Project M Social Thread

[FrozenHobo]

he's weaker and dies earlier (which is saying something since pikachu is already light). again, outside of his gimicky electricity and his costumes, why should he be brought back? could just add his positive stuff into pikachu

Spoiler

if he had any...

 

[Sora-kun]

he's weaker and dies earlier (which is saying something since pikachu is already light). again, outside of his gimicky electricity and his costumes, why should he be brought back? could just add his positive stuff into pikachu

Spoiler

if he had any...

He's adorable tho.

inb4modelhakx

 

[Grim Tuesday]

he's weaker and dies earlier (which is saying something since pikachu is already light). again, outside of his gimicky electricity and his costumes, why should he be brought back? could just add his positive stuff into pikachu

Spoiler

if he had any...

roy can't combo for **** and gets ***** by combos himself. again, outside of his gimicky fire and his different hit-boxes, why should he be brought back? could just add his positive stuff into marth

 

[jahkzheng]

Very cool...
lol, I chose a good day to spend time on this thread.


Also...

Its been quite a while since I've checked in here, but just by poking around I've discovered that this project seems to have successfully took the physics from Melee and inserted them into brawl's engine.

Now is this a complete physics change into Melee, or is it just taking some of the things that you want from Melee and putting them into your mod while keeping some of what you might want from Brawl? I've heard for instance that Ganon keeps his choke - which pleases me - but what else has gotten the same treatment?

I imagine that a weak Melee character like Kirby has retained whatever it is that made it better in Brawl or at least had it's Melee flaws worked out. I guess what I'm trying to say is... if you're using 80% of Melee in this game then is the other 20% essentially for balancing Melee?

I'm also curious how Meta Knight was or rather is being handled and how Melee clones are - if they are at all - retaining what has made them more original in Brawl. For example, I've read and seen that Falco is his much more clone-like, yet still awesome Melee self. However, is there any part of Falco that is uniquely brawl like with Ganon?

I guess long story short, I'm just interested how you guys will keep things balanced, keep things Melee, and keep things unique.
(Lol, the short question seems to be begging for a long answer...)

One thing I wanted to add was how you'd make Mewtwo, Roy, and the other missing clones less "cloneish" yet balanced from their generally weaker Melee versions... but it didn't seem relevant earlier today, lol.

 

[Strong Badam]

Roy is our boy.
Pichu is a joke.
[/jokes]

We aren't going to argue who will and who won't be included in this thread. When the game is released, you'll see who's in it, and you can deal with it.

 

[FrozenHobo]

roy can't combo for **** and gets ***** by combos himself. again, outside of his gimicky fire and his different hit-boxes, why should he be brought back? could just add his positive stuff into marth

dunno. i don't support his return either.

what i do know, is if you made marth's sword have a hitbox that could kill on the inside and the outside, you'd get mario's new fsmash.

pretty much, they haven't because it would make marth broken.

 

[stingers]

strong_bad, continuing to alienate his audience even further. gj

 

[Grim Tuesday]

dunno. i don't support his return either.

*Last comment by Strong_Bad was acknowledged, I'll stop after this post*

Exactly! Both Roy and Pichu have the same things going against them, so it wouldn't make any sense to include one but not the other.

EDIT FOR EDIT:
But what about giving him Roy's DED? Or his Dtilt?

Lol @ Stingers.

 

[FrozenHobo]

EDIT FOR EDIT:
But what about giving him Roy's DED? Or his Dtilt?

Lol @ Stingers.

there's a lot of talk about giving him and a lot of other characters roy's dtilt

 

[nicaboy]

yes, but the down side is that the common masses can't just make their own CSS with clone engines... suffice to say, for the time being, P:MBR is the only place with a working clone engine. don't expect a public version for a while.

its whatever i dont really care lol

just manchu

rolf

Seriously guys. Don't leave him out because he is low tier.
I will lose so much faith in this project.

Spoiler

But I'll probably still download it and enjoy it anyway. -__-

lol sure buddy. i dont care if old chars dont come back

 

[FireBall Stars]

Roy have a completely different style of play, that can be polished and become into a even more individualized character.

 

[Grim Tuesday]

lol sure buddy. i dont care if old chars dont come back

Considering you're the guy who thinks that Sheik is a better character than Falco, I couldn't care less about your opinion.

Roy have a completely different style of play, that can be polished and become into a even more individualized character.

And Pichu can't have a completely different, polished and individual style of play because...?

 

[stingers]

MK already has Roys dtilt. why give it to Roy

 

[nicaboy]

Considering you're the guy who thinks that Sheik is a better character than Falco, I couldn't care less about your opinion.



And Pichu can't have a completely different, polished and individual style of play because...?

Well this is true but my opnion on melee has nothing to due with this game

I swear if it makes you happy for his return then i hope it happens. I really do.

Nice troll though

 

[Frogles]

And Pichu can't have a completely different, polished and individual style of play because...?

because hes just a small pikachu with a big head. why bother bringing him back when they could add better characters like cliff clavin or that talking fish from the mcdonalds commercial.

pichu sucks.

 

[Grim Tuesday]

Well this is true but my opnion on melee has nothing to due with this game

I swear if it makes you happy for his return then i hope it happens. I really do.

Nice troll though

Thankyou, nicaboy.

because hes just a small pikachu with a big head. why bother bringing him back when they could add better characters like cliff clavin or that talking fish from the mcdonalds commercial.

pichu sucks.

*sigh*
Do I seriously have to do another analogy where I compare Roy to Pichu? -__-

 

[Revven]

There's not even a proper model for Pichu like there is YL, Mewtwo, and Roy. No good quality model, no point in discussing it.

 

[FrozenHobo]

i'm still not seeing why you just can't play pikachu?

besides being faster, what positive does pichu have that pika doesn't?

 

[Jiangjunizzy]

strong_bad, continuing to alienate his audience even further. gj

stingers, the fox news of smashboards

 

[GHNeko]

Man i love stingers

 

[ValTroX]

so, IF characters come back, what will the crowd say when they cheer for em? *wonders and expects a crash*
Edit: I guess they'll cheer for the character that was cloned

 

[shanus]

im a pichu supporter, <3 pichu

 

[BlueSuperSonic1]

I think they'll just use Sound Effects from Melee

 

[nicaboy]

Thankyou, nicaboy.



*sigh*
Do I seriously have to do another analogy where I compare Roy to Pichu? -__-

You welcome

Man i love stingers

Why you change it dog i see what you did there

 

[Sora-kun]

because hes just a small pikachu with a big head. why bother bringing him back when they could add better characters like cliff clavin or that talking fish from the mcdonalds commercial.

pichu sucks.

I'm so saving this. Best post i've seen all day.

 

[ValTroX]

I think they'll just use Sound Effects from Melee

as far as i'm concerned, they cannot add sounds without replacing other sounds, unless the clone engine works for other stuff(that would be amazing)

 

[FireBall Stars]

You don't need pichu because the new pikachu is that pichu evolved, he even knows volt tackle :B rofl

I just needed to know about Roy, now I don't care about anything but our boy.

 

[shanus]

im a pichu supporter, <3 pichu

quoted for shanus

 

[Grim Tuesday]

i'm still not seeing why you just can't play pikachu?

besides being faster, what positive does pichu have that pika doesn't?

All of his aerials are better except for up air.
The speed is a LARGE part of it, his playstyle is pretty much based around it.
His side-b is better as well.

im a pichu supporter, <3 pichu

I love you Shanus.

 

[FrozenHobo]

k. so if pikachu got pichu's aerials and side b would you be happy?

 

[GwJ]

I'd say the playstyle differences between Link/Toon Link/Young Link are just as large as they are between Marth/Roy/Ike.

But that logic is apparently thrown out the window because Marth/Roy/Ike aren't technically the same person. Nevermind that Young Link and Adult Link were already the same person in Melee.

Learn2Zelda

Link (Brawl, Melee link is YL), Y. Link and T. Link are all different people.

 

[Deleted member]

I was wondering where the ****storm had gone.

We get it. You want that low tier character you never play because you're a neurotic, meatriding fanboy of that one smasher who is capable of winning with that ****bird of a character.

Its right up there with repetitive, annoying, cycled, argumentitive firestarters that do nothing but take up space just like l-cancelling arguments.

 

[Strong Badam]

strong_bad, continuing to alienate his audience even further. gj

didn't know you guys were paying money for this game.

 

[curry9186]

There's not even a proper model for Pichu like there is YL, Mewtwo, and Roy. No good quality model, no point in discussing it.

Case in point, nailed in a coffin, and superscope blasted to the other side of Jupiter.

 

[Grim Tuesday]

k. so if pikachu got pichu's aerials and side b would you be happy?

"The speed is a LARGE part of it, his playstyle is pretty much based around it".

I was wondering where the ****storm had gone.

We get it. You want that low tier character you never play because you're a neurotic, meatriding fanboy of that one smasher who is capable of winning with that ****bird of a character.

Its right up there with repetitive, annoying, cycled, argumentitive firestarters that do nothing but take up space just like l-cancelling arguments.

Hey man. **** you.

 

[GwJ]

Two people I know of are making one however and they're coming along nicely.

 

[stingers]

didn't know you guys were paying money for this game.

didn't know you wanted all your hard work to go to waste.

 

[DtJ Jungle]

Probably been asked

Are you guys implementing momentum for when fox shines on the ground?

 

[GHNeko]

Why you change it dog i see what you did there

¯\(°_o)/ ¯

 

[curry9186]

Are there going to be new recovery moves for people with tether recoveries or is that staying?