The ‘Would you rather have in smash?’ game thread

[Wario Wario Wario]

return of tripping

WYR have a character you don't like from a game/series you do, or vice versa?

 

[CrusherMania1592]

A characte rthat I like from a game/series. Can't stand characters I don't like


Would you rather include 6 new Pokemon from the same Generation or 6 new Pokemon, 1 from each generation?

 

[nirvanafan]

1 per gen
Would you rather have Star Fox or Kid Icarus cut down to 1 rep

 

[Carrill]

Star Fox. At least it would only be cutting a clone and not a unique character like Palutena.

Do you want Anduin Wrynn or Sylvanas Windrunner as the 3rd party rep announced at E3?

 

[Mega Bidoof]

Star Fox being cut down. While I think Star Fox would deserve more reps due to its staying power, having more games than Kid Icarus, I’d rather have Falco cut over Palutena, as Falco is a semi-clone and Palutena has a completely unique moveset.

WYR have Crash or Spyro

EDIT: Oops, uh, I guess I’d have Aduin because he kinda looks cooler. I don’t know anything about WOW.

WYR have Crash or Spyro

 

[LoZ00]

Star Fox being cut down. While I think Star Fox would deserve more reps due to its staying power, having more games than Kid Icarus, I’d rather have Falco cut over Palutena, as Falco is a semi-clone and Palutena has a completely unique moveset.

WYR have Crash or Spyro

EDIT: Oops, uh, I guess I’d have Aduin because he kinda looks cooler. I don’t know anything about WOW.

WYR have Crash or Spyro

Spyro
I grew up playing Spyro the Dragon and the sequels. I would love Spyro in Smash, perhaps more than any other 3rd party, except for an Undertale character.

Speaking of Undertale...
WYR have Frisk or Sans to join the Smash crew?

 

[Violenceman]

Spyro
I grew up playing Spyro the Dragon and the sequels. I would love Spyro in Smash, perhaps more than any other 3rd party, except for an Undertale character.

Speaking of Undertale...
WYR have Frisk or Sans to join the Smash crew?

Sans. There's a lot more you could do with him mechanically and visually than Frisk.

Let's say we get a Sonic Mania stage; Studiopolis Zone or Press Garden Zone?

 

[ShadowYoshi04]

Haven’t played Sonic Mania, but Studiopolis Zone sounds cool.

WYR have 1-5 DLC or 6-10 DLC Characters?

 

[Mega Bidoof]

6-10, the more the merrier. Hopefully there’s more Nintendo newcomers than third party newcomers in the DLC this time around...

WYR have 8-player Smash return or Ice Climbers at the expense of it?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Ice Climbers

WYR have R.O.B. have his base from the Smash series (the propellers) or his base from the actual toy? (plain grey with a battery slot) no effect on gameplay either way.

 

[Zinith]

Propellers

WRY have Yoshi gain a tether recovery or a revamped Side-B?
(Yes, I am one of those people)

 

[Zeth444]

Tether, to see him hanging from his tung would be hella funny.

WYR have gen 1 startera + pika as the only pokemon representative or gen 6 'n 7.

 

[Jeck]

Gen 1 only. It's so much more wholesome and easy to get it right that way.

Earthbound question! Would you rather have the Runaway Five as a character or as a stage with their music playing?

 

[CodakTheWarrior]

A stage with their music, unfortunately Earthbound isn't iconic enough for a other character right now.

WYR have Ganon (pig form) added as a character and have the current Ganondorf stay the same, or have Ganondorf be completely rehauled and receive no Zelda newcomer?

 

[GreenOfRain]

Ganon (Pig Form). The lack of an opportunity for a newcomer from BOTW would be crippling.

WYR have 3 playable alola pokemon, or no playable alola with most of the region's pokemon being pokeball pokemon?

 

[Zhadgon]

Have 3 playable alola pokemon.

WYR have King K. Rool or Ridley playable?

.n_n.

 

[CodakTheWarrior]

You are evil... I'd have to say K Rool.

WYR cut Shiek in exchange for Impa or cut Zamus in exchange for Dark Samus?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Dark Samus

Would you rather have Chain Chomp promoted to a playable character or demoted to an item?

 

[Jeck]

Ehhhh I'm gonna say item.

Would you rather have Thwomp or the Wii Balance Board become playable characters?

 

[CodakTheWarrior]

Balance board for the lols


WYR have Spongebob or Freddy Fazbear join as playable?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

SpongeBob

would you rather have Tin Star

playable and Jill

an Assist Trophy or vice versa?

 

[CodakTheWarrior]

Vice versa


WYR have smash 5 have an incredible story mode but be the worst by far competitively, or don't have any sort of story mode and be the best game competitively?

 

[osby]

Story mode but no competitive value. People can keep playing Melee if they want.

WYR have Shadow Queen as Peach alt or Daisy as a Peach clone?

 

[CodakTheWarrior]

Daisy as clone, people really want her in, and the more the merrier since clones don't hurt anything.

WYR have Wreckless Safety Man or Monita from Nintendo Land as a new surprise/joke character?

 

[BlazingFireOmega]

Monita

Would you rather have hud/menu dlc or music dlc?

 

[Zerp]

Music DLC

Would you rather have Sakurai brutally deconfirm your most wanted newcomer in a trailer dedicated entirely to making fun of that character or have the same thing happen to your most wanted veteran?

 

[Zinith]

Newcomer

WYR have a reworked Ganondorf but only mid-tier or the same Ganondorf BUT buffed heavily to become top-tier

 

[Zeth444]

Reworked , as long as it's a fun character to play as. I actually think a lot of characters could use a rework, like mario and T-Link received.

WYR have odissey based mario rework or botw based link rework.

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

as a Mario quadary (yes, I play that many characters), BOTW Link

Would you rather have this be the only song on your favourite stage:

or have it cut all together?

 

[Zhadgon]

Have it cut all together.

Would you rather have Ice Climbers back or Rosalina, you can choose only one.

.n_n.

 

[CodakTheWarrior]

Tough choice, but Ice Climbers because of popularity.


WYR have Wolf or Bowser Jr return?

 

[osby]

Tough choice, but Ice Climbers because of popularity.


WYR have Wolf or Bowser Jr return?

Ice Climbers more popular than Rosalina?

It's a really tough choise but I'd say Bowser Jr.
WYR nerf Jigglypuff or buff Bayonetta?

 

[CodakTheWarrior]

Wow another incredibly tough one, but I'd have to say nerf Jiggles.

WYR have no third parties at all or your five mains cut?

 

[osby]

Wow another incredibly tough one, but I'd have to say nerf Jiggles.

WYR have no third parties at all or your five mains cut?

No new third parties or none at all? Eh, Sonic is one of my favourite characters but I can't play him at all so I guess no third parties.

WYR have Alph as his own character or Lucina as an alternate choise to Marth?

 

[CodakTheWarrior]

Prob Alph as his own character, hey could use rock pikmin to make him somewhat unique.


WYR have Board the Platforms come back or have an individualized target smash again?

 

[osby]

Prob Alph as his own character, hey could use rock pikmin to make him somewhat unique.


WYR have Board the Platforms come back or have an individualized target smash again?

I thought about that too, but how different can Rock Pikmin be from Purple ones? Eh, they'll find a way.

Board the Platforms. It's ridiculous to have individual stages for 50+ characters.
WYR have stickers back or have less trophies?

 

[CodakTheWarrior]

Have stickers back, even though I didn't use the feature it wouldn't hurt to have.

WYR have Shadow or Metal Sonic as a Sonic clone?

 

[osby]

Have stickers back, even though I didn't use the feature it wouldn't hurt to have.

WYR have Shadow or Metal Sonic as a Sonic clone?

Shadow, of course.
WYR have Morrigan or Amaterasu as a really unrelated Capcom character in Smash?

 

[CodakTheWarrior]

I suppose Amaterasu, though the ideal capcom rep for me would be Phoenix wright.

WYR Sega or Capcom get another rep?

 

[osby]

I suppose Amaterasu, though the ideal capcom rep for me would be Phoenix wright.

WYR Sega or Capcom get another rep?

Though. I guess Capcom, since it seems it can give more popular characters than Sega (Sonic ones don't count).
WYR have a newcomer from a M rated franchise or an E rated one?