The ‘Would you rather have in smash?’ game thread

[osby]

Lose omega stages. They were cool in For Glory but not really necessary.
WYR cut all Donkey Kong stages or Metroid ones?

 

[DYED]

All Donkey Kong stages.
They're great, but I got kind of attached to Norfair and Brinstar.
I would be really sad if they got removed.

Would you rather have tripping back as a game mechanic, or un-nerfed Brawl's Meta Knight back into the roster, replacing the current one?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Brawl MK

WYR have an ultra-comedic story mode in the next Smash or a direct sequel to Subspace Emissary?

 

[Zeth444]

Comedic

WYR have Villain x Heros Story mode or Every character against an world destroyer evil.

 

[osby]

Everyone against one evil, please. I love that cliche.
WYR see Peach and Zelda team up again or seeing them team up with Rosalina and Palutena respectively?

 

[Sinn0h]

Brawl team ftw

Would you rather have Melee Fox or Brawl Meta Knight return in Smash 5?

(Pick your poison)

 

[Jeck]

Melee Fox because it's good news for the rest of the cast/game in general.

Would you rather they renamed Luigi to "Stupid Mario" or they made Coin Battle the default game type and you had to change it in options?

 

[LoZ00]

Melee Fox because it's good news for the rest of the cast/game in general.

Would you rather they renamed Luigi to "Stupid Mario" or they made Coin Battle the default game type and you had to change it in options?

Coin Battle as default. Considering I already always switch time to stock, I can do this. Besides, sometimes I forget to switch time to stock, this way I'd try Coin Battle every now and then.

WYR have Tabuu returning in a hypothetical Subspace Emissary sequel or having an entire different storyline?

 

[ZagarTulip]

have an entire different storyline

Would you rather have Distant Planet or Hanenbow stage return?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Hannenbow

WYR have Excitebiker or Stanley the Bugman?

 

[DYED]

Excitebike, I think his moveset would be real fun.

Nintendo chooses to have only one Earthbound representative in Smash 5, and decides to remove the other.
WYR have Ness but cut Lucas out or the other way around?

 

[ZagarTulip]

Have Lucas but have Ness Cut

Would you rather have Robin or Corrin playable? (If you had to pick ONE)

 

[LoZ00]

Have Lucas but have Ness Cut

Would you rather have Robin or Corrin playable? (If you had to pick ONE)

Corrin, no doubt.

WYR have the option to upload your own music in the game or a great stage builder?

 

[ZagarTulip]

Now that's a good question... Hmm. I guess I'd love to have a great stage builder

Would you rather have Vaati or Tetra playable?

 

[Zeth444]

Tetra, easy.

WYR have pokefloats back or Helberd

 

[nirvanafan]

Poke Floats

Would you rather have all earthbound or fzero reps cut

 

[ZagarTulip]

Cut all Earthbound

Would you rather have Sora or a Dragon Quest Character?

 

[Sinn0h]

DQ9 is one of my favorite games so a Dragon Quest Character would be cool.

Would you rather have Chain-Grabbing or Directional Air Dodging put back into smash?

 

[LoZ00]

DQ9 is one of my favorite games so a Dragon Quest Character would be cool.

Would you rather have Chain-Grabbing or Directional Air Dodging put back into smash?

Chain grabs. I feel like directional air dodges made air game less prevalent and air game is something I really like.

WYR have a classic mode like in Melee or Brawl?

 

[BlazingFireOmega]

I thought they were both the same? Anyways, I guess Melee cause of targets and race to the finish.

WYR the next Namco rep be Klonoa or Nightmare from Soul Calibur?

 

[LoZ00]

I thought they were both the same? Anyways, I guess Melee cause of targets and race to the finish.

WYR the next Namco rep be Klonoa or Nightmare from Soul Calibur?

They weren't exactly the same. Brawl had fixed stages (the first one always was Zelda, the second one either DK or Yoshi etc.), while Melee had completely randomized opponents.
Anyway, I'd choose Nightmare.

WYR have Brawl Ganondorf or Melee Kirby (we've always talked about top tiers, let's talk about bottom ones)?

 

[SvartWolf]

Brawl ganon.. he is bottom tier anyways...

would you rather have the game revelaed right now woth info about the game and some veterans shown, but no newcomers and e3 revealing 2 newcomers to, or having 0 news until e3 like now, but e3 revealing the whole roster?

 

[Sinn0h]

E3.
I can wait, plus building hype is cool and speculation is fun.

Would you rather have another Wii Fit Rep or another Pac-Man Rep?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

another Pac-Man rep

WYR put Duck Hunt in Smash 64 or Pac-Man in Brawl?

 

[ZagarTulip]

another Pac-Man rep

WYR put Duck Hunt in Smash 64 or Pac-Man in Brawl?

Duck Hunt Smash 64

Would you rather have a new Victory Theme for Ike or for Ganondorf?

 

[TotallyToasted]

New victory theme for Ike.

Would you rather have the new smash feature Melee-esque mechanics or Sm4sh mechanics?

 

[CodakTheWarrior]

New victory theme for Ike.

Would you rather have the new smash feature Melee-esque mechanics or Sm4sh mechanics?

Sm4sh mechanics.

WYR cut Mewtwo yet again in order to bring back every other cut veteran in the series, or leave Mewtwo and have NONE of the old veterans return (like Ice Climbers and Wolf)?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

cut Mewtwo

WYR have Dr. Mario get a new moveset or be replaced with Paper Mario as a clone?

 

[nirvanafan]

new moveset

Would you rather 1 zelda stage based on botw or 2 zelda stages based on other games

 

[LoZ00]

new moveset

Would you rather 1 zelda stage based on botw or 2 zelda stages based on other games

1 based on BotW. Other Zelda titles already have excellent stages.

WYR have a de-cloned Dark Pit or Dark Pit as a palette swap for Pit?

 

[ZagarTulip]

Dark Pit as a palette swap

WYR have a Poochy or Waluigi in Smash as a playable character?

 

[Ze Diglett]

Poochy. Keep that overexposed, anti-funny meme out of my Smash.

Would you rather have Smash 64 alts for all of the original 12, or Melee alts for every character who was in Melee?

 

[ZagarTulip]

Melee alts for every Melee Character

Would you rather have Poliwrath or Politoed as a playable character?

 

[Sinn0h]

P O L I W R A T H.

Would you rather have Smash 5 be more like Brawl or more like Smash 64?

 

[Jeck]

Smash 64 but not its polycount lol. It had better racing events and single player and I prefer the wire frames and metal enemies rather than the Brawl Alloys.

Blanka or Dhalsim?

 

[Nebunera]

Blanka.

Would you rather have Gamecube controller support or a well optimised Pro controller for Smash 5?

 

[Sinn0h]

Gamecube, no question.

Would you rather have PM become an official Nintendo game (It would stay the same but it would just be given Nintendo's support, help, access to technology and tools, etc.) or have Melee HD released?

 

[Ze Diglett]

Project M. That way, we'd finally have a finished version of Knuckles, Lyn, and Isaac, and in an official Smash release, no less!

Would you rather have R.O.B. get a revamped moveset based on his appearance in Mario Kart DS, or have Yoshi get a new moveset based on Yoshi's Safari?

 

[Nebunera]

Yoshi should get a new moveset, never was a fan of him.

More legal stages for competitive or more fun gimmick stages?

 

[ZagarTulip]

Yoshi should get a new moveset, never was a fan of him.

More legal stages for competitive or more fun gimmick stages?

If I had to pick then more Gimmick Stages

WYR have Birdo or Samurai Goroh as a playable character?