Dr. Mario is in because everyone (well not literally everyone, but many people) hates FLUDD.
Not a good argument since we have custom moves now.
Lucina because some scrubby types like to play Marth but can't tipper worth a ****.
Maybe we should take a gimmickless clone for every character. A Luigi clone without sliding that much or a Little Mac clone without OHKO moves.
And because some people just like Lucina.
I like her, but not the moveset she has. I'm not complaining about her inclusion but her moveset.
Dark Pit because they wanted to have him as a voiced alt costume, but then Sakurai decided that it made no sense for Dark Pit to have access to the Three Sacred Treasures, so they made him his own slot so he could have a different Final Smash.
I know that's possibly the reason for Sakurai, but I think that a stupid reason. Link and Toon Link never ever performed Triforce Slash, and they still have it.
Then they just copy-pasted the Light Arrow onto him so they could get on with more important things, like other newcomers and game balance. They only make clones in their spare time, so to speak, so making Dark Pit's Final Smash unique would not have been a priority. He probably got added VERY last-minute, which is why he just has a retextured Light Arrow.
I know. And that's why his inclusion is that controversial.
I'm not the kind of fanboy who complains every second of his life. I just say there are some clones that could be improved in terms of singularity (Ganondorf, Falco and Toon Link) and some other clones that simply are not the way. You want a Mario without FLUDD? Then customize that move. You want a tipless Marth? Then bring back a very changed and improved Roy. You want Pit with a different FS? Then why don't they do a FS for each/some alt costume?
From another perspective: do you want Dr. Mario? Fine, make him in with
Dr. Mario and
Tetris series moves. You want Lucina? Awesome, she could fit witha new unique sword style. You want Dark Pit? Perfect, let's make a moveset with his special weapons from
Uprising.
And yes, I didn't want to start this clone war again. Just wanted to puntualize some things.