I personally don't agree with Bayo being first.
It's pure theorycrafting to put her in first. She doesn't have the results to back up the claim, that she's the best character in the game. It's solely based on theory
Bayonetta is #1 purely based on 'B tier players' upsetting established top players, and the sheer quantity of strong Bayonetta players.
Can she win a Supermajor? This is yet to be proven. Her prowess and success on the top 8 stage is somewhat underwhelming.
I am very much in the same vein of these two quotes; I am glad there are others that do think this way.
I have no problem with Bayonetta being the best character sometime down the line in the future, but as of now,
right now, the metagame has no reason for her to be the best character other than people being scared of her and putting her at the top.
As mentioned, her top 8 supermajor results are much to be desired, but please remember that it is no meme that SDI does indeed make it
much harder for her to perform. Remember ESAM at UGC? I do. People like to dismiss/forget this, but this is actually a prime example that there is indeed relevant counterplay to the character, counterplay that makes her noticabley struggle. The good thing about this is that this counterplay is that it isn't character/MU specific; any character can do this. Whether people like to forget about it because it's ESAM (ESAM opinions boiz), I don't know, but it's there.
But right here, right now, Bayonetta has no reason to be the best character in the game outside of people putting her there out of fear.
Again, sometime down the line, when she proves to be the best character, by winning a few supermajors, I'll gladly accept her as the best character in the game with open arms. Not yet though, certainly not yet.
THIS. EXCITES. ME.
I'd swap Rosa and ZSS though because Rosa hasn't made waves in a while, and Dabuz is drastically decreasing her usage
Actually, while Rosalina hasn't outright
won anything for a big while (Dabuz did win a relatively big German event a couple of weeks back with solo Rosalina; in fact, there was a German Rosalina that came 3rd as well IIRC), she commonly places top 8 at most events (that aren't minor weeklies) across the globe.
And we cannot drop her down because Dabuz said he might be dropping her, because as of yet, this has not happened - in fact, it's been more the opposite; Dabuz saying he'd be decreasing his usage of her because it's hard for him/doesn't enjoy her, yet at Frostbite, he went the vast majority as Rosalina (there were a couple of games he used Olimar; just for one game in his top 16 run, against Salem, after he won the first two games with Rosalina, which I will add is supposedly a losing MU), and he was visibly happy with his performance with her. He has also notably improved his game when he's in the 13 seconds without Luma, which likely helped.
I'm happy with 8th place for Rosalina personally. I think it's an accurate representation of the character's tools and representation in the current metagame.
I do agree that ZSS is a bit too low, though. I would personally put her on either side of Rosalina. Both of these would make sense for both characters IMO.
---
Overall though, this is a pretty solid list - minor gripes aside (because those minor gripes would still be move X character a space or two; Marth is an example who I would move down a spot, Bayonetta down a spot or two etc.), this is probably the best list so far.
I'm pleasantly surprised to see Lucario rise a few spots, especially when you consider that Frostbite was not included in the voting. This starts a good trend for the character.
I am even more pleased to see Peach rise, too! I have been using Peach a little more these days, and it makes me happy to see opinions on her improving, because mine too, has improved.
And yes, SAMUS IS NEARLY MID TIER!