Your Reaction If....

[kaithehedgefox]

I only know this through a video essay about Rick and Morty, but it feels like a fitting (if visually dissonant) choice.

HWYR if a second Ganondorf was added the Smash, with the old one keeping the name "Ganondorf" and the new one being called "Canondorf"?

I never heard of Canondorf until now.

Once again, assist trophies have been a creative way to include non-playable characters in-gameplay. That said HWYR if Goku (Dragon Ball) and Miku (Vocaloid) were assist trophies in a Smash fangame?

 

[HyperSomari64]

No, just no. Non-video game characters can't work as Assist Trophies, their fans will be upset.

HWYR if there was a family-friendly reference to SnapCube's Eggman monologue in Sonic movie 3?

 

[Tankman from Newgrounds]

Great, considering that SEGA likes fan stuff like memes and things.

HWYR if Shrek 5 included a scene, where Shrek does the griddy dance?

 

[DragonRobotKing26]

I don't know this dance,but i don't want this happen

HWYR if Sam and Max were in Smash 6?

 

[Tankman from Newgrounds]

Uhhh, despite being comic book characters (yeah, really. Search it up), they could be cool choices for the game. Also "Telltale games" rep would be genius.

HWYR if Telltale games/LCG made a licensed game based on "Nightmare on elm street" movie franchise?
(The games would adapt the movies while adding new stuff to the lore)

 

[darkvortex]

Pretty good fit but I'd honestly be pissed off if they did anything else before Wolf Among Us 2. They've been working on this thing for like six years now c'mon. Best to give it to the ex telltale but not called telltale team who made the Star Trek game.

In fact wouldn't the people who made Until Dawn be a way better fit? They know how to do horror and their last game was literally a slasher movie

HWYR if Nintendo made a sequel to ARMS?

 

[Tankman from Newgrounds]

Cool, really cool.

HWYR if Batman: Arkham Asylum was in Ultimate game collection?

 

[ZagarTulip]

I know very little about Batman to have a strong opinion

HWYR if Dianthus from Harvestella got into Smash 6 as playable?

 

[HyperSomari64]

Weird pick, but I'll take it.

HwyR if Sonic movie 3 referenced the infamous Sonic Gather Battle DRM incident?

 

[Perkilator]

Weird pick, but I'll take it.

HwyR if Sonic movie 3 referenced the infamous Sonic Gather Battle DRM incident?

That’s be a weird thing to reference but I wouldn’t put it past SEGA.

HWYR if the Fire Emblem lineup in Smash was:

• Marth
• Lyn
• Ike
• Either a fully de-cloned Chrom (with Lucina as an alt) or Robin
• Azura
• Byleth

 

[kaithehedgefox]

Less Fire Emblem characters on the roster? I wouldn't mind.

Earlier, Sakurai officially confirmed that is he now semi retired. HWYR if in Smash 6, not only does Waluigi get promoted to playable, and his Piranha Plant gets demoted to one of his special moves, but also Yuga (Zelda) gets an assist trophy. Yuga is a hate sink, so it would make sense once again.

 

[Perkilator]

Less Fire Emblem characters on the roster? I wouldn't mind.

Earlier, Sakurai officially confirmed that is he now semi retired. HWYR if in Smash 6, not only does Waluigi get promoted to playable, and his Piranha Plant gets demoted to one of his special moves, but also Yuga (Zelda) gets an assist trophy. Yuga is a hate sink, so it would make sense once again.

I'd say no correlation with anything you just said wtf are you even talking about but I wouldn't mind.

HWYR if this was Brawl's roster? (Italics bold denotes an unlockable character)

Mario​	Donkey Kong​	Link​	Samus / Zero Suit Samus​	Kirby​	Fox​	Pikachu​	Lyn​	Marth​
Luigi​	Diddy Kong​	Zelda / Sheik​	Pit​	Meta Knight​	Falco​	Pokemon Trainer*​	Ike​	R.O.B.​
Bowser​	Yoshi​	Ganondorf​	Ice Climbers​	King Dedede​	Wolf​	Lucario​	Ness​	Leon S. Kennedy​
Peach​	Wario​	Captain Falcon​	Mr. Game & Watch​	Olimar​	DeMille​	Jigglypuff​	Lucas​	Sonic​

*Team consists of Totodile, Grovyle and Charizard

 

[FazDude]

Probably the same as how I reacted to the IRL Brawl roster - None of the cuts were too crazy, and I still get Sonic, so it all works out in the end.

HWYR if a Walker-piloting Slippy Toad was added to Smash?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Happy we've got another vehicle character, but disappointed that it has a visible pilot

HWYR if the second Pikmin rep in Smash was a giant team of Pikmin?

 

[darkvortex]

I genuinely want the Dog but honestly it'd be funny. Sure.

HWyR if Samurai Goroh was in smash?

 

[DragonRobotKing26]

Finally,one more F-Zero rep!

HWYR if Sonic characters from IDW Comics was in a next Sonic game?

 

[Tankman from Newgrounds]

Okay, cool. I would love it.

HWYR if Dead by Daylight included Fulgore from Killer Instinct as killer?

 

[DragonRobotKing26]

It's cool idea,but it will be very weird a fighting game character on a horror game

HWYR if Metroid get a comic book series made by IDW,Archie or Image Comics?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Nice to see more Nintendo multimedia content

HWYR if the next Smash demoted characters to assist trophy?

 

[FazDude]

My exact reactions would depend on who gets demoted, but I don't hate the idea - Good way to keep veterans in the game in some form.

HWYR if the next Smash overhauled assists to work more like they do in Fraymakers?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

LET'S GOOOOOOOOO

HWYR if NASB 2 had a system like Ultimate's spirits or the Nick Kart games' pit stop crew, and it included characters from shows that don't have playable fighters?

 

[Tankman from Newgrounds]

Great idea, that would work.

HWYR if starter theme in next pokemon game (assume the region takes place in another Japanese region) was based around 3 sacred treasures of Japan?

 

[darkvortex]

That's actually a very cool idea

HWYR if smash remix added Saki

 

[Tankman from Newgrounds]

Great choice, a treasure rep seems like a good idea.

HWYR if you were sent into alternate universe, where Bomb-Robo and Wistann the gnome games were real games?
(Alternatively, what would be your reaction if you were sent into alternate gaming universe based on "Alternate gaming universe & smash bros")

 

[darkvortex]

Ahh where am i how do I get back to my friends and family.

HWYR if Dragaux was the Ring Fit rep in smash?

 

[ZagarTulip]

I'd be interested to play it

HWYR if Cranky Kong got in Smash instead of Dixie Kong?

 

[darkvortex]

BASED.

I actually have no issue with Dixie and I think shed be a lot of fun but Cranky is more unique and also funny

HWYR if Merkava got in Infinite Beyond

 

[Tankman from Newgrounds]

Quiet cool choice, even if we have a Arc system works rep (Sol badguy)

HWYR if Jay & Kay (The men in black) were playable as Aircel/Malibu comics reps in Marvel Vs Capcom 4?

 

[darkvortex]

Quiet cool choice, even if we have a Arc system works rep (Sol badguy)

HWYR if Jay & Kay (The men in black) were playable as Aircel/Malibu comics reps in Marvel Vs Capcom 4?

Undernight isn't actually by Arc System Works. they publish them but don't have anything to do with the development and I don't think they own the IP

 

[Tankman from Newgrounds]

Undernight isn't actually by Arc System Works. they publish them but don't have anything to do with the development and I don't think they own the IP

Then who owns the franchise?

 

[darkvortex]

Then who owns the franchise?

Soft Circle French-Bread. The devs

 

[darkvortex]

That's be weird tbh. Marvel don't own the IP and there are better guest picks. I don't think of the MIB as very "fighty"

HWYR if NASB had cuts but then added the characters back as free DLC

 

[HyperSomari64]

Sure, but i'm more on the all characters returning side.

HWYR if Daytona USA's Hornet (officially) appeared in a collab with Forza Motorsport (2023)?

 

[Tankman from Newgrounds]

Cool, even if it could make sense in Gran Turismo.

HWYR if Sharpedo got an evolution based on Megalodon and atomic bomb?

 

[darkvortex]

Great choice, a treasure rep seems like a good idea.

late but Remix does already have a Treasure rep actually. Marina

 

[Tankman from Newgrounds]

late but Remix does already have a Treasure rep actually. Marina

Oh, I meant an another Treasure rep.

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Did that not already have an evo??

HWYR if this was inexplicably the next Smash's roster?

just realised this is LegallyTM a creation thread, so I get 3 double posts - here's the roster. 400 characters - including some picks that may or may not have been chosen out of malice!

1. Mario (Super Mario)
2. Luigi
3. Peach
4. Bowser
5. Daisy
6. Waluigi
7. Goomba
8. Piranha Plant
9. Dr. Mario
10. Dr. Bowser
11. Roy Koopa
12. Fire Mario
13. Small Mario
14. Small Peach
15. Mario and Yoshi
16. Prince Peasley
17. Vivian
18. Baby Face
19. President Koopa
20. Yoshi (Yoshi)
21. The Stork
22. Pak E. Derm
23. Donkey Kong (Donkey Kong)
24. Diddy Kong
25. King K. Rool
26. Cranky Kong
27. Dixie Kong
28. Rambi
29. Klump
30. Stanley
31. Pipsy
32. Diddy Kong Head-Shaped CD
33. Wario (Wario)
34. Wario Land
35. Ashley
36. Jimmy T.
37. Penny
38. Captain Syrup
39. Wario’s Nose
40. Link (Zelda)
41. Zelda
42. Sheik
43. Ganondorf
44. Ganon
45. Toon Link
46. Toon Zelda
47. Wild Link
48. Octorok
49. Moblin
50. Bokoblin
51. Ghirahim
52. Midna
53. Impa (Elderly)
54. Toon Bokoblin
55. Morshu
56. Tingle (Tingle)
57. Samus (Metroid)
58. Ridley
59. Metroid
60. Kirby (Kirby)
61. King Dedede
62. Waddle Dee
63. Whispy Woods
64. Adeleine
65. Daroach
66. Dashing Super Guy
67. Fox (Star Fox)
68. Falco
69. Peppy
70. Slippy
71. Wolf
72. Arwing
73. Wolfen
74. Andross
75. Mewtwo (Pokemon)
76. Jigglypuff
77. Squirtle
78. Ivysaur
79. Rattata
80. Ditto
81. Magikarp
82. Haunter
83. Beedrill
84. Krabby
85. Ho-Oh
86. Igglybuff
87. Onix
88. Genesect
89. Meloetta
90. Trubbish
91. Braixen
92. Rowlet
93. Incineroar
94. Iron Valiant
95. Giovanni
96. Lucy Fleetfoot
97. Todd Snap
98. Technology Guy
99. MissingNo
100. Ness (EarthBound)
101. Lloyd
102. Kumatora
103. Master Belch
104. Ice Climbers (Ice Climber)
105. Topi US
106. Topi JP
107. Marth (Fire Emblem)
108. Lucina
109. Robin
110. Corrin
111. Byleth
112. Oliver
113. Mr. Game & Watch (Game & Watch)
114. Pit (Classic) (Kid Icarus)
115. Uprising Pit
116. Olimar (Pikmin)
117. Pikmin
118. Bulborb
119. Oatchi
120. ROB (ROB)
121. Villager (Animal Crossing)
122. New Villager
123. Crazy Redd
124. KK Slider
125. Wii Fit Trainer (Wii Fit)
126. Little Mac (Punch-Out!)
127. Glass Joe
128. King Hippo
129. Duck Hunt (Duck Hunt)
130. Inkling (Splatoon)
131. Callie/Marie
132. Pearl/Marina
133. Ted & Archie (Nintendogs)
134. Yuka (Rhythm Heaven)
135. Widget
136. Excitebiker (Excitebike)
137. Jill (Drill Dozer)
138. Sundes (Mole Mania)
139. Who Are You Running From? (Game Boy Camera)
140. Wii Remote Silicone Jacket (Wii)
141. Mii Brawler (Mii)
142. Mii Gunner
143. Mii Swordfighter
144. Fighting Polygon Team (Super Smash Bros.)
145. Snake (Metal Gear)
146. Senator Armstrong
147. Sonic (Classic) (Sonic the Hedgehog)
148. Tails
149. Knuckles
150. Dr. Eggman
151. Super Sonic
152. Modern Sonic
153. Shadow
154. Motobug/Flicky
155. Big the Cat
156. Fang the Sniper
157. AoStH Robotnik
158. Segapede
159. Mega Man (Mega Man)
160. Roll
161. Bad Box Art Mega Man
162. Pac-Man (Pac-Man)
163. Ms. Pac-Man
164. Blinky
165. Pinky
166. Inky
167. Clyde
168. Pac-Mom
169. Gyaraga
170. Taizo Hori
171. Mappy
172. Toc-Man
173. Pac-Man 2
174. Naked Blinky
175. Ryu (Street Fighter)
176. Ken
177. Chun-Li
178. Akuma
179. Blanka
180. Sakura
181. Zangief
182. M. Bison
183. Vega
184. Dracula (Castlevania)
185. Captain N Alucard
186. Cloud (Final Fantasy)
187. Sephiroth
188. Kefka
189. Chocobo
190. Tifa
191. Barret
192. Erdrick (Dragon Quest)
193. Solo
194. Eight
195. Luminary
196. Slime
197. Jinjo (Banjo-Kazooie)
198. Terry (Fatal Fury)
199. Iori
200. Nakoruru
201. Steve (Minecraft)
202. Ender Dragon
203. Pig
204. Kazuya (Tekken)
205. Kuma
206. Bob
207. Yoshimitzu
208. Lin
209. Doomguy (Doom)
210. Spider Mastermind
211. Kratos (God of War)
212. Zeus
213. Arteus
214. Master Chief (Halo)
215. Arbiter
216. Cortana
217. Red (Angry Birds)
218. Bad Piggy
219. Big Smoke (Grand Theft Auto)
220. I (Tetris)
221. L/J
222. Z/S
223. O
224. T
225. Bubsy (Bubsy)
226. Woolie
227. Miner Willy (Manic Miner)
228. Cursor (Windows)
229. Clippy
230. Inori Aizawa
231. Yeti
232. Space Cadet
233. Gex (Gex)
234. Rez
235. Horace (Horace Goes Skiing)
236. Lara Croft (Tomb Raider)
237. Modern Lara
238. Voodoo Vince (Voodoo Vince)
239. Lockjaw (Rise of the Robots)
240. Sqij (Sqij!)
241. Urban Yeti (Urban Yeti)
242. Putt-Putt (Junior Adventures)
243. Pajama Sam
244. Spy Fox
245. Freddi Fish
246. Dingodile (Crash Bandicoot)
247. Ripper Roo
248. Tiny Tiger
249. Pinstripe
250. Nina Cortex
251. Mettaton EX (Undertale)
252. Undyne
253. King Dice (Cuphead)
254. Ribby and Croaks
255. Baron von Bon Bon
256. Shovel Knight (Shovel Knight)
257. Mona
258. Peppino (Pizza Tower)
259. The Noise
260. Sim (The Sims)
261. Sub-Zero (Mortal Kombat)
262. Johnny Cage
263. Gordon Freeman (Half Life)
264. Headcrab
265. Flappy Bird (Flappy Bird)
266. Annalynn (Annalynn)
267. Elizabert Megafig (Bugsnax)
268. Snaxsquatch
269. PaRappa (PaRappa the Rapper)
270. Lammy
271. Guru Ant
272. Plok (Plok)
273. Yumetaro (Mr. Gimmick)
274. Dweeb (The Outfoxies)
275. Professor Ching
276. Kung Fu Man (MUGEN)
277. Willy (Rockin’ Kats)
278. Hat Kid (A Hat in Time)
279. Bow Kid
280. Sackboy (LittleBigPlanet)
281. Aloy (Horizon)
282. Penguin (Club Penguin)
283. Om Nom (Cut the Rope)
284. Crazy Dave (Plants vs. Zombies)
285. Ben (Talking Friends)
286. Power Pro (Power Pros)
287. Evil Otto (Berzerk)
288. Yorgle (Adventure)
289. Jazz Jackrabbit (Jazz Jackrabbit)
290. Space Invader (Space Invaders)
291. Toejam and Earl (Toejam and Earl)
292. Bonanza Bros (Bonanza Bros)
293. Headdy (Dynamite Headdy)
294. Ristar (Ristar)
295. Kapu Kapu (ChuChu Rocket)
296. Game Genie (Game Genie)
297. Pin Bot (Pin Bot)
298. Fall Guy (Fall Guys)
299. Impostor (Among Us)
300. UItra Fishbunjin 3000 (Ittle Dew)
301. Masked Ruby
302. Orka (Healthy Weapon)
303. Business Casual Man (Slap City)
304. Princess Remedy (Princess Remedy)
305. Wrastor (Rivals of Aether)
306. Elliana
307. Ranno
308. Pomme
309. Monty Mole (Monty Mole)
310. Bridget (Guilty Gear)
311. Faust
312. Untitled Goose (Untitled Goose Game)
313. Commander Keen (Commander Keen)
314. Delay Lama (Delay Lama)
315. Lemming (Lemmings)
316. Zoombinis (Zoombinis)
317. Frog (Chrono Trigger)
318. Skye (Darkened Skye)
319. Freddy Fazbear (FNAF)
320. Mei (Overwatch)
321. Reaper
322. Octane (Rocket League)
323. Hornet (Daytona USA)
324. Q*Bert (Q*Bert)
325. Dragonborn (Skyrim)
326. BD Joe (Crazy Taxi)
327. Noob (Roblox)
328. Peeley (Fortnite)
329. Cuddle Team Leader
330. Meow Skulls
331. Geno
332. Stubbs the Zombie (Stubbs the Zombie)
333. Banjo Man (Phalanx)
334. Chip (Chip’s Challenge)
335. Bomberman (Bomberman)
336. Act Zero Bomberman
337. Pete (Harvest Moon)
338. Boogerman (Boogerman)
339. Blue Suede Goo (Clayfighter)
340. Earthworm Jim (Earthworm Jim)
341. Atrus (Myst)
342. Kang Fu (Kang Fu)
343. Drake (Drake of the 99 Dragons)
344. Spike (Ape Escape)
345. Sam Fisher (Tom Clancy)
346. Rabbid (Rabbids)
347. Bandito Chinchilla (Thrillville)
348. Flo (Metal Slug)
349. Shiori (Tokimeki Memorial)
350. Jumbo Josh (Garten of Banban)
351. Vibri (Vib Ribbon)
352. Croc (Croc)
353. Necky (Famitsu)
354. Octodad (Octodad)
355. Plane (Flight Simulator)
356. Paddle (Pong)
357. Reindog (Multiversus)
358. Larry the Bird (Twitter)
359. Dante (Devil May Cry)
360. Vergil
361. Cole (Infamous)
362. Nathan Drake (Uncharted)
363. Big Daddy (Bioshock)
364. Radec (Killzone)
365. Avatar (Ultima)
366. Sock Puppet (Pets.com)
367. Chosen Undead (Dark Souls)
368. Ceaseless Discharge
369. Chaos Witch Quelaag
370. Baby (Super Monkey Ball)
371. Diablo (Diablo)
372. Annie (Anton)
373. Paul
374. Bertie (Bertie the Brain)
375. Fido (Don’t Buy This)
376. Jake (Subway Surfers)
377. Suzane (Blender)
378. Bosch (Line Rider)
379. Nemesis (Resident Evil)
380. PB (Polar Bowler)
381. Dingle Kringle (Elf Bowling)
382. Big Rig (Big Rigs)
383. Trapper (Dead by Daylight)
384. Thrall (World of Warcraft)
385. Aatrox (League of Legends)
386. Leona
387. Blitzcrank
388. Danzaburou (Smite)
389. Ultraman (Ultraman)
390. Godzilla (Godzilla)
391. Doraemon (Doraemon)
392. Goku (Dragon Ball)
393. Totoro (Studio Ghibli)
394. Chibi Maruko-Chan (Chibi Maruko Chan)
395. Darth Vader (Star Wars)
396. Garfield (Garfield)
397. Shrek (Shrek)
398. SpongeBob (SpongeBob)
399. Ronald McDonald (McDonalds)
400. Homer Simpson (The Simpsons)

 

[FazDude]

"i woulda been just fine with just annalynn nintendo chill"

HWYR if the next Smash added Mario 64, a fighter who used Mario's Smash 64 moveset (with Melee moves for attacks that weren't present in 64)?

 

[Tankman from Newgrounds]

Did that not already have an evo??

HWYR if this was inexplicably the next Smash's roster?

No, Sharpedo didn't had a third stage evolution. There is only Carvanha & Sharpedo.

Anyway for Faz, that would quite great idea. Also I get SMG4 vibes because of using 64-based models in videos.

HWYR if Flukeman from X-Files was a real monster?

 

[Perkilator]

No, Sharpedo didn't had a third stage evolution. There is only Carvanha & Sharpedo.

Anyway for Faz, that would quite great idea. Also I get SMG4 vibes because of using 64-based models in videos.

HWYR if Flukeman from X-Files was a real monster?

HYWR if this was SSBU's lineup of newcomers?

Spoiler: Base game (2018)

Unique fighters

• 64. Inkling (revealed in March 2018 Mini Direct)
• 65. Simon (E3 2018)
• 66. Ridley (EVO 2018 Day 1)
• 67. King K. Rool (EVO 2018 Day 1)
• 68. Isabelle (EVO 2018 Day 2)
• 69. Incineroar (EVO 2018 Day 3)
• 70. Waluigi (EVO 2018 Day 3)
• 71-72. Pyra / Mythra (September 2018 Direct)
• 73. Bandana Waddle Dee (September 2018 Direct)
• 74. Min Min (November 2018 Direct)
• 75. Banjo & Kazooie (November 2018 Direct)

Echo Fighters

1. Dark Samus (Samus)
2. Black Shadow (Captain Falcon)
3. Daisy (Peach)
4. Dixie Kong (Diddy Kong)
5. Alph (Olimar)
6. Glass Joe (Little Mac)
7. Ken (Ryu)
8. Richter (Simon)

Spoiler: Fighters Pass

Vol. 1	Vol. 2	Vol. 3
76. Joker (February 2019) 77. Hero (June 2019) 78. Crash Bandicoot (July 2019) 79. Terry Bogard (September 2019) 80. Steve (January 2020)	81. Byleth (March 2020) 82. Dr. Eggman (June 2020) 83. Sephiroth (September 2020) 84. Ring Fit Trainee (November 2020) 85. Shantae (February 2021)	86. Kazuya Mishima (June 2021) 87. Dragonborn (September 2021) 88. Estelle Bright (November 2021) 89. Cinderace (March 2022) 90. Sora (June 2022)