You may buff two characters and nerf two others. Who do you choose?

[Brinzy]

You can buff characters that have already been buffed and nerf those who already got nerfed. None of this has to be "fair", and do not take anything said personally. (Why would anyone even do that?)


Buff: Samus. I'd give her moves more killing power (or at least return the killing power her projectiles had). I'd also give her flamethrower a bit more power, and I'd make her throws inflict a bit more damage.

Buff: Ganondorf. I'd give him a bit more speed and he definitely needs more range. His up-tilt is a signature move, but I personally hate it. It should cause a miniature earthquake and it should be a tiny, tiny bit faster. His Up B should be as powerful as it was in Melee, his aerials should get less downtime, and if I really wanted to buff him, I'd rather have his Ganoncide be a move that automatically throws the opponent down, without killing Ganon, too.

Nerf: Dedede. Give him a sorry bair, allow him to throw ONLY Waddle Dees and Doos, and reduce the raw power of his mallet attacks. Reduce him to two midair jumps. Yes, I am a hater.

Nerf: Snake. Make his tilts and jab much weaker, and reduce the damage his explosives do.

 

[kr3wman]

Buff Captain Falcon and Samus.

Nerf Snake and MK.

 

[Negi-Kun]

Buff: Captain Falcon & Sonic
Nerf: Snake & Olimar

 

[Hyper_Ridley]

Buff: Captain falcon and Gannondorf

Nerf: Snake and Dedede(but only by removing chaingrab)

 

[The Halloween Captain]

Buff: Pokemon Trainer, Jigglypuff
Nerf: GW, MK

 

[faytmaker]

Buff: Sonic and Link

Nerf: Snake and MetaKnight

 

[-Big_-Blue 9]

Buff Falcon and Sonic
Nerf Game & Watch and Zelda

 

[Ratatat]

BUFF
captain falcon: make falcon paunch instant kill...and homing.
wario: should be wario-man the whole time.

NERF
sonic: should be as slow as ganon, unfair speed, nuff said

 

[Foxtrotter]

Buff: Pikachu. Give Dair a wider shock wave when used near the ground, and have Skull Bash the potential to give an electric shock to opponet.

Also buff: Charizard. Longer Flamethrower (length-wise), replace Rock Smash with Dragon Claw, and make the glide look not so ********.

Nerf: King Dedede. Remove chain grab, and stop throwing the spiky-things whose name escapes me.

Also nerf: Jigglypuff Snake.
Please. D=

 

[DTKPch]

I'd use both buffs on Captain Falcon.
The end result: He is faster than Sonic, has a projectile like Falco's laser, can combo with his aerials, his up-b has super armor frames the entire time, his knee KOs on a medium-sized stage at 40%, his Falcon Punch is an instant kill, his dthrow is a chain throw on all characters which combos into knee, he doesn't normally die until upwards of 250%, his down-b and side-b also act as reflectors, and his smashes can not be out-prioritized. Oh, and if you try to ban him from tournaments, he jumps out of the TV and breaks your Wii.

I'd nerf Sonic and Lucas.

 

[SinisterHanded]

Buff Link and C.Falcon

Nerf MK and Snake

 

[HeoandReo]

I'd buff Mario and Diddy because I think they're okay characters, and Mario needs his Tornado recovery back, and Diddy needs more knockback power on his fair.
Nerf goes to Marth and Lucas because I hated Marth in Melee and the Random Button made me hate Lucas because it selected him all the time.

I don't feel like thinking what else I should buff/nerf them with. It's just what I would do.

 

[SirKibble]

Buff: Meta Knight: Infinite jumps, more knockback, less lag for the ending of the specials. Hey, we said it didn't have to be fair.

Buff: Ice Climbers: Make them less seperable, that's all I ask. Well, more range to Blizzard and more damage/hits for Squall Hammer would be nice, too. Oh, and make the Ice Blocks shrink slower and do more damage.

Nerf: Wario: I don't care what, just make him utterly and completely sucky. I hate the guy.

Nerf: Snake: Take away his tilts. Yeah, I mean so he doesn't even have them anymore at all.

 

[Snowstalker]

Buff: Captian Falcon, Ness

Nerf: Snake, Marth

 

[AAP]

Buff: Peach- give her back her wicked f-throw, a faster/more powerful u-air, and a little more speed

Buff: Luigi- his old fair, or maybe slightly weaker than melee, and make him the only char who could wavedash

Nerf: Marth- give him ike's sword and make it so all the little fairy could do was drag it on the ground, make his jab like peachs (maybe give him girlier sounds)

Nerf: Snake- give him a pool noodle and some water ballons, his jabs should be him doing the sprinkler and make all his costumes animal prints but in pastels, snake the water aerobics instructor. oh and maybe his water balloons could randomly be flutter boards that he could throw

 

[x9whitey9x]

Buff: Lucas and Captain Falcon
Nerf: Snake and Falco

 

[Nowaytoeatatater]

Buff Falcon, then buff Falcon again.

Nerf Falco and MK.

 

[Kiki52]

This is hard.

Buff: Ness MASSIVELY.

Buff: Captain Falcon MASSIVELY (even more than Ness)

Nerf: Lucas a considerable amount.

Nerf: Snake SUPER ULTRA MASSIVELY

 

[Kitamerby]

Buff: Falcon & Pokemon Trainer

Nerf: Snake & GnW

...I just don't like GnW's priority

 

[tirkaro]

Buff: Ganon, or at least make him more similar to Melee Ganon.
Buff: Lucario. And by "Buff", I mean, turn his skin whitish purpleish, give him 3 round fingers, make more catlike, give him a giant purple tail, make his aura purple, and call it "Psychic", make him float, let him lift stuff with his mind, and call him "Mewtwo."

Nerf: Snake, obvious reason is obvious.
Nerf: Random, because there is a 1/35 chance he'll be snake.

 

[Talazala]

Buff: Mario. I would give him more range in his attacks and increase his weight so it's harder to ko him. Also, I think he deserves a higher jump. He was freakin called JUMPMAN. Oh, and make the fireballs fail less. He is Nintendo's mascot after all, give him some credit.

Buff: Jiggly: More kill! less fail!

Nerf: Ike: Bring his strength down to a more reasonable level, so now he can only kill someone with his forward smash at when they're around 100%. Not like 70%. Also weaken his bair and uair.

Nerf: Marth: You can kiss your prettyboy face and speed goodbye. REMOVE HIS SPIKE.

 

[Ace55]

Buff: Wario- just to annoy that other guy.

but seriously (Wario doesn't need a buff)

Buff: Captain Falcon, Ganon (more like change Ganon, he's still partially a clone)

Nerf: Snake, MK (but G&W and Dedede could use one to).

And most importantly: take ROB back to the toystore.

 

[Talazala]

Oh and I didn't buff Yoshi cuz he doesn't NEED it. Thank you very much.

 

[xX Boezy Xx]

Buff: Ganondorf

Nerf: Everyone else

 

[rathy Aro]

DDD HATERS!!!!!

Buff combos

nerf camping

nuff said.

 

[Nowaytoeatatater]

Accidental double post <_<.

 

[Yukiwarashi]

Buff: Pokemon Trainer and Toon Link
Nerf: Pit and Pit. Yes, double the nerf. >=D

 

[Gory snake]

Buff: Captain Falcon & Jigglypuff
Nerf: Olimar & MK

 

[Crizthakidd]

id buff mk so his attacks do as much as snakes

nerf cap. falcons falcon punch.

sht does like 25%!!!!!!

 

[-Linko-]

Nerf: Falcon and Ganondorf

Buff: Solid Snake and Metaknight

Don't you hate me now?

Now, SRLS:

Buff: Hitstun

Nerf: airdodges. Make them one per jump, but directional.

Now, you've got it: Melee 2.0

 

[Knyaguy]

Buff: Pokemon Trainer and Samus
Nerf: Meta and Ike

 

[PKSkyler]

Buff: Captain Falcon (maybe not melee status tho) and a lil Ness(just get rid of chain grabs, and make his "Wind" after psi magnet x2 or so)

Nerf: Marth and Snake.

 

[ROOOOY!]

Falcon and Sonic deserve love and buffs.
Snake and Metaknight can die IRL, but even then they'd still be top tier.

 

[Tim_The_Enchanter]

Buff the Captain and Pokemon Trainer.

Nerf Snake and MK.

 

[Jibbles]

Buff: Falcon, Ganon

Nerf: Yoshi (I don't care if he is low/bottom), Sbake (love him but the 21% damage FTilt and ridiculous invisible hitbox has got to go)

 

[BudaBoy]

Buff Sonic and Yoshi (not a yoshi fan personally, but he's an original 12 people, I think it's finally his time)

Nerf MK and G&W (that d-smash should NOT be spammable)

 

[xxvic1ousxx]

Buff: Cpt. Falcon and Ganondorf.
Nerf: Metaknight and Snake (slightly...very slightly)

 

[AbsoluteZero255]

Buff: CF and Sonic

Nerf: Snake and MK.

 

[Ørion]

Nerf MK, he would become slow and lose all combo ability.
Nerf Snake, he would lose his killing power.
Buff Toon Link, I would give him more killing power.
Buff Toon Link (again, probably cheating but watev), make his dair cancelable so it can be used off the edge and remove all landing lag.

 

[AbsoluteZero255]

New idea: Buff random.