So what do you think of the future of the Dragon Quest franchise in regards to Smash?
I’m a major optimist about the Square Enix characters. More so than any other batch of 3rd parties. I think it’s hard to overstate the significance of all of our current SE reps. Cloud and Sephiroth were already insanely popular and will likely be at peak relevance when Smash 6 rolls around.
And Dragon Quest is
mainstream in Japan. On par with Mario and Pokemon. I know SE has a reputation among Smash fans for being stingy, but they
really invested in Ultimate and I have to imagine both parties want to keep things going. I feel like things have to go terribly awry for any of these characters to be left behind.
I know every third party is significant, but I seriously feel the Square characters stand out and would be particularly heavy losses and I don't see a reason why Nintendo's biggest DLC partner for Ultimate won't be one of their biggest partners once again. And I don't think Sakurai would want to plan for selling a character as DLC twice and would likely try to compromise by once again having 2+ new Square characters as DLC in addition to our current lineup in the base game.
This is the big thing for me that I think doesn’t get discussed enough. People have a lot of good will and optimism about third party guests. I agree that nearly everyone will want to participate again, if given the chance. But we don’t have any real precedent for how guest characters are treated other than Sonic, who is the one third party character everyone thinks is 100% safe for good reason.
The scope has widened and third parties are a bigger part of the series’ identity now. I feel like this is inescapable and hard to fully scale back on. But I do question how much this is the case, whether or not the optics of Everyone is Here has skewed perception in a deceiving way. Smash has also grown into a strong vehicle to collaborate with partners and I see a lot of that being maintained, so I dunno. It’s a pretty weird grey area.
I think there's good reason to believe in either side of the argument. On one hand - they are literally guest characters and this is a Nintendo IP fighter at the end of the day. Half of our Brawl 3rd parties were cut for Smash For. There is no reason to think these characters are sacred, no matter how popular and unique they are, especially when Nintendo has every reason to prioritize their own brand, which they've regularly done in the past.
On the other hand - Ultimate went
so heavy on third party inclusions. 1st party newcomers have slowed down significantly and a certain expectation has been built up that this is the direction for Smash going forward. Additionally, Nintendo has had some of the best third party support in a long time and presumably Smash is one way of strengthening these relationships. Every party is incentivized to keep their characters in a game as popular as Smash and Sakurai sure gave every damn third party a
ton of love in Ultimate. It's hard to imagine any of them being easy to part with.
As nostalgic as I am for a more Nintendo focused roster, I do lean towards the theory that Ultimate is the first big step towards Smash changing its identity somewhat. I don't say that with a ton of confidence, but it is my current hunch.