I guarantee you after Erdrick "Kick Geno's ***, get into Smash" Dragon Quest it'll all be surprise characters
I mean, it’ll probably be surprises in the sense of “we haven’t had clues about them”. But i’m not totally sure they’d go for 4/5 complete surprises.
There’s definite value in throwing curveballs, but those should, imho, be offset with hype picks, and there are plenty of 3rd party picks that would satisfy that.
If it was like:
Joker
Erdrick
Chosen Undead
Leon/Jill
Surprise pick/pick number 5
It gives us a mix of “oh ****” and “WAIT WHAT THE ****”. It’s not lopsided, but keeps things fresh.
Also what the Smash internet fans see as surprises or “WOAH DIDNT SEE THAT COMING” doesn’t always align with what’s actually all that surprising.
The Belmont’s made complete sense for example, yet there was a good amount of people who were like, “who?”, or “Castlevania? You mean guy with the whip?”
Sakurai likes going for a mix of classics and modern picks, so I think he might do it again with this DLC. But we have roughly 20 days until we find out.