Brawl... the good the bad and the ugly.
I've just played Brawl and my first impression is that It. Is. Not. Meant. For. Competitive. Play. Sorry!
Good news is that is is fun to play. Though it seems like a party game that anyone can pick up and still be good.
The airdodging system is absolute crap, it takes too long to recover from doing it so you just get hit anyways, even worse, it gives the other person time to do an even better smash to kill you after you airdodge. There's hardly any mindgames with no wavedashing, dashdancing or anything... it's too straight foward. Coupled with no mindgames AND no ways to enhance your character's moves via "advanced techniques"... it's just so slow, not to mention it takes forever to kill somebody.
Ugh... one thing that pissed me off is randomly 'tripping'... yes... tripping... I was watching my brother play against Yamer and both of them were very high percents on their last stock. Yamer ran up to smash Dark for the victory, it was all but unavoidable! Then... TRIP! Yamer randomly falls just as he's about to smash and Dark uses this opportunity to do a smash attack and kill him. (Yamer brought up a funny point with this saying "imagine seeing that in MLG finals, last match." I mean about to get the win for the grand prize until a trip shatters your victory, that's just dumb AND pathetic.)
Some characters that we noticed were extremely better than other characters. Dedede was one of them. He has good attack, tanking power, has a chaingrab which can chaingrab almost anyone across the stage (and even if he misses he has barely any noticeable lag), and he has very good recovery. Didn't the nintendo people want to make this game more balanced? Then why the hell is this guy got everything going for him? Not to mention he has an unlimited supply of a waddledee army that he can throw instantly with no lag. Just imagine peach spamming turnips but he can throw them without picking them up and has a higher chance of a stitchface (gordon, the spikey thing).
Ugh, pikmin and olimar had to be the most annoying character to fight against in the game. Yeah he needs pikmin to do anything, except he picks up pikmin INSTANTLY! And when I say instantly I mean he can get max pikmin in less than a second. The fact that the pikmin can LATCH ONTO YOUR SHIELD is just utterly inane. There's absolutely no way to protect yourself from him spam throwing them which do insane damage quickly. Most of the time you find yourself trying to dodge the pikmin than causing damage to Olimar. All of the pikmin do random things like causing good damage and knockback to poisoning you until you have to hit them off yourself.
Sonic and metaknight were not as bad as I thought they were gonna be to fight against them. They *can* build damage up fast but they have virtually no killing moves. We found ourselves living toward up to 230 percents until we died.
I don't know who the hell was smoking when they said Peach was easy to use if you played her in Melee, I had to adjust to a lot of things. Boo her double jump and umbrella!!!