So when you get phrases like, "people who throw controllers are ********," this does not constitute mindless criticism? It doesn't say anything helpful to the person throwing it. It says nothing useful about the situation. It's an easy judgment to make, so people make it and don't care.agree mostly but it's no more fair to call it mindless criticism than it is for observers to assume the worst about those who rage. oddly enough, i think people rush to judgment in these matters not due to lack of empathy, but precisely b/c they too have been angry and demonstrated adequate emotional control. that doesn't make it good, but i don't think people are completely misguided in this regard
Oskar:
No, most smashers aren't registered psychologists. So it's actually interesting to read bold and inflammatory claims about what a given action MUST represent in terms of somebody's mental state. IE: he threw a controller, therefore he's a spoiled brat and should **** off.
Not everybody needs to chip in. If you don't know the person enough for your words to be received, or you aren't confident enough to help somebody even if they don't need it, or you are genuinely worried they could physically lash out.... then don't. That's fine.
And you know what? SOME PEOPLE ARE SPOILED. Some people *are* scrubs that won't benefit from ANY help until they do some introspection of their own. Some people aren't worth the time you spend until they make themselves available to that assistance.
By assuming that somebody who throws a controller IS that person, you could well be doing a disservice to somebody who actually needs advice and friendship, or at the least, could be genuinely hurt by insults and uninformed judgments. This whole thread was spurred because somebody publicly apologized, explained the reasoning behind his behavior, and said he'd learn from it... then he got called a johning moron for doing so. And then it turned into a circlejerk where everybody felt good about mocking the guy who threw his controller.
I don't know if a public apology and explanation constitutes disrespect, but I think actively trashing that apology does.