agreed that sonic should be at the bottom of mid tier. He has done mediocre in tournaments and sonics such as hella's show the true potential that he has.
No he hasn't.
He has 3 wins and several times has ended up in the top eight. Compared to other characters like Mario, and bowser and captain falcon who actually have mediocre standings.
And what exactly has Sonic done since then? Seth's still owning, as he won Hobo 5 a couple days ago.
I can't remember the last time he's even rose in Ankoku's tourney data, he's been dropping like a rock, while characters who we knew were good from the start are starting to rise
Perhaps it has something to do with the amount of usage the character receives.
There aren't many Sonic mains and if you look at tourney charts you would see that Sonic has definitely not had much usage during tournaments.
D rank
24 Zero Suit Samus (7 top8, 6 top4, 1 win, 23.5 pts)
25 Diddy Kong (12 top8, 4 top4, 1 win, 21 pts)
26 Luigi (5 top8, 4 top4, 1 win, 17.5 pts)
26 Sheik (5 top8, 4 top4, 1 win, 17.5 pts)
28 Ness (4 top8, 2 top4, 1 win, 12 pts)
29 Mario (4 top8, 3 top4, 9.5 pts)
29 Bowser (4 top8, 3 top4,9.5 pts) <30>
All of the above characters are often considered mid tier level (except Bowser and Ness) and Diddy Kong is often seen as being high up in the mid tier list.
It is not surprising to see that sonic is dropping or the fact that Luigi, Sheik, ZSS, Mario are in D rank.
The same goes for the above characters. They hardly receive as much usage as DDD, Snake, MK and Lucario had definitely seen a boost in usage during this time.
So it isn't accurate to say oh Sonic isn't good because he hasn't been winning much.
Is Diddy deserving of low tier simply because he hasn't been winning much? Of course not, popularity can influence the results.
I had sonic as a debatable candidate for the bottom of the middle tier because his tournament placement, but then I looked at his match-ups, in which his bad match-ups outweigh most of his good ones.He has a good share of neutrals, but a fair amount of his match-ups give him the disadvantage, so I think his match-ups negate some of his tournament sucess and in my opinion would more accurately be at the top of the low tier.(If you give me more evidence to justify sonic's position at the bottom of the middle rather than the top of the low tier, I will reconsider his placement.
Well the main reason for many of his disadvantage is also due to the ideas that people seem to be stuck on.
For example how his matchup list says he is at a disadvantage to Samus which is grossly untrue.
Or how the ZSS forums still believe that sonic is at a great disadvantage against ZSS.
So those misconceptions have affected Sonic's amtchup list.
Sonic actually does have a larger amount of advantages/neutral than disadvantages.
The matchup list has several things that irk me somewhat.
For example Samus vs Sonic is an advantage for Sonic yet it is listed as disadvantaged. At the very least it should be neutral.
It is largely believed by both Olimar and Sonic mains that Sonic goes neutral with Olimar, a character who is a very good candidate for high tier.
It is also known that Sonic has at least a neutral matchup with DK who counters Snake and MK. Even if he does have a disadvantage it is a soft one.
Or how people believe Ike is neutral to Sonic despite the fact that Sonic can easily kill him at low percentages and can approach him very quickly.
Sonic also at least has neutral matchup with Pit. Mainly because he can approach pit, and pressure him. While Pit has dominance of the air a grounded Sonic can pose trouble since Pit's range on the ground isn't very large and Sonic can approach Pit very quickly without much difficulty.
Sonic has more neutral/advantage matchups rather than disadvantaged matchups.
Some of the disadvantaged matchups are also soft counters they don't hit him hard enough to the point that he would lose.
I Do think he is a candidate for mid tier.his disadvantages only really occur with upper mid tier and up.
Bottom and low tier characters he outperforms those characters too much for him to be with them.
*shrug*
Of course Sonic is one of those characters that are hard to define in playstyle since every Sonic plays him differently so it will be awhile before he is really placed in a tier solidly.
at worst I think he is in the lower half of mid tier. (I say lower half since the mid tier has often had issues in character placement since i want to keep it general since things tend to shift.)