The ‘Would you rather have in smash?’ game thread

[LoZ00]

Thé more Marios, the better?
WYR have Duck Hunt duck switched with Falco or Pikmin switched with little Yoshis?

Pikmin switched with little Yoshis. They'd be absolutely cute!

WYR have a new whip item or a new axe item?

 

[ZagarTulip]

Whip

WYR have Melee Peach's Castle or Brawl Rumble Falls?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Rumble Falls

WYR have Muddy Mole, Duster, Rosalina and Chunky Kong added (downgraded in the case of Rosa) as ATs, or as playable characters? (connection: all these characters were rumoured to be ATs)

 

[Guh-Huzzah!]

Muddy Mole, Duster, Rosalina and Chunky added as Ats.

Midna or Skull Kid as Fighters?

 

[ShadowYoshi04]

Skull Kid

Would you rather have Isaac, Hunter (Fossil Fighters), or Starfy playable?

 

[ssbashworld]

Isaac
Would you rather have all smash e3 unveils during the direct or have some during the invitational

 

[Guh-Huzzah!]

During the direct.

Which clone should get cut? Dark Pit or Lucina?

 

[osby]

During the direct.

Which clone should get cut? Dark Pit or Lucina?

I like both but Dark Pit, I guess.
WYR cut Captain Falcon or Fox?

 

[ZagarTulip]

Cut Fox

WYR have Aiai from Super Monkey Ball or Yooka-Laylee in Smash Switch)

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

AiAi

WYR have the ChuChu Pilots from the (instruction manual of) ChuChu Rocket and Sonic and Sega All-Stars Racing, or the Bonanza Bros?

 

[ZagarTulip]

ChuChu Pilots from the (instruction manual of) ChuChu Rocket and Sonic and Sega All-Stars Racing

Would you rather have Lightning (from Final Fantasy XIII) or Zero (from MegaMan)?

 

[osby]

Zero
WYR have Morrigan Aeslendar from Darkstalkers or Amaterasu from Okami?

 

[ShadowYoshi04]

Amaterasu

Would you rather have no new first party characters or no new third party characters?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

no new first party characters.

WYR have Bubsy, Gex, Plok or Earthworm Jim?

 

[ZagarTulip]

Earthworm Jim

WYR have a 2nd Final Fantasy Character or Second Street Fighter Character?

 

[ShadowYoshi04]

Second Street fighter

Would you rather have a character to represent the 3DS or a character to represent the Wii U?

 

[LoZ00]

Second Street fighter

Would you rather have a character to represent the 3DS or a character to represent the Wii U?

I think I'm going with Abraham Lincoln from Codename: S.T.E.A.M., so a 3DS character.

WYR have Crono from Chrono Trigger or Sora from Kingdom Hearts?

 

[ZagarTulip]

Sora

WYR have Lightning or Vanille (Both from Final Fantasy XIII)?

 

[BlazingFireOmega]

Lightning

WRY every Japanese-speaking character have a English voice? (Ex: Marth, Cloud, Roy)

or have every mute character that has shown to have a voice get a voice? (Ex: MegaMan, Pac-Man, Olimar)

 

[John Hohn]

Every Japanese-speaking character have an English voice. At least they have a human voice, every time a voiceless character gets a voice it just feels...wrong. Like eating ice cream with a fork.

WYR have the next Kirby rep be Rick the Hamster or the next Mario rep be Shy Guy?

 

[ZagarTulip]

Mario Rep = Shy Guy

WYR have:

All Clones become Clones of Different Characters (Example: Falco would no longer be a clone of Fox but instead someone else)

Or

Every Newcomer be a Clone of an existing Smash Character.

 

[John Hohn]

All Clones become Clones of Different Characters. It's a tough one, but if all new characters were clones, that'd be disappointing for everyone. Now if Ganondorf can become the clone of some Fire Emblem character, then maybe he'd finally use his damn sword.

WYR gain a rep from Electroplankton or Brain Age?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Brain Training

WYR have the announcer announce the name of stages, or Assist Trophies?

 

[John Hohn]

Stage Names. It would be distracting if all the Assist trophies were named, as that'd be in the heat of battle. A quick namedrop of the stage when you select it would be painless and fun.

WYR have Olimar lose all his Pikmin and become a physical fighter, or have Sonic pick up Excalibur and become a Swordsman?

 

[Zinith]

Sonic with Excalibur. It may be another sword character and references a mediocre Sonic game, but at least it gives him a more diverse moveset and taking Pikmin away from Olimar is a crime.

WYR have rage or ledge trumping remain

 

[John Hohn]

Ledge Trumping. Rage, while giving highly damaged players a chance to bounce back, is unfair overall since it changes the fighters' strength at weird intervals that make it hard to judge an attack for both a person fighting against a high damage fighter and the person playing said high damage fighter. Ledge Trumping just makes sense, it gives an opportunity for players to stop others from eternally grabbing the edge.

WYR have Metal Mario or Pink Gold Peach as playable characters?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Pink Gold Peach

you know how one of Sakurai's other creations, Meteos, got a Disney spin-off? well, WYR have a Smash spin-off starring Nickelodeon or Cartoon Network characters?

 

[John Hohn]

Cartoon Network. All Nickelodeon characters are basically the same, some weird-looking human with no real powers. Sure, there's the occasional cat or sponge but for the most part it's pretty boring. Cartoon Network, on the other hand, has tons of heroes, villains, and items of a huge variety that would fit right into a smash game.

WYR have Great Bay or Fountain of Dreams return as a stage?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Fountain of Dreams

WYR have a villains-centered or Mario-centered Smash spin-off that has it's most popular newcomers incorporated into the main series?

 

[ShadowYoshi04]

Villains centered

Would you rather have a Smash Kart spin-off or a Smash RPG spin-off?

 

[Ze Diglett]

Smash RPG. More potential for an all-new Story Mode that way.

Would you rather have Kirby's voice replaced with that of the King from Zelda CD-i, or the King himself actually show up as a playable character?

 

[John Hohn]

The King show up as a character. That would be...interesting to say the least.

WYR have the whole roster replaced with Fire Emblem characters or Star Fox characters?

 

[osby]

Eh, Fire Emblem has more characters.
WYR have all newcomers to be revealed tomorrow or all of them for once a month but with less characters.

 

[ZagarTulip]

All Newcomers revealed tomorrow

WYR have a Subspace Emissary-like story mode as a Paid feature or have the Stage Builder as a Paid feature?

 

[CodakTheWarrior]

Story mode paid, I've never really cared about the stage builder at all.

WYR have Skull Kid get in as a bizarre Rosalina clone using his fairy, or have Pig-Ganon get in as a Bowser clone?

 

[John Hohn]

Pig-Ganon as a Bowser clone. It makes more sense than a Rosalina clone Skull Kid.

WYR have all new stages play Despacito or the Macarena?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Macarena

WYR announce Space Invader a trailer that beings with Samus fighting Ridley, only for her to defeat Ridley, walk away and then get uppercutted by the Space Invader, OR a trailer that continues from the Pac-Man trailer with a green bar turning into Space Invader?

 

[John Hohn]

I like the Metroid trailer for Space Invader. It reminds me of Robin's trailer for Smash 4, where they showed Chrom but it turned out to be Lucina and Robin. Teasing Ridley like that and instead introducing Space Invader would be legendary.

WYR have a regular Black Bear as a character or a regular Horse as a character?

 

[osby]

A regular black bear to destroy Master Hand.
WYR have a cat character or a fish character to be playable?

 

[John Hohn]

Fish. Just for the fun of it. It can function like how Goldeen does in Smash, only playable and obviously much more effective. It can flop around, maybe shoot some water out of it's mouth, and there are tons of evolutionary traits like poison, quills, and electricity that a fish can utilize.

WYR have every character suddenly be able to fly or breathe fire?