The ‘Would you rather have in smash?’ game thread

[Wario Wario Wario]

Tetromino

WYR have Mr. Stevenson from Gumshoe as a Duck Hunt Isabelle-clone (neutral and down special moves and all 3 Smash Attacks shared, nothing else) or Paula as a Ness echo?

 

[RealPokeFan11]

Mr Stevenson

WYR Have Elite Barbarians or Royal Giant playable?

 

[ShadowYoshi04]

I don't know who either of them are...Royal sounds better though.

WYR have the Grinch theory be real or fake?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Hard choice, but I'd have to go with fake, just because while I am excited for Chorus Kids and Banjo, I'll be honest and say Excitebiker >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Mach Rider.

WYR have Stage Builder with custom graphics (so, if you wanted to add a picture of Shrek, you could use a hypothetical Switch browser to find one), or an alt costume customiser? (so if you want Mario to look like flying Mario you could change his colours to look as such). neither would be available online, and the Swtich browser is added either way.

 

[RealPokeFan11]

The Royal Giant and Elite Barbarians are 2 cards from Clash Royale that are widely hated by the community and are often referred to as "cancer cards"

I'm on team real with this leak. It pleases all audiences and makes me want the game more and more. (BANJO!)

Alt costume customizer. I can now play as Thanos.

WYR have fortnite or roblox representation?

 

[ZagarTulip]

Fortnite

WYR have Mipha or Revali as a playable DLC character?

 

[RealPokeFan11]

My god this one's tough... I like both characters a lot too. Revali is really cool but reminds me too much of Falco. Mipha is different enough and represents the Zora race, while using water abilities, an underrepresented element in the Smash roster. All we have is Greninja and Corrin I think..? (Correct me if I'm wrong.) I'm picking Mipha!

WYR Have Alola Island Tour or Ultra Space as a new Pokémon stage?

 

[ZagarTulip]

My god this one's tough... I like both characters a lot too. Revali is really cool but reminds me too much of Falco. Mipha is different enough and represents the Zora race, while using water abilities, an underrepresented element in the Smash roster. All we have is Greninja and Corrin I think..? AND Squirtle now (Correct me if I'm wrong.) I'm picking Mipha!

WYR Have Alola Island Tour or Ultra Space as a new Pokémon stage?

Ultra Space

WYR have Wolf or Mewtwo get a unique victory theme?

 

[LoZ00]

Ultra Space

WYR have Wolf or Mewtwo get a unique victory theme?

Wolf

WYR have Ray, Monster Hunter or Dixie Kong as the first DLX character?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Dixie Kong (the hell is a DLX?)

WYR have Chip McCallahan (from Chip's Challenge) or the SkiFree Yeti playable?

 

[Luigifan18]

Dixie Kong (the hell is a DLX?)

WYR have Chip McCallahan (from Chip's Challenge) or the SkiFree Yeti playable?

Chip

WYR have an official Turbo Mode (from Project M) or some form of Puttsun Cancel (from JJBAASB)?

 

[ShadowYoshi04]

Turbo Mode

WYR have a Monster Hunter character or a Dragon Quest character?

 

[ABalloon]

-Better For Glory
-No Rage Mechanics
-No Staling Mechanics
-More Third Party Characters
-A certain Bandicoot
-Less FE Reps (I'd like it to go Mario has the most Reps, then Pokémon, then Zelda, THEN FE, then Kirby and Metroid etc)
-More faster (Melee side kicking in)
-3 to 4 stocks in competitive
-More offensive rather than usual defensive play in SSB4
-Combos....Percent....DAMAGE!
-1 Broken character. Aw cmon, we need one insanely fun but broken character in the game (Pls make Crash top 2)
-Less Echos. Sakurai is starting to get crazy with Echos
-More Crazy fighters. I support torns of impossible-characters-who-have-no-potential-to-get in the game. It's what makes the game fun.
- ~80 fighter cap. Lets not reach 100 Sakurai...
-Add Subspace Emissary 2 (SPIRIT MODE HYPE)
-DLC characters should be somewhat "good" if you understand what I mean
-No meme characters. I'm the only Waluigi opposer out here. Thank God the meme is dead. Now lets deconfirm TCK next please. (Please Grinch..Don't do this)
-More third party assist trophies
-No Anime **** at all. Take that weebery to JumpForce (Which I'm Buying)
-PC port
-Isaac as $1000 DLC to trigger the GS fans

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Dragon Quest

WYR have Mr. Stevenson from Gumshoe, Excitebiker from Excitebike or Muddy Mole from Mole Mania replace Mach Rider?

-Isaac as $1000 DLC to trigger the GS fans

dude, that's not funny, that's just being a huge jerk.

 

[ABalloon]

Note to self, never joke about Isaac.

 

[BarDulL]

Dragon Quest

WYR have Mr. Stevenson from Gumshoe, Excitebiker from Excitebike or Muddy Mole from Mole Mania replace Mach Rider?

Mr. Stevenson for sure. The world needs more ballin' detectives.

WYR the Phoenix Wright series or the Professor Layton series have representation in Smash?

Note to self, never joke about Isaac.

It's one of those hit or miss jokes, some would laugh and others would not lol.

More importantly though, you're missing the point of the thread! This is a "would you rather" game thread. Basically in this thread, you're supposed to answer and ask a "Would You Rather" (or "WYR" for short) question afterwards. Soon after, generally someone else will answer your WYR question and then they will ask their own WYR question, and the thread goes on infinitely until it reaches the stars.

EX:

Someone posts "WYR have Godzilla or Megatron in Smash as a playable character?"

At which point someone else will answer either "Godzilla" or "Megatron," and then they will ask a new WYR question.

I think your earlier post is probably better for the Smash Ultimate forum.

 

[ABalloon]

Lol I'm new so it's obvious

 

[RealPokeFan11]

Professor Layton.

WYR never have Steve get in Smash, let him in as DLC, or let him in just to beat him up?

 

[ShadowYoshi04]

Never

Would you rather have Smash be made into a Street Fighter-style game, Mortal Kombat-style game, Killer Instinct-style game, or Dead or Alive-style game?

 

[Champion of Hyrule]

Mortal Kombat because those fatalities would be weird in smash


Would you rather have adventure mode and no classic or not

 

[ZagarTulip]

Adventure Mode imo is more fun than Classic (Even though I find Classic fun, I'd still be willing to sacrifice it)

WYR have Wigglytuff or Raichu as a playable character?

 

[UtopianPoyzin]

I'd be fine with Raichu as an echo of Pikachu to be honest. Unpopular opinion. Do I actually want Raichu? No, not at all. Better than Wigglytuff though.

Would you rather see Dry Bowser as an 9th alt costume of Bowser, or Octoling (Agent 8) as a 9th alt costume for Inkling? We know that there are sometimes 9 alt costumes, for Ridley has 8 alt costumes, and a 9th alt costume for Meta Ridley.

 

[ShadowYoshi04]

Dry Bowser without a doubt.

WYR have Octolings be base or dlc?

 

[UtopianPoyzin]

DLC for sure. Glad you picked Dry Bowser though, I'm really hoping he makes it in. Would you rather only get the characters announced in the Grinch leak and nothing else, or only 7 characters that were NOT part of the Grinch leak (5 newcomers and 2 echoes)? If you want the second option, who would they be?

 

[Champion of Hyrule]

7: Impa, Quote, Waluigi, Rex, Kohga
Shadow (Sonic) Dark Link (Link)

 

[ZagarTulip]

I don't see a question above me so

WYR have Poochy or Skull Kid as the next DLC character?

 

[UtopianPoyzin]

I would rather see Skull Kid, but he got axed as a new character because he is now an assist trophy.

7: Impa, Quote, Waluigi, Rex, Kohga
Shadow (Sonic) Dark Link (Link)

OH YEAH!! Glad to see another Quote supporter Champion of Hyrule ! I had been nominating him nonstop over on the Rate Their Chances thread for over a month, but after this final Direct, we are wiping the nominations list, so Quote was being erased from the nominations with just under 100 nominations. What do you say we both nominate him together to get his chances rated as DLC (sorry if this sounds like an advertisement)

Oh yeah, a new question.

Would you rather get 5 new DLC fighters that are all current assist trophies, and get their assist trophy taken away and replaced by another character from their series?

OR

Would you rather get 5 new DLC fighters that are neither assist trophies nor currently known Spirits?

For either option, name your 5 characters.

 

[Luigifan18]

Replacing Assist Trophies: Bomberman, Krystal, Isaac, Lyn, and Shadow become playable, and are replaced with Max, Leon, Matthew, Serra, and Silver, respectively, as Assist Trophies.

Would you rather have Tabuu team up with Galeem or Galeem upstaged by Hades (Kid Icarus) and Zero (Kirby) as a secret superboss in World of Light?

 

[UtopianPoyzin]

I'd personally like to see Tabuu team up with Galeem; I love Hades and think he would be a great fighter to include as the Kid Icarus villain, but I feel like him and Zero don't exactly fit the bill as bosses in the new adventure mode. They seem too underwhelming compared to giants like Galleom and Gallem. They don't seem like they would be good bosses is all I'm saying, based off of what we have seen so far. Are they controlled by Galeem? Are they destroying the whole population except for Kirby out of personal gain? That doesn't fit Hades character model, neither Zero's. Tabuu might. If Hades and Zero are possessed by Galeem, then they really aren't bosses and are rather minions. I compare Hades to Ganondorf, and and I can't see Ganondorf as a full-scaled boss character. Calamity Ganon is a maybe, but that wasn't the question. Calamity Ganon, Galleom, and Rathalos are monsters. Hades is just a villain. A main villain, but a villain. So I pick Tabuu.

WYR have 5 1st party DLC, or 5 3rd party DLC. For each option, say who.

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

5 1st party. Waluigi, Jill, Muddy Mole, Excitebiker and Tingle

WYR have Bubsy appear as a Spirit, or Oinker P. Hammm (another character from the Bubsy series) appear as a boss in World of Light?

 

[UtopianPoyzin]

Bubsy as a Spirit, for once again, Oinker doesn't fit the bill as a boss character with the size of everything else.

Would you rather get Minecraft or Undertale content?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Minecraft

WYR have Excitebiker or Mach Rider?

 

[UtopianPoyzin]

Mach. Would you rather have Bandana Dee or Geno as DLC?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Geno

WYR have Plok as a Spirit using artwork from the SNES original

or the webcomic?

 

[Champion of Hyrule]

The original one from SNES

WYR have all spirits be playable or not

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

No. way too much dev time for Sakurai.

WYR have a Pepsiman spirit or a Bubsy spirit?

 

[Dyllybirdy]

A Pepsiman spirit.

WYR have the character of Rottytops (from the Shantae series) be a spirit using the Risky's Revenge art style, or Half-Genie Hero's?

Spoiler

Risky's Revenge:

Half-Genie Hero:

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Half-Genie Hero.

continuing from the last question: WYR have a Pepsiman spirit be labelled as part of the "Pepsiman series" or just the "Pepsi series"?

 

[Champion of Hyrule]

Pepsiman series.

WYR have Dark Link be playable or Shadow Kirby?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Dark Link.

WYR have Spirits of Sony and Microsoft characters, or Spirits of non-game characters from game series? (for example Oogtar or Scourge the Hedgehog)