• Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!

    You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!

Super Mario RPG Mafia: Hilt lynched, Town wins!

UTDZac

▲▲▲▲▲
BRoomer
Joined
Sep 28, 2005
Messages
6,646
Location
Judgment Count: 856
@Rajam

After re-reading a few things I gotta agree with you Rajam, Shaya hardly interacted with T-Block and this could make him a suspect but, I still can't understand why you wanted name claims right now. I'm not against it but I don't feel we need something like this right now, we are just at the start of Day2 there's a lot to happen yet.

I'm voting Shaya because I feel Rajam has the best play so far, it's the only one, at least for me, which is a confirmed townie and brought up good points by remembering us that he was the one which pressured RR and Chibo quite enough to worth a vote.

Vote: Shaya
Why do you say Rajam is a confirmed townie? I'm slightly confused with your second paragraph.
 

Omni

You can't break those cuffs.
BRoomer
Joined
Jul 10, 2004
Messages
11,635
Location
Maryland
alright got some time

Also, told ya scum was in my wagon
dont. everyone and their Mom was on your wagon. scum could have easily not been on your wagon or even RR's wagon (who flipped confirmed town).


What everyone thinks about using RR's info and do a name claim of Mario, Mallow, Geno, Bowser, and Peach? That way we'll split into two groups, one that we know there is 1 mafia and 4 town (and whoever claims Mario without being cclaimed will be 100% town), and the rest where there could still be 1 scum left, and probably 1 or 2 indies
No. We're ahead. We play simple Mafia. Gambits like that are only necessary when we're behind.

~ Note to self: Omni started the idea of me claiming. (post #251) ~
Why is this note important? Anyone who I find scummy I'll push to claim.

-----------------

There were 2 deaths lastnight: one Chibo and one T-block. Neither of these players, imo, were town vig bait so my guess is that there's an SK. Chibo was definitely off'd by mafia which means the remaining vig either targeted T-Block directly OR Chibo bus'd T-block with another player who was a night target. More likely the former.

Confirming if an SK exists only proves that the indy faction is prolly like 1 person.

There were several people T-Block didn't interact with including Shaya. He was rather tame regarding Chibo, Pado, and Zigsta. If Chibo didn't die lastnight I would've pushed for his lynch toDay.

I still like Rajam dying. He reminds me of me in CT mafia when I was trying to meta the game hard based on the knowledge I had. I also used my nailing of Shaya/Edreeses as scum as 'evidence' that I was on town's side except Rajam didn't really nail anything.

@Shaya: I completely misread it to be honest, but you make a good point. Speculating that there's only 1 out of the 4 instead of several out of 4 is a huge slip. It seems more like a slip that a solo indy with a safe claim would make. or a mafia crew with only 1 safe safe claim in that category. Luckily for me I'm town :cool: , but I wonder why Rajam came to that conclusion as well. Also, I am in favor of using this information closer to LYLO. I have no idea why Rajam is fine with trying to do a flavor/claim gambit Day 2 after we just nailed Smithy.

Vote: Rajam

This wagon is still good, and it still has cookies.
 

Pierce7d

Wise Hermit
Joined
Dec 20, 2006
Messages
6,289
Location
Teaneck, North Bergen County, NJ, USA
3DS FC
1993-9028-0439
Unvote

Vote: Hilt


Shaya, I have a null on you, for the record. I was voting for you because you were previously one of the most inactive players yesterDay, but toDay you seem to be fine.

Hilt is the MVP shadow of the game atm.
 

Rajam

Smash Champion
Joined
Oct 3, 2008
Messages
2,175
Location
Santiago, Chile
There's something not right with Omni but I can't put a finger on it.
Because Omni is still with that *** of lynching useless people instead of scummy players

Also, wtf at that speculation about NKills...

Omni, someone hacked your account


I'm also still comfortable with your lynch :awesome:

You seem to be on inactives yet, though you forgot a couple:

Tin Man
Krystedez

Hilt needs to talk more though. Or are you Kefka/Indy again Hilt?

Omni (and everyone else), who's scum with T-block?

Hint 1: Shaya
Hint 2: #1239 -> wagon-jumping

Not both though, but I think both are decent lynch candidates toDay.
 

Krystedez

Awaken the Path
Joined
Feb 22, 2010
Messages
4,301
Location
Colorado Springs
Well, I'll be more active this Thursday evening when I get home. It's impossible for me to stay active right now because I'm studying for exams and getting ready to leave for the summer at the same time.

I'm reading every post though and I'll catch up sometime tomorrow evening so I can have some contribution. Right now I'm just dead from Finals Week... :(
 

Tin Man

Smash Hero
Joined
Jan 31, 2009
Messages
6,874
Location
Belconnen, ACT, Australia
Out of the players left, Zac, Krys, Tin and Pado had not left much of a mark on me in terms of content yesterday.

Those four players:

What did you feel about Chibo at the end of yesterday? Did you think he would die? What information did his death bring to you?

Them/rest:
Did you feel T-Block was town? What lead you to believe this?
Red Ryu's trolling seemed to have gotten to a lot of people. It took a lot of the attention off of Chibo/T-Block for me. I'm surprised Red Ryu decided to play like that...

I'm going to have to re-read the game to date and then let you guys know/add more.

At least schools done so I can be more active, but I stepped up my shifts @ work. I'll have some input before the end of 2morrow.
 

Shaya

   「chase you」 
BRoomer
Joined
Jun 8, 2007
Messages
27,654
Location
/人◕‿‿◕人\ FABULOUS Max!
NNID
ShayaJP
What conclusions do you draw from your analysis on T-block?
Excluding early posts, his only "I don't like them" from T-Block was towards Krys and Omni. However, both of those players he had 'defended' to a degree. From a reread you can feel that his play was somewhat full of blenddddddddddd (iono I kinda felt the same about chibo but this was definitely more noticeable on a reread). Lot's of pampering to the players in the game, which is why it was easy for some to say he was pro-town.
But yeah other than Krys/Omni he didn't state any real strong scum feels towards other players during the mid to later part of the day.

I think there are a few things to note, one of which I bolded.
"States scum may know the real colour".
Now I'm not sure if T-Block was either being "helpful" (you know wifom playing as town mode) or he would (like I learnt after CT mafia) state this to avoid independent(s) victory. Could be a bit of both, but the former was a dangerous breadcrumb for a mafia player to state, either way.
i.e. After CT Mafia I learnt that I pretty much let Omni win the game because I knew he was lying but I didn't say anything. Whether or not town would have believed me is one thing, but I earnestly wanted to state "They're lying" before I died (however OS screwed me over with twilight because I was going out of state on a train so I didn't have any computer access for like 18~ hours, by the time I could do anything the next day had like... started lol).

@Rajam, how do you feel about T-Block after a reread?
I would really like to feel confident that you weren't OMGUSing the universe here. In hindsight there are things which look out of place, but otherwise wasn't really any worse than the lack of activity from several players in this game.

In relation to colours, assuming T-Block wasn't lying (I know it's wifom in itself), then I'm sceptical of clearing Rajam or Raziek. Even though I do kinda like Raziek's play, I feel his neck is still too retracted at the moment, and his pounce on RR could have been extremely opportunistic.


@Rajam

After re-reading a few things I gotta agree with you Rajam, Shaya hardly interacted with T-Block and this could make him a suspect but, I still can't understand why you wanted name claims right now. I'm not against it but I don't feel we need something like this right now, we are just at the start of Day2 there's a lot to happen yet.

I'm voting Shaya because I feel Rajam has the best play so far, it's the only one, at least for me, which is a confirmed townie and brought up good points by remembering us that he was the one which pressured RR and Chibo quite enough to worth a vote.

Vote: Shaya
All I can say to this entire post is "lols". The first paragraph contradicts your conclusion in the latter. Welcome to wagon jumping town. IMO I think I'll pull a rajam and say with utmost confidence that Rajam, Pierce and Pado are scum.


EBWOP:

@Shaya

Oh, and I didn't expect any of those 2 to get killed.
You didn't really answer my questions in full.
So either you've been skimming the game and can't give a concrete opinion (scum-tell) or what pado?
 

Shaya

   「chase you」 
BRoomer
Joined
Jun 8, 2007
Messages
27,654
Location
/人◕‿‿◕人\ FABULOUS Max!
NNID
ShayaJP
There were 2 deaths lastnight: one Chibo and one T-block. Neither of these players, imo, were town vig bait so my guess is that there's an SK. Chibo was definitely off'd by mafia which means the remaining vig either targeted T-Block directly OR Chibo bus'd T-block with another player who was a night target. More likely the former.
I suppose it's more likely this rather than someone "seeing" Chibo's breadcrumbs of being Booster and concluding he may be scum. Very weird / awkward wifom relating to that though which I now agree probably shouldn't remain in people's thoughts.

@Shaya: I completely misread it to be honest, but you make a good point. Speculating that there's only 1 out of the 4 instead of several out of 4 is a huge slip. It seems more like a slip that a solo indy with a safe claim would make. or a mafia crew with only 1 safe safe claim in that category. Luckily for me I'm town :cool: , but I wonder why Rajam came to that conclusion as well. Also, I am in favor of using this information closer to LYLO. I have no idea why Rajam is fine with trying to do a flavor/claim gambit Day 2 after we just nailed Smithy
I'm starting to feel like I'm getting trolled. Both Rajam and yourself came to the same conclusion about something which had otherwise nothing too overtly out of place, I don't recall anyone else in the game stating the same opinion. Omni's been on Rajam's case pretty strongly still, yet they feel the same way about something, out of game interaction scum slip?

FoS: Omni / Rajam

I found the post I'm referring to

also, if "the other 4" does refer to Mallow, Geno, Peach, and Bowser and one of those 4 flip scum then the rest are cleared town.
mmmmmmmmmm...
THE ONLY THING that I would say is conclusive is
If three of Mallow, Geno, Peach and Bowser flip TOWN than the last one is scum (mafia/independent). HOWEVER, it isn't possible to conclude anything until that condition is met. Mad scum vibes coming from those two at the moment.
ESPECIALLY at Rajam wanting to pull a mass name claim early on in day 2 when he obviously feels like he can get away with it due to people believing he is town.
 

UTDZac

▲▲▲▲▲
BRoomer
Joined
Sep 28, 2005
Messages
6,646
Location
Judgment Count: 856
In relation to colours, assuming T-Block wasn't lying (I know it's wifom in itself), then I'm sceptical of clearing Rajam or Raziek. Even though I do kinda like Raziek's play, I feel his neck is still too retracted at the moment, and his pounce on RR could have been extremely opportunistic.
You CANNOT use this color thing to clear anybody. Non-town players have to know what the town color is (since OS uses colors). Why? Because there is no Sample Role PM. If town didn't know the color, then Day 1 we could have had all of the players breadcrumb the town color. It's possible to break the system this way, I can't imagine OS "failing" like this. I've seen his previous games in DGames, and he does use a Sample Role PM.
 

Shaya

   「chase you」 
BRoomer
Joined
Jun 8, 2007
Messages
27,654
Location
/人◕‿‿◕人\ FABULOUS Max!
NNID
ShayaJP
You CANNOT use this color thing to clear anybody. Non-town players have to know what the town color is (since OS uses colors). Why? Because there is no Sample Role PM. If town didn't know the color, then Day 1 we could have had all of the players breadcrumb the town color. It's possible to break the system this way, I can't imagine OS "failing" like this. I've seen his previous games in DGames, and he does use a Sample Role PM.
This is funny, didn't you feel towny about Rajam (or was it scummy about RR) based on the colour business?
 

UTDZac

▲▲▲▲▲
BRoomer
Joined
Sep 28, 2005
Messages
6,646
Location
Judgment Count: 856
I initially got a scummy vibe towards RR because of this. After Day1, I did some re-reading and thought about the color issue again. I realized it was possible (thought wasn't sure exactly how) that if scum didn't know the color, town could out them all Day 1.
 

Rajam

Smash Champion
Joined
Oct 3, 2008
Messages
2,175
Location
Santiago, Chile
http://www.smashboards.com/showpost.php?p=12572547&postcount=241

"Quote:
Originally Posted by Rajam
Omni do you think players should say and/or explain their town reads? I've seen diverse responses to this issue and I'd like to hear your stance

sure! why not?"




Based on that:



http://www.smashboards.com/showpost.php?p=12572853&postcount=266

"Quote:
Originally Posted by Zigsta
Quote:
Originally Posted by T-block
@Zigsta: Hmm...when did he say it was his first mafia game? So you think it's unlikely that Red Ryu and I are both scum... any reasoning for that? What is it about his play that makes you think he's not putting pressure on a scummate to gain distance?

Also, what's your prior mafia experience?


Oops, I misread that.

This is my first time.



Ignores the meat of my post. Not gonna jump on him for it, but it should be noted."


http://www.smashboards.com/showpost.php?p=12573724&postcount=335

"I know I'm missing someone else's question, but I'm having trouble relocating it. Whoever asked--T-block--I think--please re-ask me and I will answer ya."

http://www.smashboards.com/showpost.php?p=12573746&postcount=336

"Quote:
Originally Posted by T-block
@Zigsta: Hmm...when did he say it was his first mafia game? So you think it's unlikely that Red Ryu and I are both scum... any reasoning for that? What is it about his play that makes you think he's not putting pressure on a scummate to gain distance?

Also, what's your prior mafia experience?


Quote:
Originally Posted by Zigsta
Oops, I misread that.

This is my first time.



It's this, Zigsta.

Although it's not quite as relevant anymore.
"


http://www.smashboards.com/showpost.php?p=12573782&postcount=338

"Thanks, T-block.

I don't think both of you are scum because it seems to be that you're legitimately trying to get reads on people. You've personally asked me the most questions out of anyone in the game. I haven't been able to post much, and everyone who's published a list has me as null.

Bottom line is while RR was memeing it up, you were asking me a chunk of questions.

And in my mind it's quite possible that RR was trying to distance himself from Rajam. But like Pierce said, he's muddling the conversation. He's distracting town. I don't see if he DID happen to be town how spamming Rebecca Black could possibly convince town to trust him."




I think Zigsta/Tin Man is not scum based on this interaction.

@Raziek, Hilt and Padô: What conclusions (if any) do you think can be taken in relation to T-block and Zigsta, based on this? (if anyone else wants to address this, it's fine)

---

Red flags on these two posts (specially #263)

http://www.smashboards.com/showpost.php?p=12572736&postcount=260

http://www.smashboards.com/showpost.php?p=12572831&postcount=263

And, about that post I commented, it just look a lot like Rajam's posts. You guys say something serious then go back hiding on the funny-rebecca-friday-funfunfun stuff, this is kind of a stupid parallel but I can't see any reason for doing this since the RVS phase is pretty much over (at least for me). This kind of posts just **** up the town's reads since everything starts to get so confusing.

Rajam is getting his posts a little better but the funny stuff is still there I wonder why right now, why are you guys overextending this? IMO this is bad for town it just makes us confused, if town agree with me (that all this rebecca-stuff is bad for us) could you guys please stop with all this bull****? If not, why are you guys still wanting to make town confused?

unvote


just in case...
That unvote at the end was super unnecesary and scummy.
Sum to that his last wagon-jump

unvote
vote: Padô


---

@Shaya: Still re-reading Day 1. I'll address your questions about T-block, Chibo and RR indirectly during the game while digging stuff

Do you think Omni and me can be both scum?

Do you think T-block, Omni and me can be mafia? (assuming mafia of 3 guys which I think is a decent option)
 

Rajam

Smash Champion
Joined
Oct 3, 2008
Messages
2,175
Location
Santiago, Chile
#270

I see Krystedez being dragged into flavour talk again, partly instigated by RR -_- Then he AtE's to defend it.

Oh right, Pado's post... I will probably label it as dumbtown judging from previous games, but that was a terrible post. To see the interaction between RR and me and immediately jump to the conclusion that we are scummates is...dubious. To be honest, I don't have much of a problem with the conclusion itself (dumbtown, as I said), but I am getting the feeling he is reaching for something to contribute, so he brings up a possibility that no one has really mentioned, without much regard to plausibility, and turns it into an "Aha!" moment.

Rajam, I didn't mind as much... he was not nearly as distracting as RR, and now he seems to be playing seriously. However:



This post follows directly after Omni's post where he mentions Rajam a lot, saying he is perfectly fine with this lynch. Rajam ignores all that, and instead goes IIoA. Why does it matter that Krystedez said the wrong name? Rajam hasn't posted since then.

Frick this game moves fast.
Liking my vote on Padô even more
 

Padô

Smash Lord
Joined
Oct 2, 2007
Messages
1,562
Location
São Paulo, Brazil
@Rajam and interactions between Zig <-> T-Block

Well Rajam, their interaction was pretty much the same as mine and I believe that it could be for the rest of the people into the game.

T-Block's play was based into asking people good questions which my put them into unconfortable positions so he could make up good stuff and manage to make town lynch people but, once you got away from his questions convincingly he just dropped the whole stuff he made abotu you and calld you townie or dumbtownie
 

Padô

Smash Lord
Joined
Oct 2, 2007
Messages
1,562
Location
São Paulo, Brazil
EBWOP: Pressed Enter Accidentaly.

@Rajam and interactions between Zig <-> T-Block

Well Rajam, their interaction was pretty much the same as mine and I believe that it could be for the rest of the people into the game.

T-Block's play was based into asking people good questions which could put them into unconfortable positions so he could make up good stuff and manage to make town lynch people but, once you got away from his questions convincingly, he just dropped the whole stuff he made about you and called you townie or dumbtownie or w/e he called you AKA scum hunting but lying about his reads/making false cases.

IMO, that's what made him look like a townie and later on it turned out to be a surprise to town that he died and flipped scum.

PLEASE, click the preview post button before posting, your last post is a big fat mess

And another thing, you are kidding me you voted me just because I voted the same guy as you. Honestly, if you voted everyone which wagon jumped you should check the last Omni's posts and then you would see stupid wagon baiting comming out of nowhere (not sure if he was kidding about those votes or just messing around) he just seemed to throw away random votes and wait for people to buy his idea and jump into too.

Your other post you quoted from T-Block saying I'm dumbtown, well, I have not said all this right now just because you suspected me. Just make sure you read the below quoted stuff from me to Shaya and you will see I explained T-Blocks play before you voted me, by the way, I believe a lot of people could confirm you that he had been making a LOT of questions SPECIALLY to new players like Krys, Zigsta and me or players which don't have too much experience with Mafia games or are bad at it just like me. I believe it gets a lot easier to pressure people like this then pressuring someone which got 20+ Mafia games.

@Shaya

Did you check my post saying this?

@Shaya

At first I suspected T-Block of being scum because with his interaction with RR at the start of the game, he seemed a little bit unsure about voting RR and at the same time told people to lynch him, maybe he was just scum trying to make himself look town by FoS'ing someone clearly scummy.
But then, as the game proceeded he start to look more safer then usual just following Town's options, doing a little bit of scumhunting and asking good questions to some players. I was starting to go from scum read to leaning town.

As for Chibo, IMO he was null, he didn't contribute too much but he did a really good job at answering a lot of questions about himself and whom he was suspecting off like he does often on other games, nothing special at all, btw I can't get precise reads on Chibo TBH I never could I believe other people have seen me saying this.
http://www.smashboards.com/showpost.php?p=12648408&postcount=1238

I believe it answered both your questions you asked me, am I right?

Anymore questions? I gotta go to the market to buy my mom bananas, apples and peaches for a delicious desert she's making.
 

Padô

Smash Lord
Joined
Oct 2, 2007
Messages
1,562
Location
São Paulo, Brazil
mmmmmmmmmm...
THE ONLY THING that I would say is conclusive is
If three of Mallow, Geno, Peach and Bowser flip TOWN than the last one is scum (mafia/independent). HOWEVER, it isn't possible to conclude anything until that condition is met. Mad scum vibes coming from those two at the moment.
ESPECIALLY at Rajam wanting to pull a mass name claim early on in day 2 when he obviously feels like he can get away with it due to people believing he is town.
Well, I don't know much about this game (SMRPG) since I haven't played it 100%, I just got the second star ****. But, AFAIK, there's no way Bowser could be town so far, could someone confirm me if later in the game (SMRPG) he turns from a baddie to a goodie?

I feel like, based on what I played from the game, he could only be an Indie. No way he could be anything else since Smithy is Mafia.
 

Padô

Smash Lord
Joined
Oct 2, 2007
Messages
1,562
Location
São Paulo, Brazil
@UTD Zac

I believe Rajam is town because of his legit breadcrumbing and the good points he brought into the game (althought I didn't like his recent posts). Also, his role explanation made sense to me, this might seem like a personal opinion but that's why I said "...at least for me..." and "...I feel like...". Is this what confuses you? Tell me specifically what's making you confused and I'll try to fix it lol.
 

Shaya

   「chase you」 
BRoomer
Joined
Jun 8, 2007
Messages
27,654
Location
/人◕‿‿◕人\ FABULOUS Max!
NNID
ShayaJP
Ninja'd by many posts. That last one was to Rajam.

@Pado, I missed that post of yours somehow... but I feel like there's more information that a non-skimming reader would come up with... You haven't changed my opinion of you and there was notable purpose in the chibo questions.

If you've done at least a re-read of Chibo's posts then say so. If you can't state anything further then say so. I'm just under the impression that due to your activity yesterday not leaving much of an impact on me, that it's very possible you really haven't paid enough attention.
 

Shaya

   「chase you」 
BRoomer
Joined
Jun 8, 2007
Messages
27,654
Location
/人◕‿‿◕人\ FABULOUS Max!
NNID
ShayaJP
btw, I feel kinda awkward that it's been silent since this day started pretty much...

Rajam/RR lunacy really filled up the days :|

Being brutally honest here, but I'm not willing to place my vote on someone until the queue of questions have been answered.

I wonder if Omni would continue his wagon if Rajam got to l-2/1?
 

UTDZac

▲▲▲▲▲
BRoomer
Joined
Sep 28, 2005
Messages
6,646
Location
Judgment Count: 856
What did you feel about Chibo at the end of yesterday? Did you think he would die? What information did his death bring to you?

Did you feel T-Block was town? What lead you to believe this?
I felt he was a town player. I've played several games with him before. He basically kinda sits back and doesn't get his hands dirty until he really feels someone is scum. Then he gets all up in their face with it and doesn't drop it. Well, sort of. Either way I didn't expect him to die, I would have expected someone more active like Omni (reasoning coming from "shouldn't scum kill the most active" and from DNM). His death reveals to us a potential switch-a-roo for Night 1, which will probably come in handy later when more people start claiming.

For those of you who don't know what a Bus Driver does, he basically switches two people during the Night. So, for example, if Omni targeted Raziek with a NK and Chibo switch Raziek and T-block, then T-block would die (Raziek would be unaffacted); and whoever targets T-block will instead hit Raziek.

I didn't look into T-block much. I had a town vibe from him because of other people saying "yeah he feels somewhat town." I just kinda took it as is, and didn't bother looking into him.
 

DtJ Hilt

Little Lizard
Joined
Feb 28, 2008
Messages
8,531
Location
Minnow Brook
Yeeeaaahhh procrastination. My bad.
Well, the fact that Chibo died leads me to believe either his Bus Driver role was limited in some way, resulting in his death (perhaps switching with maf kills him?) or he got NK'd.
Either it was something related to his role or it wasn't something related to his role. Not sure what the point in saying the last part was.

T-Block being Smithy surprised the **** out of me, I had him as reasonably pro-Town, definitely going to re-read that. His death means we either have a rapist vig, or Chibo bus'd something.
Or there's a serial killer, or there's another role that can redirect kills, or there's ____. I don't understand why people try to guess how the night victims died during the night phase. It doesn't do anything towards finding scum, in most situations.
I also HEAVILY disagree with trying to break the game via flavor on Day 2. It's not going to legitimately work, because we'd have to mass-claim, which is a really bad idea.
"It's not going to work because it's a bad idea". Haha.
I'm voting Shaya because I feel Rajam has the best play so far, it's the only one, at least for me, which is a confirmed townie and brought up good points by remembering us that he was the one which pressured RR and Chibo quite enough to worth a vote.

Vote: Shaya
The day just began and he's the only play? So there's no one else you're suspicious of? Or do you just not see any of them as viable lynch options at the moment. Or are you just riding on whatever wagon Rajam hops aboard because you're sold on him being confirmed town.
Unvote

Vote: Hilt


Shaya, I have a null on you, for the record. I was voting for you because you were previously one of the most inactive players yesterDay, but toDay you seem to be fine.

Hilt is the MVP shadow of the game atm.
What has your thinking done for you? Anything other than your vote on me?
Can't we do that whole thing without having Mario name claim?
Do you think having the rest of the characters, or players at all, for that matter, claim, is a good idea? Do you support the idea you suggested?
Confirming if an SK exists only proves that the indy faction is prolly like 1 person.
I don't understand this.
Vote: Rajam

This wagon is still good, and it still has cookies.
Curious. You say that the Rajam wagon is still good, which is something I'd expect from you, but have your reasons to vote for him expanded? Or are they based on the same grounds as yesterday's?
eh, confirmed town with a doc and watcher on board is definately not a bad play. But let me think it over a bit more.

vote: shaya
Why did you vote Shaya? Just going along with the wagon? You say you're going to think over "it" a bit more, but throw down a vote. I don't like letting votes like this slip by.
Well, I'll be more active this Thursday evening when I get home. It's impossible for me to stay active right now because I'm studying for exams and getting ready to leave for the summer at the same time.

I'm reading every post though and I'll catch up sometime tomorrow evening so I can have some contribution. Right now I'm just dead from Finals Week... :(
Really hoping to get some content from you this time around :)

How I feel about the whole "Rajam confirmed townie" thing, and the color situation. If RR had flipped scum, I would have figured that him not knowing the town color was based on him being scum and not having been given it, which would mean none of scum was given it. And since Rajam knew it, it would be very, very unlikely that he was scum. But now that RR flipped town, and it turns out he just didn't know the color, there's no reason for people to believe that Rajam is anything close to confirmed townie. After all, we have no way of knowing that scum doesn't know the color. Main reason I'm saying this is, Pado, you were one (maybe the only one, I'm not sure) that consider Rajam confirmed town for sure. What do you think bout this logic? Do you disagree? Does it make sense? I'd like to hear your thoughts about it.

Caught up through #1249.
 

Tin Man

Smash Hero
Joined
Jan 31, 2009
Messages
6,874
Location
Belconnen, ACT, Australia
Sorry for not inputting anything yesterday. I worked, then had a training session, and I was also sick, went straight to bed. I'll contribute today after work, and I have the day off 2morrow so I'll be active by then as well.
 

Pierce7d

Wise Hermit
Joined
Dec 20, 2006
Messages
6,289
Location
Teaneck, North Bergen County, NJ, USA
3DS FC
1993-9028-0439
What has your thinking done for you? Anything other than your vote on me?

Why did you vote Shaya? Just going along with the wagon? You say you're going to think over "it" a bit more, but throw down a vote.
I'm still thinking. I could parrot what everyone else is saying, but I'd rather say something useful, so I haven't spoken yet really. I haven't done my reread since the flip, since these last two days were not devoted towards Mafia, though I'm going to plop back into my normal activity now.

Wasn't I the first person to vote Shaya? Didn't I explain my vote on Shaya when I voted you. I said Shaya was the most inactive in the game, so I was putting my placeholder vote on him. Then he started being active, so you have it for now.

Considering that Booster and Frogfucius were both town characters, and knowing my own role, I am coming of the opinion that the playable characters are not the bulk of town.

Could you use line breaks next time you do a multiquote Hilt?
 

Pierce7d

Wise Hermit
Joined
Dec 20, 2006
Messages
6,289
Location
Teaneck, North Bergen County, NJ, USA
3DS FC
1993-9028-0439
Also, just a bit of meta on T-Block, he has an extremely strong pro-town game where he's scum, and then directs town in later days since he's generally so trusted. He uses this tactic to cloak his scum partners. I'm search to see if there's any players T-Block neglected to mention.
 

Rajam

Smash Champion
Joined
Oct 3, 2008
Messages
2,175
Location
Santiago, Chile
@Rajam

Considering that T-Block and I were buddying yesterday, do you think there a good chance that I'm also scum?
Yes.

Also, just a bit of meta on T-Block, he has an extremely strong pro-town game where he's scum, and then directs town in later days since he's generally so trusted. He uses this tactic to cloak his scum partners. I'm search to see if there's any players T-Block neglected to mention.
Where did you got that meta on scum T-block? Did he won that game? Would you say it was an effective technique for him there?
 

Pierce7d

Wise Hermit
Joined
Dec 20, 2006
Messages
6,289
Location
Teaneck, North Bergen County, NJ, USA
3DS FC
1993-9028-0439
LOL. I'm not scum btw.

Where did you got that meta on scum T-block? Did he won that game? Would you say it was an effective technique for him there?
I read Pokemon Mafia in the staff lounge. It was spectacular and he was the MVP of the game by far. He made several scum slips in Lylo, but there was a town player that was so scummy, he got lynched instead -_-
 

DtJ Hilt

Little Lizard
Joined
Feb 28, 2008
Messages
8,531
Location
Minnow Brook
As hard as it is to explain, no, I can't. But I see the problem it makes in quoting, so I'll find another way to make it easier. Think I have an idea, haha.
 

Raziek

Charging Limit All Day
Joined
Oct 14, 2008
Messages
9,626
Location
Halifax, Nova Scotia
NNID
Raziek
3DS FC
3866-8131-5247
Sorry for more johns, guys, but **** came up in our Smash scene, so I can't do my scheduled re-reading tonight. Sorry. :(
 
Top Bottom