Rocky Mafia | Day 7 | Game Over | Roles/Night Actions/Comments up on pg 57/58

[SummonerAU]

Oh gawd ILAG, your posts are so ********. His coconut gun, can fire in spurts.

ILAG, I swear that I am town.

Okay, now would it be ******** to vote for me? No, it wouldn't. It's a closed game ILAG, people can claim whatever they want. If everyone believed every claim in a game of mafia, the mafia would win every game

 

[SummonerAU]

I agree with your plan Vlade. If he shoots ya, it's gunna hurt. OH GAWD IT'S SO NICE TO NOT HAVE TO WORRY ABOUT THE BLOODY POST RESTRICTION.

1) Vlade is truthful. Cop investigates tonight. Reveals tomorrow. We gain an advantage going into later game. Cop is out in the open.
2) Vlade is truthful. No cop. Nothing happens tomorrow.
3) Vlade is truthful. Cop. No Doc. Mafia don't realise there isn't a doc.
4) Vlade is mafia. Fellow mafia claims cop. Big mafia play until a counterclaim.


Did I say anything that isn't right? Feel free to disagree.

 

[Hobobloke]

I think if Vlade is willing to go that far he's probably telling the truth. regardless if we're doing the pln or not I guess I should

Unvote: Vlade

ILAG you're really killing me, your posts are so laughable no-one will ever take you seriously. Just because you have an opinion on something does not mean that opionon is a unanimously agreed upon fact!

 

[Vlade]

That's 2 so far, 20 minutes to go

Will extend if there's 4 after 20 minutes

 

[Vlade]

Vyse can we please have a vote count? Just curious on what they are, since I think a few of us are on equal votes

 

[Vyse]

Another day extension will not happen. You guys are given 14 days to scum hunt each game day leaving you more than enough time to come to a majority.

4th Official Day 2 Vote Count:
(1) No Lynch : Afropony
(3) undead_moose : LeishaChu, Muzga, SummonerAU
(1) xXArrowXx : Pete278
(1) Sieg : I LAG
(2) Vlade : unreon, undead_moose
(1) Afropony : Toshi
(1) I LAG : Sieg
(1) Toshi : Vlade

(3) Not voting: luke_atyeo, xXArrowXx, Lord Bowser

With 14 alive, it takes a vote of 8 to lynch!
A deadline has been set for 11:59PM December 23rd AEST!
If a majority is not reached, the person with the highest number of votes will be lynched!
If multiple people have the majority of votes, whoever reached that majority first will be lynched!
If no votes are cast then the game moderator will roll dice!

 

[Vlade]

Thanks Vyse

Since there hasn't been enough people to support my idea I will not be choosing relaxed tonight. If you are a Doctor, Cop, or any pro-town role, DO NOT target me.

By all means I can be investigated another night to erase all suspicion

 

[unreon]

unvote: Vlade

Sorry, I've been out all night at a family dinner and completely missed this midnight thing Vlade was deciding on.

Apologies Vlade for putting you in this position. However, I still strongly urge that an investigation take place. Put me on the vote for placing an investigation. That leaves one left, and for the sake of information I am very strongly in favour for this position.

We still have no idea who is who, and any kind of confirmation would be a plus.

Also, WOW @Bowser's meltdown lol.

 

[luke_atyeo]

ok well I'm going to go with my gut feeling on this, since I have been hounding him the entire of this game day

Vote [undead_moose]

although I still think it would be wiser to go after toshi, because as I said, if moose cannot be killed directly, killing toshi will kill him and cricumvent this, I assume this because of what he said, and because it was only when toshi was on the verge of being killed that he revealed himself and went ape****. (not when he himself was being targeted) nobody agrees with me on this?

hell we dont even know if he is mafia, but whole point of this is to get some concrete information, so keep your eyes peeled from now on guys.

 

[Vlade]

Okay for some really stupid reason I thought today was wednesday

You guys still have 20 or so hours to support the investigation

 

[undead_moose]

Fine vote me

See what happens

Dont say you wernt warned.

 

[undead_moose]

Looks like im going to have to get things started then

Anyone who is still voting for me is number 1 on my suss list especially Summoner

If im lynched i wont die so you are all wasting another day

Its funny to watch town shoot itself in the foot like this

 

[luke_atyeo]

if you dont die we're not wasting a day, we learn that your a town for CERTAIN and then we can work from there.

 

[luke_atyeo]

and if anyone is still having trouble understanding the reasoning behind this, its called working out a puzzle through process of elimination, a simple yet very effective method of working out problems of any kind, shooting us in the foot is not what is going to happen

 

[Hobobloke]

So our strategy is to attempt to lynch moose to clear his name if he survives or kill a mafia if he doesn't and investigate Vlade tonight while the doctor protects him?

 

[xXArrowXx]

dont vote moose u *******
such a fail strat. atleast one of the people who voted for moose are mafia if not 2. ironically no one suspects these people..

vote: luke
for being a moose voting ******, trying to call it simple and fail proof when its fail so fail.

but yeah not like its gonna stop the stupid vote sorry moose -.-

 

[xXArrowXx]

no vlade is tense, he will kill all who target him. so use your turn to investigate someone else, someone thats not in the spot light.
except maybe a roleblocker. but that would just mess things up =P

 

[Level 9 Luigi]

How is it a mafia strategy to test someone's identity? It hardly matters if they're lynch immune. You're just acting more and more suspicious.

Ach, this is really Pete. Ignore the name.

 

[Pete278]

Reposting the above to clarify for anyone:

How is it a mafia strategy to test someone's identity? It hardly matters if they're lynch immune. You're just acting more and more suspicious.

 

[Muzga]

As ive said i am happy to sacrifice myself if it proves moose is town to all of you. i fail to see why moose would try and talk me out of it if he IS lynch immune is should be kosher and im okay with it. i voted for him first and IMO everyone should vote for him. its okay, i dont care if i die as a result:D i just want town to win

 

[luke_atyeo]

something like that, and if moose is mafia, then arrow and toshi are most likely to be mafia aswell, and then we can go back over all the old posts and see who's been working with them.

if he's innocent then we at least know toshi is as well, and we just have to look at the toshi voters for mafia members no?

 

[xXArrowXx]

no idiot.
moose came out because of the townies voting off toshi.

if he is town he is telling truth, if so mafia kills him. then probably toshi next night
if he is mafia he is lying, then he dies and i guess u can lynch toshi and me.. 3 mafia off the bat, thats ********. so i highly doubt that.

its a waste of a vote. gaining trust, just to get slaughtered. u are back at square one, douches. kill someone worth the time.

 

[xXArrowXx]

btw toshi was "random" lynch started by atyeo...

 

[luke_atyeo]

oh a new page, didnt see that, well the above post was in response to lord bowser

anyways arrow I dont need to say anything because pete already said it "How is it a mafia strategy to test someone's identity? It hardly matters if they're lynch immune. You're just acting more and more suspicious."

but I will anyways, in response to this arrow "for being a moose voting ******, trying to call it simple and fail proof when its fail so fail."

not only does this not make sense gramitically, it doesnt make sense logically either, I'm not saying we should lynch him because I have proof (he did say some suss stuff, but no proof)
I'm saying we should lynch him to create proof, innocent or not WE NEED TO CREATE A FOOTHOLD
doing this will create that, and then we can work from there rather then running around in circles.


"atleast one of the people who voted for moose are mafia if not 2. ironically no one suspects these people.."

no-one has openly suspected me because everything I say and do, I explain in full detail using logic and I try to incite group discussion and opinion, and I've been sticking to the 1 lead I had and fully exploring it.

you on the other hand keep changing your mind randomly, and you seem to think that you can decide things for everyone and if they dont go along with what you decided then they are ********, the conclusions I draw from this are either that you are a really bad obvious mafia, or that you are a really bad town who isnt helping in any way, but rather then accuse you of anything, I'm going to wait and see what happens to moose because if he is mafia then it'll be obvious that you are too, if he's innocent then it doesnt nessacaraly mean you are too, but it'll at least give you some trust back.

comprende?

 

[luke_atyeo]

if he is town he wont die, surely theres a doctor who has been watching and will protect him.

how about this, if the lynch fails and he lives, then vlade should set himself to 'tense' and the doctor can protect moose.

if moose is lynched and is mafia, then vlade should set himself to 'relaxed' and the doctor can protect him and the cop can investigate him.

'btw toshi was "random" lynch started by atyeo...' this is true, I started it by randomally picking a name, if you dont want to believe me, fine I dont really mind, but if moose is mafia then everyone that voted toshi becomes a suspect, including me, I'm willing to take that risk to create this foothold that I'm always going on about.

 

[xXArrowXx]

we have a foot hold
u just want to test it.

its not everyone that disagrees with me is sus...
i openly suspect you, you boy scout u.

 

[xXArrowXx]

thats sounds promising. so i guess the town will go with that.

however ide rather not waste a lynch.
and if the mafia knows of this plan, they would just kill someone else =P

ide protect moose with doctor
set vlade to tense
and lynch someone that seems sus.

i guess i am just more willing to trust people -,- but yeah go with that plan, i wont accept it, but i wont deny it -.-

 

[luke_atyeo]

it may seem as though I'm pushing for my way here, but after the whole moose coming out thing I left it alone for a while, and everyone ran around in cricles and voted heaps spread out, no one was unifying on anything, so while my plan may not be perfect, at least I am trying to get us to come together and accomplish something instead of timing out with 1 vote on everyone and causing us to not get an effective lynch.

in short, rather then waste a lynch because we're out of time and no one could agree on anyone else, we're using a lynch to test a foothold, does that make it sound a little better for you?

 

[I LAG]

why dont we just go back to "ilags not mafia list"

luke swear that you will never use snake again if u are caught mafia

if he doesn't respond to this at least we know 1 mafia

 

[Leisha]

I really hope all of this will be worth it... =< Looks like today is finally the deadline.

Does anyone actually know how many mafia are in this game? I'm guessing around 3-5.

 

[I LAG]

there are exactly 3 unless vyse has changed the basic 4:1 town/mafia ratio
so if moose has a neutral role them i'm guessing there are like 3 other people with neutral roles?
are they the people voting for moose?
whats their goal to win?

 

[Leisha]

Hmmm, Since i said i would change my vote before, and cant decide who i want to lynch now. Ima stick with no lynch and let everyone else decide.

Vote: No Lynch

 

[SummonerAU]

we have a foot hold
u just want to test it.

Town is climbing a mountain at the moment. D.K, Donkey Kong is here. They see a foothold up ahead. The foothold's name is moose. Some people wish to completely trust the foothold, not thinking that it could be weak/fake and cause town to fall to their death. Others want to test the foothold before putting their full weight on it.

In no way, can we say that we already have the foothold.


Also, here's another idea. If the cop is coming out for Vlade anyway, why not just get him to investigate Moose the night after?
...I can't believe I didn't think of this earlier. Nobodies dies from Moose's whipback from the lynch, Moose doesn't get targetted and such. If people think he's mafia and that keeping him around is bad, couldn't we just ask him to not vote or something until he's investigated or we'll lynch him?

It's just a matter of how quickly we want to gather information atm

 

[undead_moose]

Ill gladly not vote to prove my innocence

 

[Leisha]

Remember if you're doing that you have to put "Vote: No Lynch" in capitals, or else your vote will remain what you previously voted

 

[undead_moose]

While you all test this foot hold another person will have their rope cut and fall to their death

Its a waste of a lynch

 

[SummonerAU]

Moose, if you're seriously happy with that, it makes me less suspicious of you. As I was the one to suggest it, I hardly think that it's appropriate for me to stop voting you. So if anyone else things this is a good idea, stop voting moose and I'll remove my vote after that.

 

[Leisha]

Was just a friendly reminder,

Anyways for now, we should analyze Day 3 events very carefully to make sure we can track down some mafia, hopefully for whoever gets lynched today will hopefully be mafia so we can get an advantage.

 

[Vlade]

no vlade is tense, he will kill all who target him. so use your turn to investigate someone else, someone thats not in the spot light.
except maybe a roleblocker. but that would just mess things up =P

If a couple more people approve the investigation then I'm choosing relaxed, I only said I was going tense because I thought yesterday was wednesday

 

[unreon]

I can concur with Summoner's plan. In either case, we establish and eliminate or confirm two townies as suspects. There is nothing but good that come from this.

Let's confirm Vlade tonight, and moose the next. Once Vlade is cleared, he is untouchable and provides valuable voting power. Once moose is clear, that clears Toshi.

For now, we might as well vote people other than Vlade and moose/Toshi. Because soon we would have confirmed their identities anyway. This gives us something to work from.