I will watch it but what grabbed my attention was the comments in the tweet vs our little dusty corner of the Internet at smash boards. looks like a fair mix of "I hope he works on something else" (Reboot Ice Climbers like be did Kid Icarus for example) and "I hope we get a deluxe." Or NO new game at all because at least in those scenarios Ultimate and EiH stays on top, since so many people are afraid of who will get cut. And 2B as a newcomer.
I think a fear of moving on from Ultimate is warranted. Everyone is here, after all. But we can’t just stagnate and just add more and more to Ultimate.
This is not a Mario Kart 8 situation, where the original game was on a dying system, and given new life on a new console. And what happens on the next system, when new faces are still being created and becoming popular? Stagnation.
Third parties not returning to Smash is also a scary thought for people who wanted certain characters. If Cloud and Hero are cut, there’s no way Geno and 2B get in. If Banjo and Steve are out, Crash and Doom Slayer aren’t getting in.
I think a part of it is also a fear of newer first parties getting in over what they grew up with. Byleth, Min Min, and Pyra and Mythra all had their detractors, all being newer first parties when Ultimate was adding DLC. It means more competition for their character to get in Smash.
I would be fine with scaling down the roster, but not too far. I don’t want to go back down to a Melee or Brawl sized roster. Preferably around post-DLC Smash 4’s size. And of course… bias plays a factor.
People can end up cutting characters for petty reasons, such as disliking/unfamiliar with a series, a game/character’s fanbase, or simply disliking the look of a character.
It is also so easy to cut clones for some people. But it’s important to know that clones are a part of Smash. Every game, since 64, has had its fair share of clones.
A lot of people aren’t ready for the unprecedented cuts we could see. I wouldn’t be surprised if Star Fox is only left with Fox, or Mother cut in its entirety besides music. Kid Icarus may be left with only Pit. I don’t think the original 12 are safe from cuts.
We may also see other cuts. Assist Trophies, stages, music, and more. Sure, playable fighters matter. But it’s important to look at ATs and more too.
The original 12 in Smash 64 made sense, because it was representative of Nintendo at the time. But it’s been 25 years since then. Nintendo has changed. Their premiere franchises have changed. It’s like some fans have an aversion to post-Millenium or post-GameCube franchises.
People feel nostalgia over many things, but nostalgia is constantly evolving, not stuck in the pre-Wii era. People will feel nostalgic over the Switch at some point, like remembering their experiences with BOTW and Mario Odyssey, or dabbling their feet in newer series like Xenoblade and Splatoon.
Smash fans on websites such as Twitter and Reddit love the EiH and third party presence. But a roster of that scale and licensing is just not sustainable.
The next Smash game doesn’t need to be Ultimate. After Ultimate, you have to cut back to move forward. Perhaps a new game that is more first-party focused with less third parties would be a good thing.