You know he wasn't talking about Minecraft Steve, right?
Hmm, I do agree here and there, though, while they didn't choose the best way to go about it with say, Wesker, Umbrella intention were always to create the perfect BOW via either the T-Virus, the G-Virus and the like. Mr.X & Nemesis notably were colossal human that looked more or less human while still being able to think and make decision like one, which make them truly scary opponent for our heroes to deal with (Well, more so Nemesis that Mr.X in the original, in the remake tho, yeah, he is going to give it to ya). So, with that logic in mind, I can see what they were going for with Wesker at first, Wesker being able to get the benefit of powerful BOW without, you know, changing into a horrible monster in the process, and keeping his mind and intelligence intact could have work to make the scariest opponent our heroes could have face (because as we know, human can become the greatest monsters of all at time). Instead tho, we got Agent Wesker doing Matrix-****, which while entertaining (to me atleast), isn't that scary in the slightest, and the cheesy comic-book one-liner he has in RE5 doesn't help either (even if I love them due to D.C. Douglas delivery, and RE5 in general is a game that I take less a horror game and more a really fun action shooter when you play with it someone, so, again, agree with you it's not scary, but I still found value in it).
That all being said, I just hope they don't throw Wesker out of the window in the remake continuity and try instead to make him fit with more realistic tone of it, cause man, I love the big *******, and I be a bit sad if he was just out of the picture for good. :/