The ‘Would you rather have in smash?’ game thread

[Autumn ♫]

3rd gen! Pokemon Sapphire was my first Pokemon game, and still one of my favorites!

WYR have an anime character, or a live action movie character playable? (James Bond, for example)

 

[Zeth444]

Put in Indiana Jones

WYR Have Rocket league car as a character or Have youre main as DLC?

 

[CodakTheWarrior]

Rocket league car as character, why not

WYR have E Gadd or King Boo as a Luigi's Mansion rep?

 

[Blargg888]

Rocket league car as character, why not

WYR have E Gadd or King Boo as a Luigi's Mansion rep?

E Gadd. Potential for a Poltergust based moveset there.

Would You Rather have a new character that wields magic, or a new character that wields a Staff?

 

[Ze Diglett]

Magic, easy. Two magic users is way too few for a such a common category with so much potential.

Would you rather have Tingle as a joke character, or Lightning McQueen?

 

[Blargg888]

Magic, easy. Two magic users is way too few for a such a common category with so much potential.

Would you rather have Tingle as a joke character, or Lightning McQueen?

Tingle Tingle Kooloo Limpah!

Would You Rather have a new stage with falling rock hazards, or a new stage with lightning hazards?

 

[Autumn ♫]

Lightning Hazards!

WYR have newcomers focused on unrepresented franchises, or focused on already established franchises?

 

[CodakTheWarrior]

Tbh already represented so we can finally get characters like K Rool, Ridley, and Waluigi.

WYR cut Megaman or Pacman?

 

[ZagarTulip]

Tbh already represented so we can finally get characters like K Rool, Ridley, and Waluigi.

WYR cut Megaman or Pacman?

Mega Man

Would you rather have Rainbow Road or Lumiose City return?

 

[BlazingFireOmega]

WYR cut Megaman or Pacman?

Cut Pac-Man. MegaMan's got more moveset potential than a circle that eats dots.

Would you rather have Rainbow Road or Lumiose City return?

Lumiose City.

WYR have the next Square Enix rep be Geno from Super Mario RPG or Black Mage from the Final Fantasy series?

 

[Autumn ♫]

Geno, I don't know much about him, but seeing people who have wanted him for forever see him get in would be amazing.

WYR have our next Capcom character be Phoenix Wright, or a Monster Hunter character?

 

[CodakTheWarrior]

Phoenix Wright, he's my third most wanted newcomer ever and I would flip if he got in.

WYR cut all of melee' s newcomers or cut all of brawl AND smash 4's newcomers?

 

[osby]

Cut all of the Melee's newcomers.
Smash For newcomers: base game ones or DLC ones (or Miis, if you prefer)?

 

[ZagarTulip]

DLC

Would you rather have Riolu or Igglybuff as a playable character?

 

[Deleted member]

It’s a straightforward game. Come up with two possible things that can be included in Smash.

They can be anything. A gamepl

It’s a straightforward game. Come up with two possible things that can be included in Smash.

They can be anything. A gameplay mechanic, a mode, a stage, a poke ball, a character, a circumstance, whatever. The only rule is it has to be in regards to Smash brothers switch. So the first poster posts:

“Would you rather have rayquaza as a poke ball summon or as a stage hazard?”

And then, the next guy posts:

“Stage Hazard” (unless he wanted pokeball summon, then he should have posted that.)

BUT HE’S NOT DONE! To keep the game going not only does he say what he’d rather want, he posts his own brand spanking new question with new circumstances. So he should post:

“Stage Hazard.

Would you rather have more smash run stages or a revitalized Smash tour?”


So yeah. There you go.

Would you rather have more smash run stages or a revitalized Smash tour?

ay mechanic, a mode, a stage, a poke ball, a character, a circumstance, whatever. The only rule is it has to be in regards to Smash brothers switch. So the first poster posts:

“Would you rather have rayquaza as a poke ball summon or as a stage hazard?”

And then, the next guy posts:

“Stage Hazard” (unless he wanted pokeball summon, then he should have posted that.)

BUT HE’S NOT DONE! To keep the game going not only does he say what he’d rather want, he posts his own brand spanking new question with new circumstances. So he should post:

“Stage Hazard.

Would you rather have more smash run stages or a revitalized Smash tour?”


So yeah. There you go.

Would you rather have more smash run stages or a revitalized Smash tour?

Would you rather have *Communism* or *the Third Reich*

 

[Zinith]

Would you rather have *Communism* or *the Third Reich*

There's hardly a difference in my eyes.

 

[Autumn ♫]

omg, way getting off topic.

DLC

Would you rather have Riolu or Igglybuff as a playable character?

Riolu, I don't care for Igglybuff much.

Would you rather have *Communism* or *the Third Reich*

Communism, because communism good and Nazis are incredibly bad.

WYR have Arena Ferox return or The Coliseum?

 

[Ze Diglett]

Arena Ferox. The less walkoffs in my Smash game, the better.

Would you rather have Poke Floats or Fourside?

 

[Freduardo]

Arena Ferox. The less walkoffs in my Smash game, the better.

Would you rather have Poke Floats or Fourside?

Tough one. I think Poke Floats, but it’s close.

WYR Stanley the Bugman and DK Jr as assist trophies or Kiddy Kong and Chunky Kong as assist trophies

 

[ZagarTulip]

Stanley the Bugman and DK Jr.

Would you rather add more Street Fighter Stage Music or add more Final Fantasy Stage Music?

 

[Applebutter61]

Street Fighter Music

Would you rather have Mystery Dungeon (any one) music or Pokemon Battle Revolution music?

 

[ZagarTulip]

Street Fighter Music

Would you rather have Mystery Dungeon (any one) music or Pokemon Battle Revolution music?

Battle Revolution

Would you rather have Steve from Minecraft or Banjo and Kazooie playable?

 

[Diddy Kong]

BANJO-KAZOOIE! Without a second of doubt!

Would you rather have revamped veterans and them being more true to their root origins or more newcomers?

 

[osby]

More newcomers, all of them are pretty faithful to their origin anyway.
WYR have 8-player Smash with all Ice Climbers or 48 Pikmin?

 

[ZagarTulip]

48 Pikmin sounds awesome

Would you rather add Samurai Goroh from F - Zero or Micaiah from Fire Emblem as a playable character?

 

[osby]

Samurai Goroh, I don't need to know anything about him to know he's awesome.
WYR have item switch constantly on or off?

 

[Diddy Kong]

Off. For Glory ftw baby

Adventure Mode or a new Subspace Emissary?

 

[Ze Diglett]

SSE, by far. Classic mode with two platforming segments is just lame, and that's coming from someone who grew up with Melee Adventure Mode.

Mimikyu as a playable character, or as a Pokeball summon?

 

[osby]

Hard question. I'd like to see him as playable, but I'll say Pokeball summon.
WYR have Sheik or Zero Suit Samus to be confirmed as returning?

 

[ZagarTulip]

I honestly prefer Sheik

Would you rather have Duck Hunt or Wii Fit Trainer return if you had to pick one?

 

[osby]

Wii Fit Trainer. I love both though.
WYR have a Panel de Pon stage or a Mysterious Murasame Castle one?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Panel de Pon if it is correctly refered to as Tetris Attack, Murasame otherwise.

3-way WYR this time: WYR have the Bowlo, Vampire or Thwomp Candy from Mario Party 8 as an item?

 

[ZagarTulip]

Thwomp Candy

Would you rather have Sheik get a new Final Smash or have Falco get a new Final Smash?

 

[Ze Diglett]

Falco. Sheik sharing a FS with Zelda at least makes sense, considering they're the same character.

WYR have Captain Toad as a newcomer, or regular Toad?

 

[SvartWolf]

Falco. Sheik sharing a FS with Zelda at least makes sense, considering they're the same character.

WYR have Captain Toad as a newcomer, or regular Toad?

Captain toad

WYR have more smash or more bros?

 

[osby]

More bros all the way.
WYR have more bash sisters or more really rottens?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Really Rottens. guessing that means villains, correct?

Would you rather have Bowser get his armoured form from Yoshi's Safari as an alt, or Wario get his WarioWare D.I.Y. outfit as an alt?

 

[ZagarTulip]

Yoshi's Safari Bowser

Would you rather have Tiny Kong or Lanky Kong Playable?

 

[Tedawesome]

Yoshi's Safari Bowser

Would you rather have Tiny Kong or Lanky Kong Playable?

He has no style, he has no grace, I would prefer Lanky to take a space.

Would you rather bring back tripping or not be able to turn of items?

 

[osby]

He has no style, he has no grace, I would prefer Lanky to take a space.

Would you rather bring back tripping or not be able to turn of items?

Not being able to turn off items all the way. We play like casuals.
WYR have new stages with just platform differences or with stage hazards?