucks!
48. Yo-Noid
49. Kilik (from SC) - they need someone with a staff
50. Dry Bones
51. Parakoopa
52. Rawk Hawk
53. Boo
54. Bowser JR. (from Mario Sunshine)
 

Meta_Owns_Ur_Dad

Smash Ace
Joined
Mar 1, 2007
Messages
697
Location
Pennsylvania
1. Mario
2. Link
3. Kirby
4. Pikachu
5. Samus
6. Metaknight
7. Wario
8. Snake
9. Fox
10. Z. Samus
11. Pit
12. DK
13. Luigi
14. C. Falcon
15. Ganondorf
16. Doc. Mario
17. Marth
18. Bowser
19. Jigglypuff
20. Ness
21. Game & Watch
22. Zelda/Shiek
23. Roy
24. Peach
25. Yoshi
26. Earthworm Jim
27. Balloon Fighter
28. Waluigi
29. Hammer Bros.
30. Megaman
31. Banjo & Kazooie
32. Pacman
33. Cloud or Sephiroth
34. Baby Mario/Baby Luigi (1. char.)
35. Diddy Kong
36. Lanky Kong
37. King Dedede
38. Birdo
39. Parakoopa
40. Waddle Doo
41. Ice Climbers
42. Knuckles
43. Marowak

normally, that list would be crap, but the

33. Cloud or Sephiroth

made it Horrible! MY LIST OWNS! haha j/k, but not really.
 

LuCKy

Smash Master
Joined
May 30, 2006
Messages
3,214
Location
norwalk,CA
yes finally i can let out my feelings..........................lol anyway

1.mario
2.luigi
3.vacum luigi
4.bowser
5.bowser jr
6.peach
7daisy
8.yoshi
9.dk
10.diddy kong
11fox.
12.falco
13.fox's brother (forgot his name)
14.ic's (aka god tier)
15. a new charecter from ic series
16.samus
17.zero suit smaus
18.ridley
19.link
20 young link (from majoras mask with speacial to become oni link)
21.zelda/shiek
22.pikachu
23scizor
24lucario
25.pit
26.kirby
27.meta knight
28.king dee dee
29.marth.
30.roy
31.sonic (aka god tier)
32.shadow
33.megaman x
34.megaman zero
35.bass exe (aka god tier)
 

kmokmo

Smash Cadet
Joined
Nov 30, 2006
Messages
72
Location
poking dead things with a stick
well here's mine

1. Mario
2. Luigi (cause he's awesome)
3. Peach
4. Bowser
5. Toad (he deserves it he's been in most if not all mario games)
6. Link
7. Zelda/Shiek (i dont care if zelda is in her TP form sheik still deserves to be in)
8. Gannondorf
9. Skull kid (wearing the mask of course)
10. Kirby
11. Meta Knight
12. King Dedede (He's a penguin, nuff said.)
13. Pikachu
14. Jigglypuff (shes been in every smash so far)
15. Mewtwo (with a moveset change of course)
16. Dragonite (he could be very unique)
17. Samus/Zamus
18. Ridley (been in alot of metroid games and deserves a spot)
19. Fox
20. Falco (with a luigified or tottaly new move set)
21. Krystal
22. Wolf
23. DK (he's classic)
24. Diddy Kong
25. Yoshi
26. Kamek (he's one of yoshi's main enemies and is very unique)
27. C. Falcon
28. Samurai Goroh
29. Marth
30. Ike
31. Lyn (I know 3 FE chars is pushing it but hey)
32. Mach Rider
33. Captain Olimar
34. Mii
35. Baloon Fighter (he's just too awesome to not get in)
36. Stafy
37. Simon Belmont
38. Solid Snake
39. Sonic
40. Mega Man.
 

yugi9267

Smash Cadet
Joined
Mar 7, 2007
Messages
36
Location
Quebec
every characters from melee should return, i dont care if there game are modified.
the comfirmed characted should be in.
Yoshi should become the best character for brawl. ( for he is the best for melee)

1 Boo
2 Geno
3 Sagi
4 Isaac
5 King K.rool
6 Diddie
7 Wolf
8 Crystal
9 Ike
10 Sophitia ( character from soul caliber 2. it should make a surprise)
11 Koopa Kid
12 Banjo and Kazooie


this shouldd be perfect
 

Kalmetam

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Feb 23, 2007
Messages
282
Location
alphace area L
I put a ton of thought into this.... Ok, here it goes...

1. Mario
2. Luigi
3. Wario
4. Waluigi
5. Peach
6. Pit
7. C. Falcon
8. Snake
9. Fox
10. Krystal
11. Falco
12. Metaknight
13. Kirby
14. King Dedede
15. Ganondorf
16. Link
17. Zero Suit Samus
18. Samus
19. Ness
20. Marth
21. Sonic
22. Tails
23. Shadow
24. Knuckles
25. Amy
26. Game and Watch
27. Bowser
28. Koopa Kid
29. Ice Climbers
30. Polar bear (in the icicle mountain stage in melee)
31. Ripley
32. Megaman
33. Balloon Fighter
34. Deoxys
35. Kyogre
36. Groudon
37. Pikachu
38. Daisy
39. Zelda
40. Shiek
 

Kunitsuna

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Feb 16, 2007
Messages
257
Liek new roster!

01. Mario
02. Luigi
03. Peach
04. Bowser
05. Bowser Jr. *
06. Shadow Mario *
07. Geno
08. Yoshi
09. Donkey Kong
10. Diddy Kong
11. Wario
12. Kirby
13. Metaknight
14. King Dedede
15. Pit
16. Link
17. Young Link
18. Zelda
19. Ganondorf
20. Vaati
21. Ness
22. Kumatora
23. Pikachu
24. Jigglypuff
25. Mewtwo
26. Pichu
27. Deoxys
28. Lucario
29. Captain Falcon
30. Samus *
31. Zero-Suit Samus *
32. Ridley
33. Marth
34. Ike
35. Micaiah
36. Fox
37. Falco
38. Krystal
39. Ice Climbers
40. Mr. Game & Watch
41. Takamaru
42. Captain Olimar
43. Sonic (Third Party - SEGA)
44. Snake (Third Party - Konami/Kojima)
45. Mega Man (Third Party - Capcom)

Characters with asterisks transform into/form another character.
 

sHy)(gUy

Smash Ace
Joined
Jan 28, 2006
Messages
558
Location
Metairie LA
1. Mario
2. Pikachu
3. Kirby
4. Link
5. Fox
6. Metaknight
7. Zamus
8. Wario
9. Pit
10. Snake
11. Luigi
12. Peach
13. DK
14. Yoshi
15. Capt. Falcon
16. lucas
17. Marth
18. Zelda/sheik
19. Ice Climbers
20. Geno
21. midna
22. Poo
23. King Dedede
24. Capt. Olimar
25. Ray MK2
26. Diddy
27. Ridley
28. Lucario
25. Sonic
26. Krystal
27. Ike
28. claus
29. Mewtwo
30. Mr. Game and Watch
31. Falco
32. Bowser
33. Ganondorf
34. Jigglypuff
35. pokemon trainer
 

K4M1K4Z3

Smash Cadet
Joined
Apr 13, 2007
Messages
33
the 26 from melee, the newcomers, and sonic and megaman among others that im to lazy to type
 

Tera253

Smash Ace
Joined
Jun 5, 2006
Messages
866
Location
Spamland
one glorious word, y'all: Lyn.
2. maybe Krystal

other than that, it's mostly who Tera does NOT was to see.

(this topic should totally be stickied)
~Tera253~
 

Sculelos

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Aug 23, 2005
Messages
496
Location
Wyoming, USA
Well my list would include...all returning chars except for doc, young link, roy, pichu and sheik, so that brings us the first 21

Add- the confirmed chars.

22)Zero Suit Samus
23)Wario
24)Pit
25)Meta-Knight
26)Snake

And then the Newcomers

27)Wolf
28)Krystal
29)Ridley
30)Diddy Kong
31)Bomberman
32)Sonic
33)Megaman
34)Geno
35)Samuri Gorah
36)Ike
37)Black Knight
38)Lucario
39)Midna
40)Simon Belmont
41)Captain Olimar
42)Mii
43)Paper Mario

Any other chars I would take but wouldn't mind if most of my newcomer list is missing.
 

Nephane

Smash Rookie
Joined
May 29, 2007
Messages
1
Ok, so here we go.

Melee-ers to Retain
-----------------------------
1. Mario
2. Yoshi
3. Luigi (maybe continue to mess with his moveset a little)
4. Peach
5. Bowser (just makes him better)
6. C. Falcon
7. Link (will they mess around with a wolf from from Twilight Princess?)
8. Zelda/Sheik (Prolly as seperate Characters)
9. Ganondorf (sword moveset, w/e, just don't make him a clone again)
10. Fox
11. Falco (luigify please)
12. Samus
13. Pikachu
14. Jigglypuff
15. Mewtwo (he's a cool character and just needs to be rebuilt from the ground up)
16. Kirby
17. Ness
18. DK
19. Marth (because they basically said Roy won't be back)
20. Ice climbers (they can be made better, but they're an intersting idea)

That means I'm cutting
Roy, Pichu, Young Link, Dr. Mario (alternate costume?), and Game & Watch.

Then the confirmed newcomers
---------------------------------------

21. Snake
22. Pit
23. Wario
24. Zero Suit Samus
25. Meta-Knight

So FInally onto my Picks
------------------------------

Mario franchise needs no one else, neither does the Legend of Zelda, or even Pokemon for that matter.

26. Wolf O'Donnel, because Krystal is so boring. Wolf could have a cool moveset
27. Sonic, no more needs to be said
28. Knuckles, because I think hes more of a bada** than Tails
29. Megaman, and if all goes well he won't end up like Samus
30. Ridley, cuz man he just cool
31. Ike, because he's just a shoo-in
32. Hector, because he was the best Lord of the first American Fire Emblem, and has an axe
33. Lyn or Ephraim from FE (I'm a Fire Emblem fanboy so cut me some slack), they both could have interesting movesets with the spear/Katana styles.
34. Diddy Kong, because he's cool and has a jetpack =D
35. Dedede, I really think Sakurai has been dying to put him in
36. Bomberman (if you can come up with a decent moveset)
37. Samurai Goroh (he seems to have a lot of support so what the heck?)
38. Either Isaac or Felix from Golden Sun because it needs some representation
39. SOME FINAL FANTASY CHARACTER, because they're bound to be worked in. Cloud is most liekly with maybe Sephiroth as a sort of Giga Bowser sorta boss?
40. And finally YODA because man hes a bad@$$ and a good WTF character.

Nephane
 

RWB

Smash Ace
Joined
Jan 28, 2006
Messages
969
Melee-ers to Retain
-----------------------------
1. Mario
2. Yoshi
3. Luigi (make him less cloney)
4. Peach
5. Bowser (make him better)
6. C. Falcon
7. Link
8. Zelda(Remove Sheik, if she have a transformation, Tetra is the way to go)
9. Ganondorf (sword moveset)
10. Fox
11. Falco (luigification)
12. Samus
13. Pikachu
14. Jigglypuff
15. Mewtwo (he's a cool character and just needs to be rebuilt from the ground up)
16. Kirby
17. Ness
18. DK
19. Marth
20. Ice climbers
21. Game & Watch.

That means I'm cutting
Roy(No reason for him to stay with a boatload of other FE lords with swords and more popularity), Pichu, Young Link, Dr. Mario (alternate costume?), and Sheik.

Then the confirmed newcomers
---------------------------------------

22. Snake
23. Pit
24. Wario
25. Zero Suit Samus
26. Meta-Knight

So FInally onto my Picks
------------------------------
27. Paula(Earthbound)
28. Adeleine (from the Kirby series)
29. Vaati.
30. Tetra, either as a transformation or as a character of her own.
31. Ike, because he's just a shoo-in
32. Midna
33. Eliwood with the Durandal(I hate Cloud, so Eliwood is my choice for a Bihänder user)
34. Hector
35. Sigurd with a lance style (I dislike Ephraim)
36. Sigurd with the Tyrfing
37. Lyn or Eirika
38. Diddy Kong
39. Dedede
40. Krystal
 

Erk Aduro

Smash Apprentice
Joined
Aug 13, 2005
Messages
122
Location
Somewhere over the rainbow presumably.
Yellow = confirmed, Green = Melee, Orange = possible newcomer, Red = not bloody likley.

1. Mario (Perhaps with Doc as a costume)
2. Luigi
3. Bowser (Could use some improvement)
4. Peach (Her fighting should involve her parasol more as it's become more prominent in recent games)
5. Wario
6. Yoshi
7. Donkey Kong
8. Diddy Kong
9. Captain Falcon
10. Samurai Goroh (Since everyone likes him so much and he looks fun)
11. Fox
12. Falco (Perhaps Luigified, which may or may not irk some Falco users :p)
13. Wolf O'Donnel
14. Krystal (Some people may not like her, but her staff would make for an interesting addition)
15. Ness
16. Paula
17. Jeff
18. Poo
19. Ice Climbers
20. Kirby (Un-nerfed ;))
21. Meta Knight
22. Dedede
23. Samus
24. Zero Suit Samus
25. Ridley
26. Zelda (With her Twilight Princess appearance and moveset based off of recent Zelda games)
27. Link
28. Young Link (With his Wind Waker appearance and a moveset based off of recent games Zelda games. I'll get into a rant about him after the list)
29. Ganondorf (With a moveset inspired by recent Zelda games and his appearance based off of Twilight Princess)
30. Midna (Imp form or true form, whichever is more interesting)
31. Skull Kid (With Majora's Mask. In my opinion, this would be AWESOME)
32. Pikachu (Unfortunately, I can't really see them Luigifying Pichuand there are lots of more deserving Pokemon that could take his place)
33. Jigglypuff
34. Mewtwo (With a complete overhaul to make him less unweildy to play)
35. Blaziken (I Like Blaziken)
36. Legendary Pokemon (Lucario seems to be the most popular)
37. Mr. Game and Watch
38. Marth (He's the main protagonist of the first Fire Emblem game. He's too important to the history of FE to get rid of)
39. Ike (First Lord in a 3D Fire Emblem)
40. Lyn (I really like Lyn :D)
41. Pit
42. Snake
43. Sonic
44. Dr. Ivo Robotnic (He was fighting Sonic before Tails, Knuckle, or any of the other side kicks showed up. I just hope they use his old appearance instead the rather freaky looking one in the most recent Sonic game on the XBox)
45. Mega Man (Classic, not X)

Nothing new or original, but I'm not terribly creative anyway. :p This is all really just a dream list. Take it as you will.

Okay, here's my pissy little rant about Young Link. First of all, it's Wind Waker Link. Not Celshaded Link or Celda Link. Being cel-shaded is NOT INHERENT TO HIS CHARACTER. It's a method of rendering 3D models so they look handdrawn. They used that artsyle as it captured the feeling Miyamoto wanted for the game. If he was put in the Super Smash Bros Brawl they DON'T HAVE TO CEL-SHADE HIM. I wouldn't care either way, but characters like Ness, Ice Climbers, and hell even Mario show that characters who are cartoony can be put into Brawl.

Second of all, the Wind Waker style has been used for Winder Waker, Four Swords, Minish Cap, and Phantom Hourglass. Four games to gather moves from. He needn't be a clone. Though, honestly I don't really have a problem with clones anyway. :p
 

NukeA6

Smash Master
Joined
May 17, 2002
Messages
3,103
Here's my updated roster:

Mario Series:
1. Mario
2. Luigi
3. Peach
4. Bowser
5. Bowser Jr. / Toad


Zelda Series:
6. Link
7. Zelda
8. Ganondorf
9. Vaati
10. Midna / Tingle / Any other Zelda character


Kirby series:
11. Kirby
12. Metaknight
13. King Dedede


Pokemon series:
14. Pikachu
15. Jigglypuff
16. Mewtwo
17. Lucario


Mother Series:
18. Ness
19. Lucas


Fire Emblem Series:
20. Marth
21. Ike
22. Black Knight
23. Ayla / Any character that doesn't use a sword


Star Fox Series:
24. Fox McCloud
25. Falco Lombardi
26. Krystal


F-Zero Series
27. Captain Falcon
28. Samurai Goroh


Metroid Series
29.Samus (plus Zero Suit Samus)
30. Ridley


Donkey Kong Series
31. Donkey Kong
32. Diddy Kong


Other Series
33. Wario
34. Yoshi
35. Pit
36. Tatsumaru
37. Olimar
38. Stafy
39. Ice Climbers
40. Mach Rider
41. Lip
42. Balloon Fighter


3rd Party Characters
43. Snake
44. Sonic
45. Simon Belmont / Geno / Megaman
 

Kunitsuna

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Feb 16, 2007
Messages
257
My character list. Please comment!

Super Mario Bros.
01. Mario (Dr. Mario would appear as an alternate costume)
02. Luigi (Given more electric-themed moves to further separate him from Mario)
03. Peach (Parasol is replaced with the SPP one, and her B-move could be emotion-based)
04. Bowser (Essentially unchanged--SSBM captured Bowser´s personality quite well)
05. Bowser Jr. (Ambassador for the party games, not a Bowser clone in any regard)
06. Shadow Mario (Transformation of Bowser Jr., uses E. Gadd´s brush; not a Mario clone)

Yoshi´s Island
07. Yoshi (Carries a different baby from YI with each costume, which changes one B-move)

Donkey Kong
08. Donkey Kong (Largely unchanged; his Final Smash should really involve bongos)
09. Diddy Kong (Fast and resourceful, having the jetpack, peanut popper and guitar to use)

WarioWare
10. Wario (User of largely exaggerated and odd moves to portray the flavor of his franchise)

The Legend of Zelda
11. Link (TP appearance; moves unchanged except for TP instead of OoT/MM items)
12. Wind Waker Link (Not necessarily cel-shaded; has own moves and items, not a clone)
13. Zelda (TP appearance and sword, less dependant on magic; no Sheik this time around)
14. Ganondorf (TP appearance and sword; de-cloned, uses dark techniques mainly)

Kid Icarus
15. Pit (As seen in trailers and screenshots; a floaty seraph with a penchant for archery)

Pokémon
16. Pikachu (Not much should change, if anything at all; Pikachu works as it is)
17. Jigglypuff (The eternal easy unlockable; largely unchanged as well)
18. Mewtwo (Tuned up for the sake of balance and usefulness, but unchanged otherwise)
19. Rocket´s Meowth (Iconic since day one, his presence is overdue; a nimble brawler)
20. Lucario (An incredibly popular new Pokémon; its typing and move pool are ideal)

Kirby
21. Kirby (Pretty much the same; his mallet may have to be ditched due to a newcomer)
22. Metaknight (Definitely a swift and dashing swordfighter, with close-combat prowess)
23. King Dedede (A heavy floater with an oversized mallet; Sakurai will include him)

F-Zero
24. Captain Falcon (Immutable; the shady F-Zero franchise needs no further representation)

Pikmin
25. Captain Olimar (With a command-based moveset, he has potential for originality)

StarFox
26. Fox (He could keep half his old moves and share the other half with Falco)
27. Falco (De-cloned and in his Assault outfit, with some of Fox´s attacks and some new)
28. Krystal (A female, first and foremost, and her four staff powers are perfect B-moves)

Earthbound / MOTHER
29. Lucas (Lucas is Ness but more actual, and with a perfect Final Smash: PK LOVE)

Metroid
30. Samus (Confirmed to return, hopefully unchanged beyond her new transformation)
31. Zero-Suit Samus (Samus´ lighter alternate form; uses a gun-slash-laser whip)
32. Ridley (The heaviest of fliers, very reliant on his brute strength and fearsome weapons)

Fire Emblem
33. Marth (The original Lord; he can be worked with for balance and move variety)
34. Ike (Obvious by popular demand; he can be entirely different from Marth potentially)
35. Sigurd (Another beloved Lord--the heavier one; Ike already advertises FE10)

Ice Climbers
36. Ice Climbers (Their tag-teaming strategy and retro charm deserves a second run)

Punch-Out!!
37. Li´l Mac (One of the best candidates for Brawl, an ideal retro character to revive)

Balloon Fighter
38. Alice (Balloon Fighter was almost in SSBM; possible handicap character, much like Pichu)

Sonic (THIRD PARTY - SEGA)
39. Sonic the Hedgehog (Everyone wants to see Mario vs Sonic; there is no avoiding this)

Metal Gear (THIRD PARTY - KONAMI)
40. Snake (I bet you never thought you´d see him and Kirby in one game before this)

The last character slot, for the WTFWHOISTHAT!?!?!? character (much like Mr. Game & Watch in SSBB), I cannot entirely decide on. Takamaru (Mystery of Castle Murasame), Muddy (Mole-Mania) Chibi-Robo (Chibi-Robo!), Sukapon (Joy Mech Fight), Mike Jones (Startropics), Lip (Panel de Pon) and even a returning Mr. Game & Watch (Game & Watch) are all solid and potentially great choices (among many others), and since they are all equally obscure there is no telling who it will be; if anyone at all. Nevertheless, for now I´m gonna go with...

Zombies Ate My Neighbors!
41. Zeke (Knives and soda can bombs and 3D glasses, oh my!)

Please note that I´m including who I think will get in, not who I wish will get in. Had it been up to me, Geno would be in there, and so would Vaati, Pichu, Simon Belmont, Kumatora and Jill, among a myriad of other characters. Not to mention that Krystal, Lucas and a couple more would never make the cut. What is in parentheses is often wishful thinking, though. Anyways, those are my thoughts.

Again, please comment.
 

BoG

Smash Journeyman
Joined
May 24, 2007
Messages
306
Location
Utah
I think the originals will all return, I won't bother listing them. Mewtwo, Pichu, Young Link, Mr. Game and Watch, Dr.Mario and Roy will NOT be returning from melee.
Changes will be made to Gannaondorf.
Of course, Pit, meta knight, Wario, and snake are coming.
Newcomers:
-Ridley (a must)
-Krystal (As much as I hate to admit it, she's likely)
-Samurai Goroh 9I'd say he's a must, though not as likely as ridley)
-Simon or Richter Belmont (We know Konami is willing to give the rights, and so a spot for a character in one of their major franchises seems likely, expecially since they are re-releasing and making more and more CV games)
-Dedede (He's a cool, creative character with the possibility of a good moveset, and Sakurai created him)

And noiw, wishful thinking:
Tom Nook, he would rock!
Li'l Mac would rock too.
Ephraim from FE:SS. I don't think anyone has considered him, but he would rock. He weilds a lance!
Lucas, Jeff, or Flint, the series needs more representation. I personally think Jeff or Flint would make the best additions.
Once again, I really think Ephraim deserves more attention. He would be perfect!
 

dantemasta

Smash Apprentice
Joined
Mar 4, 2007
Messages
128
Ooh... a place to put my ideal roster. I picked most of the characters simply because I have seen their moves and believe that they would be good characters for Brawl. Also some just popped into my head. Anyone wanna challenge my opinion? I'd be glad to let you do so.

  • Mario
  • Donkey Kong
  • Link
  • Yoshi
  • Kirby
  • Pikachu
  • Fox
  • Samus/Zero Suit Samus
  • Jigglypuff
  • Ness
  • C. Falcon
  • Luigi
  • Peach
  • Bowser
  • Zelda/Sheik
  • Ice Climbers
  • Marth
  • Mewtwo
  • Ganondorf
  • Meta Knight
  • Pit
  • Wario
  • Snake
  • Daisy
  • Waluigi
  • Diddy Kong
  • King K. Rool
  • Samurai Goroh
  • Wolf
  • Krystal
  • Deoxys
  • Heracross
  • King Dedede
  • Adeleine
  • Demille
  • Lyn
  • Hector
  • Sonic
  • Ridley
  • Ash
  • Sigurd
  • Nayru
  • Vaati
  • Jody Summer
  • Geno
Heracross isn't popular enough, and Ash isn't eligible. Lyn would probably be replaced by Ike who is more popular. And if Jody Summer is the chick I think she is( I'm guessin' the chick from F-Zero) then Samurai Goroh is way more likely.
 

Mini Mic

Taller than Mic_128
BRoomer
Joined
May 5, 2007
Messages
11,207
Can anyone tell me why it is necessary to include crap characters with no personality, plausable moves or really anything else like Samurai Goroh when there are so many better choices?
 

Evolver

Smash Cadet
Joined
May 16, 2007
Messages
55
Location
Austria
Well here is my try. I think it turned out pretty realistic?
what does everyone think?

Confirmed

Mario Wario
Link Zero Suit Samus/Samus*
Pikachu Solid Snake
Kirby Metaknight
Samus Pit
Fox

*Share one slot


Returners

Luigi
Yoshi
Marth
Bowser
Ice Climbers
Peach
Jigglyputh
Captain Falcon
MewTwo
Donkey Kong
Game & Watch

New/Redone

Legend of Zelda:
Midna
Zelda (Twillight Princess Style without Shiek)
Gannondorf (Twillight Princess Style)
young Link (Wind Waker Style)

Star Fox Series:
Wolf (or Falco)
Krystal

Donkey Kong Series:
Diddy Kong

Metroid Series:
Ridley

Earthbound Series:
Lucas
Paula (or Ness)

Fire Emblem:
Ike

Kirby Series:
King Dedede
Lololo & Lalala (ok maybe i am biasd here, but i want them in :p )

Pokemon Series:
Lucario

F-Zero Series:
Samurai Goro

Mario & Co Series
Toad
Waluigi (Influenced from Mario STrikers -> Whips and Vines :p )

Misc
Balloon Fighter

Pimkin
Captain Olimar

Animal Crossing
Tom Nook

New 3rd Party
Sonic or Nights
Megamen
Geno or Bombermen


Sum: 45
 

Procrasticritter

Smash Journeyman
Joined
May 29, 2007
Messages
349
Well here is my try. I think it turned out pretty realistic?
what does everyone think?

Confirmed

Mario Wario
Link Zero Suit Samus/Samus*
Pikachu Solid Snake
Kirby Metaknight
Samus Pit
Fox

*Share one slot


Returners

Luigi
Yoshi
Marth
Bowser
Ice Climbers
Peach
Jigglyputh
Captain Falcon
MewTwo
Donkey Kong
Game & Watch

New/Redone

Legend of Zelda:
Midna
Zelda (Twillight Princess Style without Shiek)
Gannondorf (Twillight Princess Style)
young Link (Wind Waker Style)

Star Fox Series:
Wolf (or Falco)
Krystal

Donkey Kong Series:
Diddy Kong

Metroid Series:
Ridley

Earthbound Series:
Lucas
Paula (or Ness)

Fire Emblem:
Ike

Kirby Series:
King Dedede
Lololo & Lalala (ok maybe i am biasd here, but i want them in :p )

Pokemon Series:
Lucario

F-Zero Series:
Samurai Goro

Mario & Co Series
Toad
Waluigi (Influenced from Mario STrikers -> Whips and Vines :p )

Misc
Balloon Fighter

Pimkin
Captain Olimar

Animal Crossing
Tom Nook

New 3rd Party
Sonic or Nights
Megamen
Geno or Bombermen


Sum: 45

seems pretty good, though I don't think Waluugi or Toad would be in; there are too many Mario characters already, in everyone returns. Also, Nights seems a bit iffy. Nice job on every1 else though
 

SmashYou6666

Banned via Administration
Joined
Apr 7, 2007
Messages
47
Here's mine, 44 in all. This is all speculation from my POV.

Mario
Donkey Kong
Link
Yoshi
Kirby
Pikachu
Fox
Falco
Samus/Zero Suit Samus
Jigglypuff
Ness
C. Falcon
Luigi
Peach
Bowser
Zelda/Sheik
Ice Climbers
Marth
Mewtwo
Ganondorf
Meta Knight
Pit
Wario
Snake
Waluigi (Most likely Mario representative IMO)
Donkey Kong Jr. (Nintendo don't tend to forget)
Samurai Goroh (1 more F-Zero representative and most likeky)
Wolf (Villain representative for Starfox)
Meowth (Popular pokemon, and most likely)
Dark Samus (Ridley won't be in, pretty **** sure)
Jimmy T (1 more wario ware representative)
Takamaru (Original character and obscure to the US audience)
Ike (following the wagon here)
Andy (1 Advance wars representative)
Lucas (1 more Mother representative and most likely)
Mr. G & W
Young Link
Roy
Isaac (1 Golden Sun representative)
Tingle (1 more Zelda representative and VERY LIKELY, LIKE IT OR NOT)
Kensuke Kimachi (At least one of sports game representative, either him or Ryota Hayami)
Geno (3rd party representative)

And you can start hate me..........now.
 

Procrasticritter

Smash Journeyman
Joined
May 29, 2007
Messages
349
Sry, I can't say I like your list considering that you left out some of the most plausible characters:

Ridley, Olimar, Krystal, Midna, Dedede, Diddy, Tom Nook, and Lucario

and fyi, all of these are 1st party. I don't know what you are talking about in your sig.
 

Erk Aduro

Smash Apprentice
Joined
Aug 13, 2005
Messages
122
Location
Somewhere over the rainbow presumably.
Erk Aduro, lucario isn't a legendary pokemon,
Whoop, my bad. I don't know too much about the 4th generation Pokemon, and since he had his own movie, I just assumed. Legendaries are a little too overpowered anyway. :\ I'd much rather see a starter from any of the generations or another popular first generation Pokemon get in.

Also, Smashyou666 I'm with Procrasticritter. What are you talking about? Do you understand what the term "third party" means? Ridley first appeared in the first Metroid game back on NES, created and owned by by Nintendo. Same for Animal Crossing. Tom Nook is owned by Nintendo. Now Sonic (owned by SEGA), Mega Man (owned by Capcom), Snake (owned by Konami), etcetera. Those are third party characters, owned by companies that make software, but not hardware. They are not owned by any of the big three, thus "third party."

Unless you knew all that and just have that in your sig to irritate people. Then I suppose I just wasted several minutes of my life. Meh...

Lastly, Skull Kid before Tingle, d00d. D:
 

Kurizu208

Smash Journeyman
Joined
May 26, 2006
Messages
409
Location
Magna, UT
My complete roster, with commentary.

1)Mario: Duh. Confirmed already. Doc would be an unlockable costune with no special .

2)Luigi: The source of the term "Luigify," the act of de-cloning an existing character. Expect him to become a bit more different.

3)Peach: With her own Super Princess Peach game, it is possible they will change her moves around and arm her with the umbrella for most of her attacks. On the other hand, she could also stay the same. It's all up to Sakura.

4)Bowser: Mario's arch nemisis. Although slow to the point of obscenity(sp?) in melee, in Brawl they could give him more hitstun on his moves, allowing him to combo better.

5)Yoshi: Although his own platformer days are over, Yoshi will inevitably return in Brawl.

6)Wario: Confirmed in the trailer, all we know is one of his moves is a fart.

7)DK: Mario's first enemy. Well, ok, that was really his dad, Cranky, who stole the princess, but who's counting?

8)Diddy kong: Since DK's turn to the light, he's picked up a few friends. Diddy would come well equipped with peanut popguns and a Jetbarrel for recovery.

9)Captian Falcon: One of four racers that date back to the first F-Zero game. He's been in smash since the begining... they're not going to drop him now.

10)Pico: With Gannondorf moving on to have his own moveset, the slot for semi-clone of Captian Falcon is open. Pico was also one of the first 4 F-Zero racers, and he has the body mass to pull off the moves Gannondorf used in melee.



11)Fox McCloud: The leader of Team Starfox, he's been here since the beginning. Expect some changes on how the shine works.

12)Krystal: According to rumors, Fox has actually married her by Starfox Command, the upcoming DS game. Although I expect her to have her flight suit, the moveset provided by her staff in Starfox Adventures gives he a uniqueness very few can match.

13)Falco Lombari: The ace pilot of Team Starfox. Already one of the most different of the clones, it would be difficult to further separate them without losing their playstyle.

14)Wolf O'Donnel: Fox's rival, Wolf was playable in Versus mode in Starfox Assault. Expect a slow, heavy character with lots of guns and a decent recovery, thanks to the booster pack item.

15)TP Link: Revealed in the trailer, TP Link seems similar to the adult link we know and love. The Gale Boomerang could provide an interesting change, as could a wolf based dash attack, but these are hardly needed.

16)WW/PH Link: Rumored to be included, "Celda" would be the Luigified Young link. Expect a longer spin attack, and grapple hook. (not to be confused with Hookshot, which TP link uses)

17)Gannondorf: Evil warlock, wielder of the tryforce of power, bent on world conquest... if that pesky Link didn't keep stopping him. Gannondorf has long taunted us with the blade you see in his victory pose... we deserve a proper fist, blade, and magic moveset from him.

18)TP Zelda: Wielding a sword in the promo art, Zelda could have a very intereresting moveset, combining he lighning kicks with fencing-type swordplay. However, Shiek would be lost to us, as TP no longer needs the ninja.

19)Kirby: Sakura's own creation, Kirby was confirmed in the trailer, being the only character who didn't get a graphical facelift. Expect his gameplay to counter this lack.

20)Metaknight: Kirby's archrival, Metaknight was confirmed in the trailer.




21)Pikachu: Picachu can be found on anything from vitamins to airplanes, and some people even remodel their VW beatles to resemble this pokemon. Revealed at E3, nothing will keep this pokemon out of Brawl.

22)Jigglypuff: The singing wonder, Jiggs has mooved from being the joke character in the first game to being a tourny-worthy character in Melee. And of course, would the game be the same if the first thing you did was beat Classic on Very easy with 5 lives, and Jiggs DIDN'T show up?

23)Mewtwo: The ultimate genetically modified pokemon, he went on a diet just to squeeze into melee, droping from 260-odd pounds to something in the double digits. Before Brawl, he needs to put those pounds back on. I recomend McDonalds.

24)Rukario: Spelled Lucario in english, Rukario is a Legendary Fighting/Steel type pokemon who is shown throwing Ki blasts around in promo art. With his own movie and being in 4 games this fall (Diamond and Pearl, and the Mystic Dungon(?) games), his inclusion is needed.

25)Samus/Zamus: Revealed at E3, Sakura has said that under certian circomstances Samus will shed her armor and become Zero Suit Samus, sometimes refered to as Zamus.

26)Ridley: Samus's nemisis. This Cyborg Dragoness could be argued to be the leader of the space pirates, and she has been in exactly half of all the games Samus has been in, greater than any other single entity.

27)Marth: The champion must return. However, expect a nerf of his tipper.

28)Hector: Dude with an ax. Fire Emblem. Enough said.

29)Ness: Cult Classic. the Hero of Mother 2 will no doubt be back, this time stronger and heavier.

30)Pokey: Ness's nemisis, he usually uses mechs to fight with.



31)Ice Climbers: Do not doubt the power of Teamwork! Athough rumored to be dropped, this rumor was admitted to be a hoax. Retro Returneth!

32)G&W: Phear teh Sausages! This classic character also was rumored to be dropped, but there was no evidence to support this claim.

33)Pit: A third characer not seen since the NES, Pit was revealed in glorius 3D at E3. He is an angelic archer with multible jumps.

34)Issac: Representing the Golden Sun franchise, Issac is a spellcaster who uses a sword and Earth magic to defeat his foes.

35)Ray Mk I: From Custom Robo, Ray is armed to the teeth with weapons.

36)Megaman X: The second most wanted third party character in Smash. Although the similarities to Samus are remarkable, megaman could have an interesting moveset as a range specialist.

37)Snake: The one ond only 3rd party character revealed at E3, his appearence caused both supporters and detracters to repeat a classic line. Snake? SNAKE??? SNAAAAAKKKEEEE!!!!!!!

38)Sonic: Mario's ultimate archrival. The single most wanted 3rd party character for brawl. Fans have waited 15 years for this battle, and Sakura had better not make us wait another 6 more.
i pretty much agree with you except id chanbe ray mk1 to Ray01 and drop young link and replace him with king dedede, or some one else from yoshi's story since he hasn't had another character from his series yet.
 

Procrasticritter

Smash Journeyman
Joined
May 29, 2007
Messages
349
Hey, I like your list. Props for suggesting Ray01. He'd make no less than an awesome Brawl character. Also props for putting in 4 from Starfox, which is my favorite series (Fox has always been my main for Smash; Krystal and Wolf are probably the two characters I'm hoping for the most!) If there are going to be 4 chars. From Zelda, I think I'd rather see Midna than WW link, since IMO, original character > clone, but maybe that's just me...

Although, I think if Megaman were in Brawl, it would more liekly be his original version rather than Megaman X. also, I think Ike would be more likely in Brawl over Hector.
 

SmashYou6666

Banned via Administration
Joined
Apr 7, 2007
Messages
47
Sry, I can't say I like your list considering that you left out some of the most plausible characters:

Ridley, Olimar, Krystal, Midna, Dedede, Diddy, Tom Nook, and Lucario

and fyi, all of these are 1st party. I don't know what you are talking about in your sig.
I explained about Ridley - Olimar could be in, +1 - Tingle before Midna which Midna is very unlikely - I don't think that nintendo will put 2 more Kirby representative so King Dedede - DK Jr. before Diddy - Tom Nook...please - Lucario? *roll eyes* for the people who follows deeply the pokemons series...Meowth is more likely

And what's with the "all of these are 1st parties"?
AND?
For your info, King Dedede and Lucario are second party.

Whoop, my bad. I don't know too much about the 4th generation Pokemon, and since he had his own movie, I just assumed. Legendaries are a little too overpowered anyway. :\ I'd much rather see a starter from any of the generations or another popular first generation Pokemon get in.

Also, Smashyou666 I'm with Procrasticritter. What are you talking about? Do you understand what the term "third party" means? Ridley first appeared in the first Metroid game back on NES, created and owned by by Nintendo. Same for Animal Crossing. Tom Nook is owned by Nintendo. Now Sonic (owned by SEGA), Mega Man (owned by Capcom), Snake (owned by Konami), etcetera. Those are third party characters, owned by companies that make software, but not hardware. They are not owned by any of the big three, thus "third party."

Unless you knew all that and just have that in your sig to irritate people. Then I suppose I just wasted several minutes of my life. Meh...

Lastly, Skull Kid before Tingle, d00d. D:
My mistake on the sig, I know what a 3rd party is, I shouldn't have wrote "other". And believe me, Tingle before Skull Kid.
 

OmegaXXII

Fire Emblem Lord/ Trophy Hunter
Joined
Jul 4, 2006
Messages
21,468
Location
Houston, Texas!
Here's my list of who shouldbe in Brawl.

Mario Series
Mario
Luigi
Wario
Bowser
Bowser Jr.
Donkey Kong
Wart

Zelda Series
Link
Zelda
WW Link
Ganondorf

Kirby Series
Kirby
Meta-Knight
King Dedede

Metroid Series
Samus (as a seperate character)
Zero-Suit Samus
Ridley
DarkSamus

StarFox Series
Fox
Falco
Wolf

Pokemon Series
Pikachu
Deoxys
Mewtwo
Blazakin

F-Zero Series
Captain Falcon
Samurai Goroh

Fire Emblem Series
Marth
Ike

Earthbound
Ness

3rd Party
Solid Snake
Liquid Snake
Megaman
Sonic

Others
Mr. Game & Watch

I didn't include the the rest of the EarthBound cast because in my opinion I think the rest of them suck and I can't see the Ice Climbers making a come back due to thier popularity so this is what I think a reasonable number of characters that should make it in.
 
Top Bottom