Don't fail her like PS Allstars did.
Surprising to see Ellen brought up. She's actually near the top of the characters I'd like to see from Sony and even
I forgot to mention her this time.
While I've pretty much fallen away from Sony (and MS) from pretty early in that generation, Folklore was one of the games I did enjoy. Didn't live up to its potential in many ways, but was still a lovely game that hasn't gotten enough attention through the years.
That said, I actually kind of prefer the way Keats fights... But Ellen is definitely the one to go with (for... several reasons).
Big question would be, 'What would they go with for a stage?'
I love the quaint aesthetic of Doolin (which is probably one of my strongest and fondest memories of the game, honestly), so that would be my preference. It feels like it has to be something from the Netherworld though, so you can actually take advantage of the fantastical elements.