The ‘Would you rather have in smash?’ game thread

[HelloImAxel]

Shrek would def be interesting and fun
Would you rather have Melee Jiggly-puff or Melee Mario

 

[biigshaq]

Melee Mario

WYR have no projectiles or every character getting some kind of projectile?

 

[JackD2204]

Every character getting some kind of projectile

WYR have more clones, or no change in cast size at all?

 

[biigshaq]

No change.

WYR have the game never be balanced or never be updated (besides balances)

 

[JackD2204]

No change.

WYR have the game never be balanced or never be updated (besides balances)

You mean no DLC?

 

[biigshaq]

You mean no DLC?

Basically.

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

never be balanced.

would you rather have Sonic's victory theme changed to the Sonic 1/2 stage clear, or the Sonic 1/2 title theme?

 

[NintenRob]

Uhh, stage clear I guess

Would you rather

Character specific break the targets AND board the platform

Or

Character specific boss fights, most with their appropriate boss theme

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Break the targets.

Would you rather have go back to the development of Smash 64 and have the Falcon Punch removed or go back to the development of Melee and have Temple removed?

 

[PsySmasher]

Remove Temple

WYR have Xenoblade or Kid Icarus be overrepresented in Smash Switch (in terms of roster slots)?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Kid Icarus

Would you rather have Bubsy added, or no newcomers?

 

[Sprite]

Bubsy, atleast we get some other newcomers then.

Would you rather have Lucario or Greninja cut

 

[biigshaq]

Bye Lucario

WYR have no Pokemon or too many Pokemon by about 5 or so

 

[Pacack]

Bye Lucario

WYR have no Pokemon or too many Pokemon by about 5 or so

Too many Pokemon. While it would bug me a tad, I also like Pokemon enough that I wouldn't be upset.

WYR have half the roster be unlockable or have no unlockables outside of trophies?

 

[JackD2204]

Half the roster be unlockable,

Would you rather have all cut veterans return and no newcomers, or some newcomers but no returning veterans?

 

[GeflGabe]

Some newcomers. N̶o̶t̶ ̶t̶o̶d̶a̶y̶ ̶w̶o̶b̶b̶l̶i̶n̶g̶.̶

WYR have or return , assuming there's Sm4sh physics with the exception of the two.

 

[Zerp]

Some newcomers. N̶o̶t̶ ̶t̶o̶d̶a̶y̶ ̶w̶o̶b̶b̶l̶i̶n̶g̶.̶

WYR have or return , assuming there's Sm4sh physics with the exception of the two.

I'd rather have , nothing can compare to horror known as . Except for Smash 4 doubles Cloud lol.

Would you rather have Elma from Xenoblade and Elmo get in, or Goku from Yūyūki and Goku from Dragon Ball get in?

 

[Freduardo]

I'd rather have , nothing can compare to horror known as . Except for Smash 4 doubles Cloud lol.

Would you rather have Elma from Xenoblade and Elmo get in, or Goku from Yūyūki and Goku from Dragon Ball get in?

Elma and Elmo. I’m doing it for a muppet. And I’ll be honest, I would have taken any muppet over Elmo.

Would you rather have two Advance Wars characters or Mallo (Pushmo) and Dillon (Rolling Western)?

 

[PsySmasher]

Mallo and Dillon

Would you rather have your most requested character as DLC or another character from the same series in the base roster?

 

[biigshaq]

Requested as DLC. I am not afraid to pay money for what I really want, as long as it is reasonable price like it has been

WYR have no online play or only online play?

 

[Zerp]

No online play, I don't even play Wi-Fi as it is now.

Would you rather get or as a newcomer?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Clefairy.

Would you rather have each stage have 1 song on the level of quality of music from Ocean Software SNES games, or a ton of existing music and no remixes?

Spoiler: Ocean Software music for reference

 

[FamicomDisk]

Clefairy.

Would you rather have each stage have 1 song on the level of quality of music from Ocean Software SNES games, or a ton of existing music and no remixes?

Spoiler: Ocean Software music for reference

Those SNES songs don't sound that great to me, so definitely the latter option. Even if those songs were great, though, I feel like having one per stage would make them feel old quickly. I like to switch it up, so Smash 4 and Brawl made a good change in having a music list for each stage.

Would you rather they bring back the menu style of Smash 4, or Smash 64?

 

[LunarOctopus]

Smash 4

Would you rather Shadow or Knuckles be added, Knuckles being a bit slower and harder hitting and Shadow having more speed but less attack power?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Knuckles.

Would you rather have the SkiFree Yeti or Master Chief as a Microsoft rep?

 

[LunarOctopus]

Master Chief, I assume he'd just play like Snake

Would you rather PAC-LAND or the side scrolling Mario stage return to Smash for Switch?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Pac-Land. love that stage

would you rather have a Coca-Cola can as a playable character, or a Pepsi can?

 

[LunarOctopus]

Pac-Land. love that stage

would you rather have a Coca-Cola can as a playable character, or a Pepsi can?

Coke has a better taste, and is slightly more acidic for higher attack power.

Would you rather they remove Bowser Jr. or Duck Hunt?

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

Bowser Jr.

Would you rather have Excitebiker or Urban Champion

 

[LunarOctopus]

Bowser Jr.

Would you rather have Excitebiker or Urban Champion

Excitebiker, although I probably wouldn't use him much seeing as I'm not a fan of characters who play the way I assume he would, and Urban champion punches. We have C. Falcon and Mac so I don't think we need another.

Would you rather Dr. Mario get replaced by another Marth clone, or Lucina get replaced with another Mario clone?

 

[Freduardo]

Excitebiker, although I probably wouldn't use him much seeing as I'm not a fan of characters who play the way I assume he would, and Urban champion punches. We have C. Falcon and Mac so I don't think we need another.

Would you rather Dr. Mario get replaced by another Marth clone, or Lucina get replaced with another Mario clone?

Lucina replaced by another Mario clone.

Would you rather get Cool Spot and the Domino’s Pizza Noid as assist trophies or E.T. As a playable character?

 

[LunarOctopus]

E.T. as a playable character all the way man, been pushing for him to be added since Melee!

Would you rather they remove All-Star or Classic?

 

[LoZ00]

E.T. as a playable character all the way man, been pushing for him to be added since Melee!

Would you rather they remove All-Star or Classic?

All-Star. Honestly, considering we're going to have 70+ characters, All-Star seems to be impossible to do.

WYR have a Marvel character or a DC character?

 

[Sage of Ice]

Marvel! one gloomy movie after another has kinda killed my interest in DC, but Marvel continues to deliver. (don't ask me to pick a specific character though, i've got like half a dozen favorites and i couldn't possibly narrow it down)

Would You Rather get your first choice for new character and your second choice for a stage, or your first stage and your second character?

 

[DuwangAnon]

First choice new character and second choice new stage.
WYR have Smash 5 be developed by Konami or EA Games?

 

[JackD2204]

Konami. Both are horrible, but EA would make each DLC character 50 dollars.

WYR have waddle dee, or Ridley be in smash 5?

 

[Sage of Ice]

ridley! let me ask a harder question - would you rather get $700 and a date with Scarlett Johansen, or one (1) ham sandwich?

ok ok ok a smash bros one, lemme see... Would You Rather a custom color editor to make your own recolor, or an alternate model (like overalls Wario vs WarioWare Wario) for each character?

 

[biigshaq]

Color I guess.

WYR have easy sours or easy sweets

 

[Wario Wario Wario]

easy sweets... whatever that means?

Would you rather have Donkey Kong voiced by Sterling Jarvis (his VA in the DKC cartoon), or have Ness with an American accent?

 

[CannonStreak]

Donkey Kong’s cartoon voice.

Would you rather have Peach’s Castle from Melee or Fountain of Dreams from Melee return?