The ‘Would you rather have in smash?’ game thread

[Wario Wario Wario]

Birdo

WYR have the lamp from the final boss of Wario Land 1 be an item, or the Mario movie's Thwomp Stompers?

 

[Jeck]

First off, mad props for picking Birdo over Samurai Goroh. I would main Birdo in a heartbeat just to shame people.

Thwomp Stompers. I love my memories of watching that movie but not the movie itself. Also if that was Mario's fun new concept and there was just zero trace of Cappy I would enjoy myself.

WYR have a spin-off of "Smash Bros. vs MARVEL" or "Smash Bros vs Street Fighter"?

 

[TotallyToasted]

Smash bros vs marvel. That sounds like fun!

WYR (completely hypothetical because it would never in a million years happen) keep Marth in the roster or remove Marth and replace with Ice Climbers?

 

[Idon]

Definitely keep Marth. I actually like his game, franchise, character, and playstyle as a whole as opposed to Ice Climbers who I just remember hating playing against and not knowing anything about them outside of Smash.

WYR have a decloned Young Link based off of his mask moveset from Majora's Mask or a decloned Toon Link based off his hurricane spin moveset from Wind Waker?

 

[CodakTheWarrior]

A declined Young Link, its something I've wanted for actual years...

WYR receive only 20 new fire emblem characters (and Inkling I guess) for newcomers and no one else, or have only three total newcomers (counting Inkling)?

 

[Diddy Kong]

Oh God give me the 20 new Fire Emblem characters. I at least genuinely enjoy the franchise.

Give me Alm, Celicia, Lyn, Hector, Zelgius the Black Knight, Tibarn, Caineghis, Soren, a Pegasus Knight as Caeda or the White Wings or Hinoka, Takumi, Azura, Ryoma, **** it bring Xander as well Leif, Sigurd, Seliph, Chrom, Tiki, Anna and Batta the Beast and I'll be content.

Would you rather have the game take inspiration from Hyrule Warriors, in terms of movesets for excisting characters and newcomers from the Zelda franchise, or Pokken, also in the same terms but for the Pokemon franchise?

 

[ZagarTulip]

Hyrule Warriors

Would you rather have 3 new Kirby Characters or 2 new Yoshi Characters?

 

[NobleClamtasm]

Hyrule Warriors

Would you rather have 3 new Kirby Characters or 2 new Yoshi Characters?

Kirby characters all the way. Give me Marx, Adeleine, and maybe Waddle Dee for the fans.
WYR have an obscure NES era retro character, or an obscure N64 retro character?

 

[Diddy Kong]

Hard choice, doubt there's that many N64 characters that are obscure and first / second party that warrant inclusion. Am all the way for a N64 era newcomer, but just not a obscure one.. So NES newcomer I'd say.

Again this question:

Oh God give me the 20 new Fire Emblem characters. I at least genuinely enjoy the franchise.

Give me Alm, Celicia, Lyn, Hector, Zelgius the Black Knight, Tibarn, Caineghis, Soren, a Pegasus Knight as Caeda or the White Wings or Hinoka, Takumi, Azura, Ryoma, **** it bring Xander as well Leif, Sigurd, Seliph, Chrom, Tiki, Anna and Batta the Beast and I'll be content.

Would you rather have the game take inspiration from Hyrule Warriors, in terms of movesets for excisting characters and newcomers from the Zelda franchise, or Pokken, also in the same terms but for the Pokemon franchise?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Hyrule Warriors, because of Tingle

WYR have Omega forms changed into different competitive legal stages from other Smash games, a la Legacy TE, or get extra Alpha forms based on Battlefield alongside Omega forms which are still FD?

 

[Diddy Kong]

Give me Alpha forms, I need this to happen. Battlefield is a more fun platform than Final Destination anyway if done right (not the way it was handled in Melee for example).

Would you rather have more clones added last minute or another , orgininal stage?

 

[CodakTheWarrior]

More clone characters all the way, the more characters in Smash the better I say.

WYR Octoling as an Inkling clone or Alph as an Olimar clone?

 

[Sinn0h]

Octoling for sure, I've never been too into Olimar as a character.

Would you rather have Doc Louis (Punch Out), Dr. Kawashima (Brain Age), Dr. Wily (Mega Man), or Dr. Light (Mega Man) added to Smash?

 

[Caravan of Noobs]

Dr. Kawashima as I think Punchout and Megaman already do a good job representing their series. Also he would rep a new series that hasn't had a playable character.

Would you rather have all the new characters in Smash 5 be assist trophies turned into characters. ex. Takamau, Ashley, Samurai Goro, ect.
or scrapped characters from previous games become playable. ex. Plusle&Minun Ayumi Tachibana, Exite Biker, ect.

 

[Ze Diglett]

Assist trophies. Those scrapped guys were all scrapped for a reason.

Would you rather have Duck Hunt lose the duck and Zapper and be just a dog, or have Marth lose the sword and be just a guy?

 

[Zinith]

Marth losing the sword. It will give that snob some perspective.

WYR have Sushi Striker representation or Pokemon Quest representation?
(topical)

 

[ZagarTulip]

Pokemon Quest representation

WYR have a Story Mode in the style of Subspace Emissary (but with a new name) OR have a Very Customizable Stage Builder?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Stage builder

WYR have Flat Zone 3, Poke Floats 2, WarioWare 2 or Pictochat 3?

 

[ZagarTulip]

Pokefloats 2 is something I wanted for years

Would you rather have Petey Piranha or King Boo playable?

 

[CodakTheWarrior]

Very tough choice, but id say King Boo, he's my most wanted pipe dream character.

WYR have a gen 1 Pokémon rep for let's go Pikachu/Eevee, or a late DLC character from Pokémon gen 8?

 

[Diddy Kong]

Generation One. I'll atleast cherish that character, they are the most popular and recognisable, and nostagia. Can't really go wrong with a Generation One Pokemon honestly. Be it Gengar, Rhydon, Blastoise, Raichu, Dragonite, Eevee and it's evolutions. Squirtle, Ivysaur. even Snorlax (I always imagine Snorlax as a super heavy Jigglypuff semi-clone).. Lots of possible choices.

Two new Fire Emblem characters who you genuinely like, or 1 new character from another franchise?

 

[CodakTheWarrior]

1 new character, I'm one of those people who say FE is WAY too over-represented.

WYR have three new retro characters or one new character from a popular series (Mario, Pokémon, Zelda, etc.)?

 

[Diddy Kong]

Sorry am gonna be selfish and take the popular series, cause especially Donkey Kong and Zelda really need newcomers. And arguebly, even Metroid, Kirby, and StarFox needs Wolf back.

Rather have Lucina or Dr.Mario return?

 

[CodakTheWarrior]

This probably controversial, but I'd say Dr Mario considering he's my main along with Cloud.

WYR exactly one stage per character plus five other stages, or a more traditional spread of stages among series?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Spread

WYR have all Metroid representation cut not only from Smash Switch, but all previous installments as well, or have every song in the series replaced with a SiIvaGunner/Soundclown mashup?

 

[Ze Diglett]

Bye-bye, Metroid.

Would you rather have a stage based on Hell's Kitchen, complete with Gordon Ramsay as a stage hazard, or Guy Fieri added to the roster?

 

[osby]

Hell's Kitchen, please.
WYR have Teletubbies in Smash or cut all DK content?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Teletubbies

WYR have Q*Bert or Bub (Bubble Bobble) playable?

 

[CrusherMania1592]

Q*Bert


Would you rather have another Adventure mode similar to Melee or another Subspace similar to Brawl?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Adventure mode

WYR go back in time and add Muddy Mole from Mole Mania to Smash 64, or add Jill from Drill Dozer to Brawl?

 

[ZagarTulip]

Muddy Mole Smash 64

Would you rather go back in time and add King Boo in Brawl or add Kamek to Melee?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

King Boo in Brawl.

WYR have Fire Emblem as a series cut from Smash Switch, or Old Man Jenkins from SpongeBob playable?

 

[osby]

King Boo in Brawl.
WYR have Dixie in Brawl or 4?

 

[Kirby Dragons]

Sm4sh, Donkey Kong at least got a character in Brawl.
EDIT: Old Man Jenkins.

Have all your favorite characters cut, or have everybody cut except your favorite characters?

 

[Ze Diglett]

Everybody cut except my favorite characters, because I'm a selfish prick.

Would you rather have a character you don't know from a game you've never played, but you end up really enjoying how they play, or one of your favorite characters from your favorite game, but with a moveset that you just can't get behind?

 

[Sinn0h]

I'd be disappointed if a character I was super hyped for ended up being trash, but I'd be pleasantly surprised if I got a new favorite character. So I'd rather have a character I didn't know from a game I've never played.

Would you rather have Monty Mole (Super Mario Bros.), Mondo Mole (Earthbound), or Mr. Resetti (Animal Crossing) added to smash?

 

[ZagarTulip]

Mondo Mole

WYR have Baby Mario or Riolu?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Baby Mario

WYR have a ZX Spectrum stage or an Atari 2600 stage?

 

[osby]

I'm going to pretend I know what it is and say Atari 2600
WYR have a stage from Majora's Mask or Bowser's Inside Story?

 

[Kirby Dragons]

I wanna say Majora's Mask because I played it, but it got a stage in Melee. Bowser's Inside Story.

Have a character that can meteor smash with any of their moves, or have a character that gets heavy armor from all of their moves?