The ‘Would you rather have in smash?’ game thread

[CodakTheWarrior]

E rated, makes far more sense for smash.

WYR declone Ganondorf but never declone any of the other clones, or vice versa?

 

[osby]

E rated, makes far more sense for smash.

WYR declone Ganondorf but never declone any of the other clones, or vice versa?

Declone Ganondorf, I guess? I don't really have a problem with any clones' movesets but people seems to really want a change in his one.
Jokes about Peach/Link/Zelda love triangle or Zelda/Dedede?

 

[CodakTheWarrior]

Zelda/Dedede easy


WYR have Skull Kid or Tingle as characters?

 

[osby]

Zelda/Dedede easy


WYR have Skull Kid or Tingle as characters?

God, Skull Kid, please.
WYR have Cranky Kong or Dixie Kong as a newcomer?

 

[CodakTheWarrior]

Dixie, it's absurd to me that she hasn't been in Smash yet after all these years.

WYR have Pichu and Squirtle come back, or have Ivysaur and Young Link come back?

 

[Zeth444]

Pichu and Squirtle is too easy of an answer to me.

WYR have Pachirisu with pichu moveset or as an entirely new pikachu clone?

 

[CodakTheWarrior]

A new pika clone I'd say.

WYR cut all of Brawl's newcomers or all of Smash 4's newcomers?

 

[Freduardo]

A new pika clone I'd say.

WYR cut all of Brawl's newcomers or all of Smash 4's newcomers?

You’re asking me to pick between ROB and Mac?

You monster.

Diddy and Dedede made me know I’m dropping 4’s.

I wanted Mac for so long.

WYR Two Splatoon playable Reps or two ARMs playable reps.

 

[CodakTheWarrior]

Probably two Splatoon reps, Inkling and Octoling as a last minute clone. For ARMS, we could have Spring Man with Springtron as an alt.

WYR have King Boo as playable or as an assist trophy/stage hazard?

 

[Zinith]

Assist Trophy

WYR have Boshi (from SMRPG) or Kid Koopa (from Mario Party)

 

[CodakTheWarrior]

Boshi to confuse everyone.

WYR have your one dream, most wanted newcomer added as playable but have your current main cut, or leave the main out to save your main?

 

[Sarki Soliloquy]

Honestly, dream newcomer for main.

WYR cut Shiek, Ganondorf, & Falco OR subtract from any of the Original 12?

 

[CodakTheWarrior]

Realistically, I would have to keep Shiek, Ganondorf, and Falco and cut Jiggles from the og 12.


WYR have Decidueye or a Gen 8 Pokémon join the game?

 

[FamicomDisk]

Going to go with Decidueye simply because I don’t know any Gen 8 Pokémon yet.

Would you rather they put in Geno, or a partner from Paper Mario or TTYD?

 

[Pizza Robo]

Geno
Would you rather have Lord Raptor(Darkstalkers) to be playable in Smash Bros 5 or Hakan(Super Street Fighter 4) playable in Smash Bros 5

 

[osby]

Lord Raptor
WYR have Melee modes but Brawl mechanics or Brawl modes with Wii U mechanics?

 

[Sage of Ice]

brawl modes, wii u mechanics. melee's targets were better but SSE blew adventure mode out of the water. and wii u had the best handling in the entire series, a perfect balance of melee and brawl. it's a fair compromise

WYR 18 newcomers that all come from established games like mario and star fox, or only 6 newcomers but they're all from currently unrepresented games? (this one's super easy for me but i wanna see what someone else thinks)

 

[Nu~]

My dream list shall now be complete

Spoiler

Kirby
Marx
Magalor
Galacta Knight
Bandana Dee

Star Fox
Krystal
Panther
Leon

Metroid
Ridley
Rundas

Fire Emblem
Chrom
Anna
Lyn
Leif

Donkey Kong
Funky Kong
Cranky Kong
Dixie Kong

And 3rd parties too!

Mega Man
Zero (Mega Man Zero version)

Pac-Man
Spooky

I reealllly want Crash but I gotta take the 18 no question. So many chars to choose from.


WYR your favorite character be top tier in the next game, or your least favorite character be bottom tier in the next game

 

[Zinith]

Yoshi top tier anyday, I don't even mind if Shiek is above him on the tier list...

WYR have Fi or Adam Malkavich?
(Spicy choice of chars there)

 

[osby]

Yoshi top tier anyday, I don't even mind if Shiek is above him on the tier list...

WYR have Fi or Adam Malkavich?
(Spicy choice of chars there)

Fi, at least she has a interesting design.
WYR have Dark Samus or Waluigi?

 

[Jeck]

Waluigi because oddly enough I think he'd be less of a clone if they did make him.

Would you rather cut Corneria and Onett from the next game and get to choose any other past stage to replace them,
OR
Would you rather have both of them return?

 

[osby]

Waluigi because oddly enough I think he'd be less of a clone if they did make him.

Would you rather cut Corneria and Onett from the next game and get to choose any other past stage to replace them,
OR
Would you rather have both of them return?

Both of them return, I'm bad at selecting stages.
WYR have three more unique tournament legal stages or just Omega mode for all stages?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

More unique tournament legal stages

Would you rather have every Mario Odyssey outfit be an alt for every character, or moveset swaps to become official?

 

[CodakTheWarrior]

Move set swaps become official.


WYR have Metal Sonic as a Sonic alt, or in as a last minute clone character?

 

[osby]

Move set swaps become official.


WYR have Metal Sonic as a Sonic alt, or in as a last minute clone character?

Clone character. He doesn't make much sense as an alt.
WYR have a modern Pac-Man skin or Ms. Pac-Man alt?

 

[CodakTheWarrior]

Ms Pac-Man alt, I can't stand modern Pacman's design.

WYR have a Dry Bowser alt for Bowser, or a Mr L alt for Luigi?

 

[osby]

Ms Pac-Man alt, I can't stand modern Pacman's design.

WYR have a Dry Bowser alt for Bowser, or a Mr L alt for Luigi?

Dry Bowser. I love his design.
WYR have all the music in the past games to return uncut but no remixes... or only as much music as Wii U version but with remixes of half of them?

 

[Zeth444]

All musics from old games

WYR have only pikachu as returning pokemon or all returning pokemon - pikachu

 

[CodakTheWarrior]

All others minus Pika, meaning Pichu could come back and finally rise above his evolved, more popular counterpart...

WYR Dixie and Funky Kong included in the game with Funky as a last minute clone,or have neither and get K. Rool instead?

 

[osby]

All others minus Pika, meaning Pichu could come back and finally rise above his evolved, more popular counterpart...

WYR Dixie and Funky Kong included in the game with Funky as a last minute clone,or have neither and get K. Rool instead?

Funky and Dixie of course.
Neither makes sense but have Ridley as a Charizard clone or King K.Rool as a Dedede clone?

 

[CodakTheWarrior]

K Rool as a D3 clone I'd say, Ridley is just too different from Charizard.

WYR cut Jigglypuff or Mewtwo?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Mewtwo

WYR have the Flat Zone 1 and 2 songs return, or get replaced by the arranged G&W Gallery music?

 

[ZagarTulip]

Have FZ 1 and 2 songs return

Would you rather have Baby Mario or Kamek playable?

 

[Zhadgon]

Ridley as Charizard Clone.

Edited;
Kamek.

WYR have Sonic / Ryu or Mega Man / Bayonetta / Cloud or Pac-Man / Snake in the next Smash, you can only choose one batch.

.n_n.

 

[CodakTheWarrior]

Veeery tough choice but I'd say Pacman/ Cloud.


WYR buff Cloud more or nerf Zelda more?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

nerf Zelda

WYR have Miss Warp from Yoshi's Story playable, or the scary unused face from Wario Land 3 as a stage?

 

[osby]

Veeery tough choice but I'd say Pacman/ Cloud.


WYR buff Cloud more or nerf Zelda more?

Buff Cloud more.
WYR get KOed by Zelda's Lightning Kicks or Captain Falcon's Knee?

 

[CodakTheWarrior]

The Captain's knee, the best way to go out...

WYR cut your main or leave your main but have extremely cringey characters like Shrek, Freddy Fazbear, and Spongebob join?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Shrek, Freddy and SpongeBob. also, the correct word is cringeworthy.

WYR have non-Omega tournament legal alts for each stage a la Legacy TE or have alts for every stage that is the same thing as the existing stage but with an N64 graphical style?

 

[CodakTheWarrior]

N64 style would be soooo cool.


WYR have more retro characters (like Excitebiker/Takamuru) or more surprise/joke characters (like Reckless Safety Man/Labo Bot)?