I still want Ridley even though his chances arent looking as good as they once did with that recent video calling him a boss I still want to play as the Pirate King. Here is why I want Ridley and why I think Nintendo would be doing us all a disservice for not including him.
1. Metroid is arguably one of Nintendo's best franchises if not the best and the only character from Metroid to show up thus far is Samus (be it twice as both Varia and Zero suit thats still the same character). Metroid deserves more representation.
2. If not Ridley who could better be Samus arch enemy. You could argue Mother Brain or Dark Samus but they are confirmed as assist trophies and therefore out. They only other character that besides Ridley might work would be one of the hunters from either Metroid Prime 3: Corruption or Metroid Prime: Hunters which are far less interesting then Ridley way too obscure and Don't have the kinda personal connection for Samus' antagonistic relationship with Ridley. He killed her family remember that.
3. Ridley's size is irrelevant. No one is the size they are supposed to be. In past Mario games Bowser has been massive to the point where if he never made it into any of the super smash games past massive sizes such as his size in Super Mario Galaxy or Super Mario Sunshine could have been cited as proof he's too large. Also keep in mind Ridley's size in the intro to Super Smash Bros Melee was about the same size as everyone else. Ridley was roughly Samus' size in the original Metroid. AND if he was just a tiny bit smaller in Brawl he would have been playable size(well in his base form Meta-Ridley not so much lol). Also consider Omar. He is the size of a bug in the pikmin games yet they changed his size to make him fit the game. Why not do the same with Ridley?
4. Ridleys size is not his defining characteristic. He is a central antagonist to the Metroid franchise. He is a ranking member of Space Pirate High Command, the ruling council of the space pirates. Baring Mother Brain who just wouldn't work as a character anyway he is the perfect Metroid villain. Every Nintendo hero should be represented by a villain as well. Mario has Bowser, Link has Gannondorf, Kirby has Dee Dee Dee who does Samus have no one. Ridley is more then just a mindless big brute, that quota has already been filled with the likes of Bowser and Dee Dee Dee. Ridley is the diabolical villain who made Samus an orphan. Even with out his often massive size he is still intimidating for his iconic alien pterodactyl appearance with draconian features. Making him smaller will not detract from his look.
5. Does size really matter? It may be disappointing to some to see Ridley scaled down but would that really make the character unplayable? If scaling him down makes him playable I say do it. If we didnt scale olimar up we would have never gotten him as a character at all. Ridley would still be able to fly, breath fire, claw, and do all his cool stuff even if he's smaller.
6. Even if they intend him as a boss development is not over they could still change things and make him playable.
7. Nintendo has stated they would make free dlc this generation this could be like Martian Manhunter in Injustice he might appear as a dlc character.
8. Stages change as wii have seen with conductor toon link. Maybe hes only a boss/hazard on the firepit so long as he is unselected and replaced with Kraid or someone if ridley is selected.
9. Saukura is a notorious troll and has liked to play with our expectations in the past maybe hes doing so now.
10. Ridley has great potential for cool alternate costumes which I'd like to see implemented better regardless.
1. Yes, we love Metroid, but Japan doesn't so much. Metroid isn't nearly as big of a seller as Mario or Zelda, possibly even Kirby (granted all three have WAY more games, but still). Metroid is underrepresented though, I do agree. I also believe Samus/ZSS is the same because it's still Samus, playstyles don't matter to me on that front.
2. I actually thought Rundas would be an interesting character, but no one has the same backstory, and with DS confirmed as an assist trophy (I don't think anyone honestly thought Mama Brain was playable anyways), Ridley would be the go-to villain for Metroid, were they to do one. He killed her entire colony besides her, by the way, not just her parents.
3. We all know this, but the toobigots will NEVER agree with you there. However, until we get a confirmation, they're as right as we are for speculating because he's not confirmed yet/isn't ever confirmed.
4. Kirby's villains aren't DDD and MK. They're Marx, Dyna Blade, Magolor, etc. However, yes, every major Nintendo series has a villain. Ridley's a very iconic Metroid character, but that doesn't mean he's a shoe-in. Others have been left out before.
5. Size can be an issue if he is very large, meaning he has way more hitboxes and thus is easy to get destroyed by a faster character, even if he's not uber slow. That's part of the toobigot's argument, and that one actually has some merit. If I wanna play as Ridley, I wanna bash some skulls, not be a rag doll.
6. If he's implemented as a boss only, his development is more than likely done by now. If they're implementing him as playable, then he might have some tweaks before the release. You gotta figure that the 3DS version has to be g2g in just a few months. The major stuff should be done by now.
7. I don't want DLC for Smash, because then everyone's still gonna have hopes about their guy that didn't make the cut. I'd argue that it'd be way more deflating if they had DLC and Ridley still wasn't included after all the DLC. Double gut punch and heart ripped out if that does happen.
8. The Toon Link one makes perfect sense, though. As much as I love Kraid, I can't see him making it back in like that. I think if Ridley's selected, he just won't be there, period. Maybe the lava will be a hazard or something, but I can't see them randomly throwing in Kraid like that. It wouldn't feel right.
9. Like the GameFAQs post earlier, Ridley is in the same boat as Palutena, and most people think she's in. Sakurai did about the same thing with her, so we'll see.
10. This is what I'm hoping for most if he's in. You could be any Ridley you want: Super, Meta, Omega, X-Ridley, Other M, and probably Zero Mission.