The ‘Would you rather have in smash?’ game thread

[ZagarTulip]

Replace Lucina in 3DS/Wii U with Virtual Boy as a R.O.B. Luigi-clone

Would you rather have a playable Goomba or a playable Boo?

 

[Carrill]

Playable goomba

Which newcomer announced at E3? Kim Kardashian or Kylie Jenner?

 

[ZagarTulip]

Kylie Jenner

Would you rather have Groose or Vaati playable?

 

[Ze Diglett]

Let the Groose loose.

Would you rather the next Smash be directed by someone other than Sakurai, or no next Smash at all?

 

[NoUsernameHere]

I'd rather the next Smash be directed by someone other than Sakurai.

Would you rather have your main cut with the guarantee of more newcomers or have your main stay with the guarantee of no newcomers (aside from the Inklings)?

 

[Caravan of Noobs]

Keep R.O.B. without him I'll be lost.

Would you rather all veterans reuse their Smash 4 renders so their amiibos will be re-released or all the veterans get new renders meaning you need to collect 58 new amiibos for characters you already own.

 

[ZagarTulip]

all the veterans get new renders meaning you need to collect 58 new amiibos for characters you already own


Here is a twist to my WYR:
If there was a story mode, Which Boss would you rather see? Medeus (Fire Emblem) OR Kracko (Kirby)

 

[CodakTheWarrior]

Kracko would be really rad.

If there was a story mode, would you rather have Petey Piranha return as a boss or have the Stone Talus from BOtW?

 

[ZagarTulip]

Stone Talus would be neat

If there was a story mode, Would you rather have Empress Bulblax (From Pikmin) as a boss or have King Bob-omb as a boss?

 

[Autumn ♫]

King Bob-omb! One of the first bosses I've ever went against!

WYR declone all current clones or give new movesets to all of the characters who have a clone

 

[NoUsernameHere]

Declone all current clones.

WYR see the Smash Ball return as an optional item or have a new mechanic which integrates Final Smashes into a match somehow without needing the Smash Ball?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Smash Ball returns

WYR have Dr. Eggman as a playable character, Assist Trophy or stage hazard?

 

[Ze Diglett]

Eggman as a character. The man's just too entertaining to relegate to any less of a role.

Would you rather have Smash 5 be stuck with Smash 4's menu structure, or Smash 4's singleplayer? (Bear in mind, this means no new singleplayer modes, period.)

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

menu

WYR have your favourite Nintendo hidden gem get a character, or your favourite not-yet-added character from a big Nintendo heavy-hitter get in?

 

[ZagarTulip]

have my favourite Nintendo hidden gem get a character

WYR have Adeleine (from Kirby) or Maxwell (from Scribblenauts) as a playable character?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Adeleine

I've asked this before, but WYR have Metal Head DK or Robot Ness as an alt?

 

[osby]

Robot Ness.
WYR have next game to have Brawl's art direction or Smash For's GUI design?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Smash 3DS/Wii U menu design

WYR have a pinata from Viva Pinata as a Microsoft rep or PaRappa the Rapper as a Sony rep?

 

[ZagarTulip]

Pinata from Viva Pinata as a Microsoft Rep

Would you rather have Yooka-Laylee or Banjo-Kazooie?

 

[LoZ00]

Pinata from Viva Pinata as a Microsoft Rep

Would you rather have Yooka-Laylee or Banjo-Kazooie?

Banjo-Kazooie would be neat, although I'd like to see Yooka-Laylee just to see how Banjo-Kazooie fans would react.

WYR have DJ Octavio as a stage hazard or as a stage boss (you couldn't defeat him if he were a stage hazard, but he'd be less annoying).

 

[PeridotGX]

Hazard

Would you rather have your most wanted as an assist trophy or completely absent?

 

[ZagarTulip]

Assist Trophy (seeing as how assists can become playable in future installments, just like Little Mac)

WYR have Smash Run (like in the 3DS) or have Smash Tour (like in the Wii U)? (I know what I'd do)

 

[Almand]

Smash Run. I would like to meet the guy who prefers Smash Tour.

WYR have only Mario rep newcomers, or only Fire Emblem newcomers?

 

[Ze Diglett]

All Mario. That way, my man Geno will likely be among those chosen to finally get his chance in Smash! That, and I actually like Mario, whereas I'm incredibly indifferent to Fire Emblem and am among the vocal majority who believes FE is overrepresented as-is.

Would you rather every character's voice, even the silent and nonverbal ones, be changed to that of Smash 4 Fox, or that of Waluigi?

 

[CodakTheWarrior]

Only Mario rep newcomers, has sooo much more variety than Fire Emblem any day.

WYR add Captain Toad and Waluigi, or add Ridley and King K. Rool?

 

[CodakTheWarrior]

Only Mario rep newcomers, has sooo much more variety than Fire Emblem any day.

WYR add Captain Toad and Waluigi, or add Ridley and King K. Rool?

All Mario. That way, my man Geno will likely be among those chosen to finally get his chance in Smash! That, and I actually like Mario, whereas I'm incredibly indifferent to Fire Emblem and am among the vocal majority who believes FE is overrepresented as-is.

Would you rather every character's voice, even the silent and nonverbal ones, be changed to that of Smash 4 Fox, or that of Waluigi?

Waluigi voices, wouldn't that be an improvement? Same question

 

[Ze Diglett]

Ridley and K. Rool, easy. I am of the opinion that Ridley is, in fact, too big for Smash, but the former two I take way more issue with personally. Captain Toad just isn't cut out for a fighting role in my opinion, and to see him get in over pretty much any other Mario character would make me at least a little miffed, and Waluigi needs to **** off and die like the overexposed, unfunny meme he is.

Would you rather Mario's default costume replaced with 7 GRAND DAD and all his alt costumes removed, or remove all of Shulk's costumes except for Shirtless "im really feeling it xD" Shulk? Basically, pick your poison between two run-into-the-ground memes.

 

[CodakTheWarrior]

The shirtless Shulk, at least it's not inherently awful by itself.

WYR Geno and Crash Bandicoot added while having every other third party removed, or keep them out to save the current 6 third parties?

 

[ZagarTulip]

I'd say Geno and Crash without any other 3rd Party

WYR have a Goomba with a baseball bat be playable or have a Waddle Dee with an umbrella be playable?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Goomba with a baseball bat

WYR make it so every time Ness does a KO, the photo-man comes down, pauses the game, does his entire speech, takes a photo, and then resumes the game or every time Sonic gets a Smash Ball, you have to complete the Sonic 1 special stage in order to activate the Final Smash?

 

[osby]

Photo-man, of course. It's always a pleasure to see him.
Wyr Bowser to have Zelda's voice clips or Peach's?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Peach's voice clips.

WYR have the Red Angry Bird playable, or a Zombie from Plants Vs. Zombies?

 

[ZagarTulip]

Red Angry Bird

WYR have a Cuphead character or Yooka and Laylee playable?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Cuphead

WYR have DK get his voice from the DKC cartoon, or get an alt using the exact same model used in the cartoon?

 

[Almand]

Voice, but I will add that I want his singing voice. I consider either an improvement over his current sounds.

WYR double the power of Lucario's Aura (only does 0.3x damage at 0% while 2 stocks ahead, and 3.6x damage at 190% while 2 stocks behind), or quadruple the power of Rage (1.6x knockback at 150%)?

 

[BlazingFireOmega]

Double Lucario's aura.

WRY the "clang"/"clank"/"when two hit collide" sound from Melee come back or have the meteor/spike sound from Smash 4 make a return?

 

[Almand]

Spike. It just sounds too good, really gives spiking that extra oomph of hype.

WYR have your least favorite character added as a top-tier clone of your main, or have your favorite newcomer added, but as a bottom-tier clone of your least favorite character?

 

[osby]

My favourite character. I don't care abort tiers and if it fits, a barrowed moveset is not bad.
WYR have your main have an original moveset and be bottom tier or be an A tier clone?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Bottom tier... not sure who Duck Hunt could be a clone of...

WYR have Wario get the D.I.Y. outfit,

as an alt, or Bowser get the Yoshi's Safari armour?

 

[osby]

Wario gets his DIY costume, it's gorgeous.
WYR have Peach her Fire Peach costume or a Shadow Queen alt?