• Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!

    You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!

Shining Force II Mafia || Game Over! Who lived happily ever after?

#HBC | Ryker

Netplay Monstrosity
BRoomer
Joined
Sep 16, 2008
Messages
6,520
Location
Mobile, AL
What made you say this all the sudden? You also never came through with your promise. You stated that you disagreed with almost all of our pushes, but again the only "push" you should have disagreed with was Swiss. Explain.

btw can you stop spaaming the thread with stuff like "die" and useless one liners like that? We get that you don't like dietz, even if you don't have any reason behind it.
His latest post, as should be apparent.

Because lazy.

I dunno? I'm bad at mafia, obviously. I remember distinctly wanting to watch you because I didn't like you. Possibly had something to do with your early game bull****. Then you made a push I found absolutely disgusting.

No, I won't. Every time I post that it's an updated read even if it's unchanged. Generally it also gives you an idea of what I thought of the last post.
 

No Lynch

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Feb 23, 2012
Messages
245
Location
Soup/Zen
I dunno? I'm bad at mafia, obviously. I remember distinctly wanting to watch you because I didn't like you. Possibly had something to do with your early game bull****. Then you made a push I found absolutely disgusting.
You're full of ****.

No, I won't. Every time I post that it's an updated read even if it's unchanged. Generally it also gives you an idea of what I thought of the last post.
You will say that to any post Ryker. You never look at things more than one way. Once you have your mind on something, you just push every post that person makes even when there is nothing scummy about it at all.
 

#HBC | Ryker

Netplay Monstrosity
BRoomer
Joined
Sep 16, 2008
Messages
6,520
Location
Mobile, AL
My play is dependent on the game, but oftentimes you get nothing but a constantly updated read list. You can go to hell. I don't generally shove something through until I've gotten to a point that it's highly unlikely I'm going to change my mind.

So go guzzle gasoline.
 

#HBC | Ryker

Netplay Monstrosity
BRoomer
Joined
Sep 16, 2008
Messages
6,520
Location
Mobile, AL
Give me more and I'll give you more.

Give me a Dietz flip (town or scum) and I'll give you a scumbag. Deal?
 

vanderzant

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Mar 24, 2008
Messages
271
Location
Beneath my dreaming tree
With 13 Alive it takes 7 to lynch.

Red Ryu has been Silenced, and any votes they cast will not be counted for the remainder of the Day!

Voting (7):
Jdietz43 (2): Swiss, Ryker
Swiss (2): Jdietz43, Dark Horse,
felipe_9595 (1): Rockin
Red Ryu (1): Bleck Mang

No Lynch Target (1): felipe_9595


Not Voting (6):
dabuz
July
Red Ryu
th3kuzinator
Orboknown
No Lynch

 

Rockin

Juggies <3
BRoomer
Joined
Oct 16, 2006
Messages
3,546
Location
Bronx, New York
NL, where did that come from, you are getting a little bit paranoid.

http://www.indiedb.com/games/super-smash-bros-crusade

I have been pretty busy working on this game, we have to make a bugfix patch in 1 day (thats why i said i was not going to be here), believe what you want. But i have been really busy.

Also, i havent sleep in 2 days, i have read the topic but barely have any stances (Everybody knows my problem gettings reads due to my english, but you have to add i have sleet 2 hours in 2 days, my mental condition is not the best)
If that was the case (your reasoning due to your english), why do you play the game? I don't understand this...

I am bad because I never play better than bad.

I was really just wondering whether your style involves being condescending, controlling, and intimidating.

My reads are:
RR scum
NL as town
Ryker leaning town
DH leaning town
Orb is dumb or scum
Dietz town
Kuz is leaning scum
Everyone else is null
I'm watching Swiss in particular because my opinion on you keeps changing.
Oh great! you posted your reads...


....but you didn't vote. And you're asking useless questions that doesn't help town at all.

/RAGE

cop and doc should make their own decisions as of now. Tbh we don't even know if swiss and ryker are more protect worthy role wise than someone else would be.
I've seen several posts from you with the extended catchup, and nothing mentions your opinions about what's been happening.

/RAGE

I'm more than willing to ask people questions about what I should do at this point, I can be selective and standoffish when I actually know what's a good idea for myself
You could just...vote on who you think is scummy and pressure them for their lynch....>_>

@Rockin: Hydra derp of difference of opinions. You quoted Gorf then you quoted myself. xD

I like the opinion you have given on Kuzi as being scum, but I dno't really feel that's why I have Kuzi as scum. What you are saying is more of an exaggeration of what he has actually done TBH. Plus your other three scum-picks are just the inactives/no-shows sans Kuzi.

Can you give me your opinions on Swiss/Ryker/NL?
Again, it's just the thing I noticed in terms of his motives. Or reasons why are different....so eh. *shrugs* lol

Swiss is Raging hard atm, but he still knows how to show his Swiss like self (being confident, trolling others a little, etc.). For the moment, I see him as town. He's really giving effort to wanting Dietz lynched. He's been contributing, so I have no qualms with him

ryker is about the same as Swiss, only being a bit more...harsh and angry? lol. I havn't seen a big post with him. Just more of a 'who should die' list. Null atm

No Lynch is Town, without a doubt. He's really giving effort to contributing. I do think he needs to relax more, cause he seems to get angry a bit too quickly.


I do believe that we've been debating about Dietz long enough, and should try to focus our power to other players as well (peferably the quiet ones). We shouldn't let this topic dominate most of D1, especially considering we have till March 5th to lynch someone.

Kuz, who do you feel is scum and why?

Felipe - what are you planning on doing?

No Lynch - do you still think that DH is scum? Your votes seem to be flip flopping atm.

Swiss - assuming JDiez isn't the play. Is there anyone else in mind you want to lynch?

As much as I dislike Kuzi this game, the more I read this line the more I dislike it because it just isn't true at all.



It's just....wrong. Like wrong wrong wrong. X_x
 

Rockin

Juggies <3
BRoomer
Joined
Oct 16, 2006
Messages
3,546
Location
Bronx, New York
lol forgot to say a comment to that last quote lol

My comment to that is just.... *shrugs* we have our differences of reasons/opinions why we don't like Kuz, It can't be helped...
 

Jdietz43

BRoomer
BRoomer
Joined
Apr 3, 2008
Messages
2,625
Location
Milwaukee
You could just...vote on who you think is scummy and pressure them for their lynch....>_>
That isn't a comment on the current situation, that's a response to one of Swiss's inquiries as to why I was asking town 'obvious' questions at one point. If you haven't noticed: my vote and stance are pretty Swiss oriented atm
 

~Bleck Mang~

Smash Rookie
Joined
Feb 23, 2012
Messages
0
Location
THERE'S SEMEN IN MY WALRUS
lol forgot to say a comment to that last quote lol

My comment to that is just.... *shrugs* we have our differences of reasons/opinions why we don't like Kuz, It can't be helped...
The thing about this "difference" of opinions is that what you are saying has no supporting evidence to back up what you are saying because the facts aren't there. Can you show me what exactly you are talking about with your different opinion as to why Kuzi is scum?
 

~Bleck Mang~

Smash Rookie
Joined
Feb 23, 2012
Messages
0
Location
THERE'S SEMEN IN MY WALRUS
Rockin said:
I do believe that we've been debating about Dietz long enough, and should try to focus our power to other players as well (peferably the quiet ones). We shouldn't let this topic dominate most of D1, especially considering we have till March 5th to lynch someone.
Post of interest if Dietz flips scum.
 

Jdietz43

BRoomer
BRoomer
Joined
Apr 3, 2008
Messages
2,625
Location
Milwaukee
(I'm willing to focus on other people should it come to that for the record though, Swiss just gave me the biggest scumtells and made it hard for me to ignore him)
 

~Bleck Mang~

Smash Rookie
Joined
Feb 23, 2012
Messages
0
Location
THERE'S SEMEN IN MY WALRUS
Ditzy, let's talk a bit. If you can't have Swiss than who would you like to focus on?

Gimme a read on Kuzi and then talk about Rockin and what vibes you have gotten off his last couple posts. Then tell me would you be willing to lynch RR?
 

Rockin

Juggies <3
BRoomer
Joined
Oct 16, 2006
Messages
3,546
Location
Bronx, New York
The thing about this "difference" of opinions is that what you are saying has no supporting evidence to back up what you are saying because the facts aren't there. Can you show me what exactly you are talking about with your different opinion as to why Kuzi is scum?
Alright, I'll do my best

When Kuz came in to replace Bardul, he quickly goes to vote Jdietz

Vote: Jdietz43
Follow by a form of confidence that Jdietz is scum

Swiss, if I told you I was 100% sure Ditz was scum would you switch to his wagon on the assumption that I shot DH toNight?
And when he wanted to show his reason, he did.

I'm surprised. You've been quite analytical this game yet have failed to notice how transparent Ditz is being.

He's being way too cautious. All of his posts have a backdoor attached. He hasn't taken a firm stance on a single thing. When asked who he'd want to lynch toDay, he said leaning Dark Horse but that that feel was diminishing because of the scene Felipe was making (implying that he felt Felipe was scummy/a higher priority), yet fails to even comment on his read on Felipe. He then closes the post by saying that, if he had to guess, Bardull is town but that read in analogous to guessing that the sky was blue. When he's called out by Swiss for posting so safely, he retorts that it's because Swiss is asking him safe questions.

My problem with him isn't because he has a lack of stances, it's that every stance he attempts to give comes with an escape route attached.
Almost every post he's written he's taken a completely neutral stance on whatever is presented - swaying from one side to the other. Textbook noobscum.
IFrom the sound of things, he was pretty much set on doing his hardest to get him lynched. You'd think he'd be pretty stubborn about it, given his confidence. But then something happened. When Dietz mentioned about the neighboring thing, Kuz got a bit interested.

Dietz: Your neighbor's alignment is not confirmed to you, yes? First off, don't tell him your role. Secondly, in what manner did he ask you for his role? Did he offer to reveal his to you/has he already done so?
It came to the point where he was more interested lynching the said person and not Dietz

I would be in support of you telling me who your partner is. I would also be in support of lynching that person.
It seemed clear that Kuz 'deflated' the hot air he had of lynching him and focused on this would-be neighbor of his, as well as clearly saying he would lynch the person.

Then the most lulz worthy thing happened, and looking back on it again makes it even funnier for two reasons

1) Kuz didn't even try to vote Swiss. In fact, he seemed to believed him almost immediately (as that makes sense. Still lulz about not going with his word)

So Swiss. You did not ask him to roleclaim?
I told him not to claim in thread.

I did probe him as to his alignment, and may have offered him a fakeclaim to see if he'd bite. But he clammed up and stopped responding. Like he was waiting for help.
2) the fact that he thought swiss was the neighbor, who, at the time, labled Dietz as n00bscum

I'm guessing by saying that, it must've made things awkward for Kuz and decided to not voice on it at the time...

When Dietz actually claimed who it was, again he never tried to attack me or pressure me. Instead, he said some positive things/conclusions about it

And all this can simply be analyzed through perspectives. Why would scum Dietz bother revealing his neighborhood when there was no reason too. If he was on a scumteam, his mates would have told him to pump info out of Rockin or at least play along until they could get a handle on him. The fact that he gave it up for no reason just means he doesn't have anything to gain from keeping the masonry hidden, something scum would definitely have.

Also, everyone feel free to ignore Swiss. He's not reading mafia atm. Probably indy. Will be dealt with later.
Stop being dense. I had read Dietz as scum but have changed my read with these new string of posts. You're wrong on them not being genuine. I thought they were very convincing. And I'm not insulting the intelligence of Rockin. His scummates, if they were competent to any degree, could have told him to act noobish in the QT and try and gain Rockin's trust. He wouldn't pump info from Rockin, he would just simply ask Rockin to claim to him after he fake-claimed to Rockin. Simple as anything.

You're way over-complicating the scenario and reaching to do so.
After I confirmed it, most of his attention and comments went towards Swiss in defense of Dietz. Unvoted and hasn't said much who he thinks is scummy. No Lynch brought up his thoughts on me, as well as wondered if he still wanted to lynch me.

Kuz what happened to wanting to lynch Rockin?
2 things.

1. It's Rockin.
2. I re-examined my mindset wrt to how Deitz described the interaction and kind of agree with some of Swiss' rationale. As a neighbor partner I myself probably would pump a newbie for info, even as town, just so if he told me I could get a honest read on the player slot. I probably wouldn't have been concerned with him knowing we weren't confirmed as much as I would have wanted an untainted esponse.
Reasoning seem a bit weak IMO.

Kuzi, since I have ya here, do ya mind if I pick your brain a tad?

What is your read on Rockin? If the Swiss wagon continued picking up speed, would you join in?

*just saw vote-count*

Wooooow, I completely forgot Felipe was even in this game. He is in the same category as Orbo.
Rocking currently is null. I would.
And here's his response towards your question.

This is why I feel that Kuz is looking like an opportunist:being ready to pounce on a possible easy wagon.
 

Jdietz43

BRoomer
BRoomer
Joined
Apr 3, 2008
Messages
2,625
Location
Milwaukee
Ditzy, let's talk a bit. If you can't have Swiss than who would you like to focus on?

Gimme a read on Kuzi and then talk about Rockin and what vibes you have gotten off his last couple posts. Then tell me would you be willing to lynch RR?
Ryker, because he gives me vibes as bad as Swiss, he spends all his time bashing and being unhelpful. (but that won't happen considering people see his play in the same line as Swiss's play and consider it normal Ryker)

After that it's mostly the unhelpfuls such as Felipe, Orbo, and Dabuz (in that order). Red Ryu has been doing a lot to help win my trust back after the rocky start, and I would have had him near the top of this list not too long ago, I'm not as sure as I was anymore but I would probably still lynch him if it came down to it.



Kuzi seems like a good townie to me, he's the one I trust second most after NL. I can see why people would have doubts since he's been playing close to the chest, but since the most needling has been coming from Ryker/Swiss (and yourself) I've been hard pressed to take it without more than a few grains of salt.
 

th3kuzinator

Smash Master
Joined
Mar 17, 2010
Messages
3,620
Location
Winning
I'm honestly really getting tired to repeating myself. Rockin, most of those things in your post I've already explained 10 times over. The other bits are just blatant reaching in an attempt to bring the whole thing together into something worth talking about.
 

Rockin

Juggies <3
BRoomer
Joined
Oct 16, 2006
Messages
3,546
Location
Bronx, New York
I'm honestly really getting tired to repeating myself. Rockin, most of those things in your post I've already explained 10 times over. The other bits are just blatant reaching in an attempt to bring the whole thing together into something worth talking about.
I remember what you said before. You said you change reads (If I'm not mistaken).

Still, I dislike how that high amount of confidence you had (despite your changes) easily deflates after hearing our side of the story and then moving onto something else.
 

th3kuzinator

Smash Master
Joined
Mar 17, 2010
Messages
3,620
Location
Winning
And I don't know which part of NL posted that bit about lynching Dietz despite having a town read on him just because he was such a big topic of conversation, but I hope it was Soup. We're not lynching Dietz. I'm with Zen (I think?) that I will literally fight his attackers into the ground. It's never a good idea to lynch someone you think is town even if you think you're getting connections, and with the degree of certainty my read holds I won't let it happen.

Real life hits me hard during the week hence why I'm not being more proactive. Deal with it.
 

th3kuzinator

Smash Master
Joined
Mar 17, 2010
Messages
3,620
Location
Winning
I remember what you said before. You said you change reads (If I'm not mistaken).

Still, I dislike how that high amount of confidence you had (despite your changes) easily deflates after hearing our side of the story and then moving onto something else.
I'm always confident in anything I push until I'm proven otherwise. This is definitely a case where relevant in-game action was sufficient enough to change my read. I've already explained this 3 separate times to three separate people.

If you disagree with my logic as to why my read changed, then do something about it. Don't clutter the thread recycling already used arguments.
 

th3kuzinator

Smash Master
Joined
Mar 17, 2010
Messages
3,620
Location
Winning
And J, I'm pretty sure I know why you have a scum read on me. It's my tone. I've been more passive and slightly apathetic. There's a reason for this and I'll discuss it with you at endgame if you want.

On to more important things. What's your read on Ryker? What about DH?

@Rockin: who do you want lynched toDay?
 

Rockin

Juggies <3
BRoomer
Joined
Oct 16, 2006
Messages
3,546
Location
Bronx, New York
And J, I'm pretty sure I know why you have a scum read on me. It's my tone. I've been more passive and slightly apathetic. There's a reason for this and I'll discuss it with you at endgame if you want.

On to more important things. What's your read on Ryker? What about DH?

@Rockin: who do you want lynched toDay?
Felipe.

already made my list and reason from must need to least need
 

No Lynch

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Feb 23, 2012
Messages
245
Location
Soup/Zen
@Dietz: What makes you dislike Oro more than dabuz (or what makes you like dabuz more)?
@Kuz: Would you still be willing to lynch Swiss today? Do you see scum behind his posts?
@Rockin: You have RR as town right? What about July?
 

July

Smash Apprentice
Joined
Jun 1, 2010
Messages
142
Location
Philadelphia, PA
Can you show the bolded Pink because this is a first can recall you saying that you didn't see the town intent behind some posts. Most of your responses about disliking our slot were based around the attitude of our posts and Gorf's suspicions. It seems from the tone of this post, most of your qualms have been terminated by what I have said. =3


As much as I love that, I still am trying to figure you out as to why you have this super-scum read on me dear because I am still not getting the bottom line as to why we are scum?
Yes yes I can address some of those posts that made me uneasy about your intent, and that's where the scum read comes from and hangs in there (it's not a super scum read, you've definitely alleviated many of the concerns I had about sidelining that made me feel you were extremely scummy).

Things like this:

Am I the only one that finds this string of quotes humorous =P?

Anyway, Dark Horse, if you really are town I would get off of your high horse (I couldn't resist duder =3) and start complying, because you seem a very weird for somebody who has as much suspicion as he has on him.
Idk what your real intentions are. What you say here is correct, but it's not really giving an opinion or reads or scumhunting; it's just advice. And I think that while it might just be you being nice and being nice guys, it could also have scummy intent of faking content and making it look like you were contributing to the convo on Dark Horse when you really weren't. And then you do it again here:

Bleck! Get out of that mindset mister! If you think Swiss needs to be looked at, it shouldn't matter that others don't, it's your job to convince them and get them to understand where you're coming from duder. Whether all of town sees the merit in what you're saying or not shouldn't matter as long as you think he needs looking at.
Once again, this post is purely advice, and since this happened twice in a short span of time in the beginning of the game, it seems highly likely your intent was just to look like you were contributing or furthering the conversation when really you were just giving advice.

And then it happens again with Felipe telling him to not be rude to bardull, but that one was a more warranted.
K here we go yo. Lemme start off with this Unvote Vote: JDietz. I'll get back to that later.

For right now, I'm really digging July's wall (even though her walls annoy the living hell out of me :glare:). The thing that really separates how I feel about that wall and down right near anything she posted in Walgreens is that, even after last night, there's a lot of memory of it that I have. She's really stuck her head out and made an effort to make an impact, whereas in Walgreens each of her posts were essentially geared to be so unreadable that I'd just not even bother and skip on. That, and the fact that J is a little July fanboy, is really making me dig her.

I'm loving the Bardull/Kuz slot. Bardull's daring and showing that he's looking to scumhunt painted him as pretty obvtown to me, and no I'm not gonna be one of the clowns that are JUST gonna drop that cuz Kuz is taking that slot (and of course I wasn't just gonna give Kuz a free pass but anyway...). And then, when I read Kuz' spiel on JDietz it really got me to understand what it is I was thinking about JDietz as I was looking into em in the beginning (I think I touched on it last night).

As far as Swiss, Rockin, and Ryker go, they all seem fine for me as far as living through toDay. All of them have been open with what they've been feeling and doing their part to scumhunt (haven't really read Rockin v Ryker, gonna do that after I'm done with this), so ultimately no qualms in this here area. And now that I think about it I'm fine with putting No Lynch in this category too.

Red Ruy bugs me, and it's not because of how Red Ruy usually is. There's really nothing concrete that I have on him, but it feels like a majority of what he's doing is too methodical, too planned, too polished... His idea of wanting to lynch based off of experience or something like that was totally offsetting, and off base considering the fact that I remember that being a problem in Adventure Time... call me the devil's advocate but I can see scumRuy wanting to use that as a way to look like he's doing something that'll help town out, rather than sticking to his norm as scum and not really being in the scene. Plus his whole stopping of Ryker's pressure was sooooooo "What would a townie say at this point hurr durr?".

I think I touched on Felipe last night, but he's just so antitown and such a nuisance, to me, that I don't even want to waste my time looking into him... If he's still alive by near end game I'll look into em and read em. If he's got a wagon on em I'll join. But he continues, on a regular, to do dirt poor nothing and I don't wanna go out of my way to get em to try and care. I can't change him, the only thing I can change is how I handle the situation (thank you therapy :cool:).

Dark Horse is probz my second strongest scum read atm, and not too far behind JDietz. His very first post in the game was so wtfareyoudoing it's insane, and like I said it'd TOTALLY make sense with a JDietz-DH scum team noob scum mistake, going all chainsaw defense on dat a**. Plus all of his snide remarks when people are pressuring him, and his super defensive attitude, all make me think DH scum. BUT, if there's a DH town flip, then that really opens me up to Felipe scum cuz of that whole him hopping up on the DH wagon for no reason thing, and I'm sure scumFelipe would be thinking townDH is a balls easy lynch.

I already voiced my thoughts about JDietz... But I think he deserves a lot more pressure than what he's getting. It's almost like he's being fed on how to play scum by someone, but that you can tell it's noobscum. I see a lot of my noobscum mistakes in him. He's yet to make a concrete stance on anything. And I read back on JDietz' posts. Literally everything has a condition attached. As far as content goes, he has content flow, but it's a severe case of quality > quantity. His posts are so meek, so bland. He deserves eons more pressure than what he's getting.
Then there's this post, which was really unnerving for me. You've been quite vocal about supporting me and finding me town this game, and like a lot of the other things I've addressed, it's determining whether or not this is the case or if you are being nice to me because both you think that being nice to me will make me soften my scum read (which has been an issue for me in the past, admittedly). Also the

Why is Felipe not on this list w.r.t. Orbo/Dabuz?
Because (at the time you asked this question and the time of my original post), Orbo and dabuz hadn't posted anything of substance and Orbo stated he was willing to just blindly follow Swiss which isn't very comforting for his motivation to play the game. Felipe hasn't been too active lately, but I remember some stances he made, specifically on bardull/Kuz and No Lynch being town.

I also would like for you to explain your Kuzi-townish read because you are the first person to voice such an opinion so far this game. (I thiiiiiiink NL said something about liking Kuzi but I got confused since it was so whiplashish ^^")
I like that he stopped pushing JDeitz when he saw town intent behind his posts, that has been a huge factor for me, and the fact that he hasn't budged at the questions and pressures for changing that read which he has garnered. I also liked his interactions with you, which were at some points focused on the JDeitz issue and the fact that he tried to shut down the conversation when it got away from scumhunting/asking legitimate questions (like when you posted "Even July has lynched you before. Swiss can deffo pull it off so don't be like that. xD") and his response was "Stopping this conversation right here. I have no interest in discussing bravado.").

What are your "weak suspcions" of Swiss, dear? You say you don't wanna lynch him but if a good case comes along, you may go along with it? Let me try and clarify something w.r.t. your Swiss read:

Swiss is null right now where you don't see scum but you don't really see scum but if someone were to persuade you well enough with a decent case as to why he is scum, you may be swayed to go along with a lynch even though you aren't confident that he would flip scum and you feel there are better choices for toDay's lynch?

*phew* That was a lot but I think I got it. xD
Weak suspicions on Swiss (once again, at the time of this post) were that he was pushing someone I have as a strong town read on and it was a push that wasn't really substantiated.

The Swiss lynch thing...is not explained here (and maybe not in my post) like I wanted to explain it.

I don't see Swiss as a good lynch for toDay. I think the chances that Swiss is even a viable lynch for toDay, as in anyone could get enough support for a Swiss lynch, is quite low. I don't see myself going along with a Swiss lynch unless it was a choice of lynching him or no lynching. I do however, want to hear why people want to lynch him, and why they are confident enough in their scum reads on him to support his lynch. I'm not confident he would flip scum at all because any suspicions I've had on him were based on his actions, not his intent because reading Swiss is like trying to read Greek for me: I'd love to be able to do it, I'd like to have confidence I can do it, but really I can make out some meaning here and there but it's for the most part incomprehensible for me.
 

#HBC | Red Ryu

Red Fox Warrior
Joined
Jun 15, 2008
Messages
27,486
Location
Milwaukee, Wisconsin
NNID
RedRyu_Smash
3DS FC
0344-9312-3352
Bleck Mang, I haven't talked to you.

What do you think of Rockin's post on Kuz or rather to be more specific, does it change your read on his slot?

~

Kuz, you read Swiss' case on Jay, Deitz if it isn't clear. Does any of it change your thoughts on Jay, because I still disagree with his case even if I can see a bit of town from what Swiss posted there.

~

Ryker, please die.
 

#HBC | Red Ryu

Red Fox Warrior
Joined
Jun 15, 2008
Messages
27,486
Location
Milwaukee, Wisconsin
NNID
RedRyu_Smash
3DS FC
0344-9312-3352
July, my in pieces case is why I want him dead. But it's not in full and I need to get the Deitz v Him, and Kuz vs Him up.
 

July

Smash Apprentice
Joined
Jun 1, 2010
Messages
142
Location
Philadelphia, PA
Dabuz #757 I would like reasons for his reads on DH, Kuz, and RR if he hasn't provided them already. I do agree with him, however, that if JDeitz is playing the noob card, it'll be obvious after another Day or so, so I don't see why he is such a huge threat that he needs to be lynched right now when there is a lot of contrary evidence to the JDietz scum theory.

Swiss does start to provide reasoning in #780 for his push on JDietz, and while I understand not trusting "dumb and honest" play (Ran pulled that in his first newb too), I think that JDietz transcends that combination of safe, dumb, and honest which work together in newb scum. He played safe at first, but once he started playing honest I think a lot of that safety went out the window: I don't think that claiming he had a neighbor was safe, nor providing the name of his neighbor, and I find it a lot less likely it was feed to him, especially with how fast the game was going at that point, and much more likely it is honest and he really is town.

@JDeitz: Your vote is on Swiss correct? In your #813 you say you don't want to lynch Felipe, but you'd be willing to. Who all would you be willing to lynch toDay, and of those people which do you find truly suspicious? Would you lynch Rockin toDay if a wagon formed on him?

@Swiss' #847: Your points on his #247 ("He came off strong digging himself a big hole, then recently has done an ok job of coming back out of it a tad. I'm inclined to side with the people who actually know him to a certain extent though") and this part of his #367: "
I figured the best way for me to help was just give my honest opinions and waffle them some so no one took them too serious. That way mafia doesn't care about me, and the people who actually know what they're doing right now don't get pulled off track. But I guess that backfired some because now people are paying attention to the fact I was doing that. I've been looking at wikis a lot to try and figure out what I should be doing, but the hard and fast rules I could figure out were just not to say absolutely nothing and don't warpath everyone in sight for no reason either.
Were the strongest part of your case to me, and I did have to go back and look at the context of those because you make some valid points. That doesn't invalidate the points made about why he looks like newb town though. However, why is it so imperative to you that JDeitz is lynch toDay over one of your other scum read? You seem extremely confident that you've nailed JDeitz as scum, do you really think he's that much of a threat that he is the only play possible toDay?

I'm not in favor of lynching you or JDietz toDay, I have a town read on you both. My only reason for considering either of your lynches right now is because I'm not sure you guys can co-exist for another Day phase if both of you make it through toDay -_-

@No Lynch's #848: That's a drastic change in opinion after saying something along the lines of being willing to die for JDeitz...how much were you influenced by Swiss's case, and what parts were convincing to you? (I realize only one head feels this way but I would like that head to answer this please)

Part 2 is on hold while I try and analyze Swiss' case on Jay.

Also after I get my program done.
When do you think this will be?

@Kuz: I feel like you are ignoring me ;-; Thoughts on Rockin?
 

#HBC | Red Ryu

Red Fox Warrior
Joined
Jun 15, 2008
Messages
27,486
Location
Milwaukee, Wisconsin
NNID
RedRyu_Smash
3DS FC
0344-9312-3352
I don't see Swiss as a good lynch for toDay. I think the chances that Swiss is even a viable lynch for toDay, as in anyone could get enough support for a Swiss lynch, is quite low. I don't see myself going along with a Swiss lynch unless it was a choice of lynching him or no lynching. I do however, want to hear why people want to lynch him, and why they are confident enough in their scum reads on him to support his lynch. I'm not confident he would flip scum at all because any suspicions I've had on him were based on his actions, not his intent because reading Swiss is like trying to read Greek for me: I'd love to be able to do it, I'd like to have confidence I can do it, but really I can make out some meaning here and there but it's for the most part incomprehensible for me.
This part.

I'll get it up after midnight CST then I'll hammer in part 3 before I go to bed at like 3-4 in the morning if I procrastinate it too much.
 

Jdietz43

BRoomer
BRoomer
Joined
Apr 3, 2008
Messages
2,625
Location
Milwaukee
@Dietz: What makes you dislike Oro more than dabuz (or what makes you like dabuz more)?


The way he casually just threw his vote in blindly trusting Swiss before he read anything like he just didn't even care. (Especially after he had already said it would be a bad idea to blindly follow Swiss in his first post iirc) Dabuz at least showed up to the door and had the courtesy to read (or even simply pretend to read) the thread first.

That's about the only difference between them right now.
 

July

Smash Apprentice
Joined
Jun 1, 2010
Messages
142
Location
Philadelphia, PA
This part.

I'll get it up after midnight CST then I'll hammer in part 3 before I go to bed at like 3-4 in the morning if I procrastinate it too much.
Ah kk.

July read is Ryker being lazy or purposefully doing this?
I think he's doing it purposely because he's content with his reads right now and has a clear idea of what direction he wants town to go in right now. He could do that as scum, but I think he's much more likely to do so as town, thinking that his scumreads are correct and thus it is in town's best interests to push his scumreads until they are the play for the Day.
 
Top Bottom