holy ****, this thread has been awesome the last couple of pages.
about Odd Future:
I am not crazy on any of OF's music, but I LOVE what they've accomplished in the past year+ and their basic outlook and perspective on art. I have mad respect for all of OF. I think some of them are going to go great places once their music matures a little bit. I want to see them live so bad. It's gotta be fun as ****.
My problem with Christian music- and this isn't limited to hip hop- is that it very often strikes me as "message first, music second". That makes me salty no matter what the message is. I've criticized Immortal Tecnhique for the same thing.
The beauty of music is that, no matter what perspective an artist is coming from, if the music is heartfelt and they put some thought into it, I can empathize with ANYTHING. This way, I can be as emotionally affected by Jesus Walks as I am by...well, the majority of MBDTF and Watch the Throne. It just seems sincere to me. I am almost anti-religious so I tend to vibe with Kanye's more recent stuff, but stuff like Jesus Walks and J. Ivy's verse in Never Let Me Down hit me hard. It's very touching when someone is moved by faith, even if it is something I think is imaginary. But, as I have no religious dogma to be faithful to, I can't really speak for religious folk when their beliefs are put down in media.
The one thing that WOULD offend me a LOT would be to somehow find out that Jay and Ye are just pushing the satanism thing just for press and popularity. I would not doubt it that Jay is just hopping on the bandwagon because that seems to be his forte, but to think that Kanye is just playing to what he thinks will be a broader demographic is far more offensive than thinking that he truly lost his faith.
Kanye has always been about the confliction of faith with his love for hedonism, though.
"ask the reverend, are the strip clubs cool if my tips help send a pretty girl through school?"
"I want to talk to God but I'm afraid cuz we aint spoke in so long."
and, I remember a quote from an interview where he said "I lose my religion every time I walk in the club"
that kind of introspection and honesty is something I admire more than anything in an artist. and it's why I like Ye a hundred times more than Jay. Jay seems to me like a shark that will jump on whatever fad he thinks is gonna get hot just for the sake of keeping his name out there. Kanye seems eternally sincere.