Ignoring the fact that even as scum I never have pre-set reads this logic is definitely faulty. The same kind of play is not necessarily scummy for two different players - it's not untypical for you to be reversed about certain reads while it definitely is for Ryker.
Ok well it's more of the fact that you didn't question me at all at that point for any of my posts. (I'll bring up the quote specifically that I did not like. It also shows the praising if my Gord vote).
And yeah you do have preset reads as scum. A quick example is Sleepover mafia where you had a town read on me at the very start of the game while everyone else felt I was scum. Your read on me carried throught the game no matter how scummy I played and you never had any real reason for it. This is what I feel you were beginning to do here. It was like you assumed that I had town motives for:
-My questions for Ryu in RVS
-Calling TSN town with no reason around RVS.
-Voting Gordito with no reason.
Later on you continue with the assuption that I had town motives and claim that the points against me were minor. At this point I had:
-Claimed I knew who scum was.
-Claimed I would disappear (which I did).
-And claimed we would quick lynch when I returned.
Yet you didn't find any of these things questionable. You didn't have to gain a scum read from these, but you should have at the very least found them questionable. Which again is why I believe you already had a set take on my alignment.
I didn't praise you for voting Gorf. Where did you get that idea from?
Quoting in a sec.