Official Newcomer/DLC Speculation Discussion

[Iko MattOrr]

I remember I voted for Adeleine and Karate Joe.
I think there was a text somewhere that said that multiple votes were possible, but they asked us to limit the votes to two for each user, and that's why I voted twice.

Saved somewhere I probably still have the text that I included in those vote submissions too.

 

[Idon]

You all fail to realize the truth of the voting ballot:

 

[Deleted member]

You all fail to realize the truth of the voting ballot:

View attachment 268494

I see you're a person of culture as well haha

Tbh I didn't partake in that ballot stuff so I have no idea.

 

[DarthEnderX]

I just voted the one time...for Simon.

 

[RealLuigisWearPink]

I voted for Wolf. I was very happy with the Ultimate reveal lol

 

[Dalek_Kolt]

I voted Ganon, since the other character choices I wanted (Ridley, K. Rool, Skull Kid) already had sizable enough fanbases and didn't need my help, and I felt I should instead be bringing visibility to some more overlooked characters.

...At least he's a proper boss now instead of just a half-second cameo in a Final Smash?

 

[Verde Coeden Scalesworth]

I voted Ganon, since the other character choices I wanted (Ridley, K. Rool, Skull Kid) already had sizable enough fanbases and didn't need my help, and I felt I should instead be bringing visibility to some more overlooked characters.

...At least he's a proper boss now instead of just a half-second cameo in a Final Smash?

I mean, who knows, maybe some votes helped.

I just voted for Brian one time and that was it. As much I wish I put more moveset ideas down, I just treat him as no-chancer anyway. I'll support him with all my heart, but I'm aware of the various issues. Etc.

 

[PeridotGX]

I don't remember who my ballot vote was, except for the fact it was someone I really don't care about anymore. Maybe Ninten?

 

[Cutie Gwen]

Man it sure is great seeing Bayonetta's fanbase all be considering one whiny dude when in reality she was a popular Smash suggestion on sites like tumblr and NeoGAF back during the ballot period. I'm going to now say that your favourite character who got im the ballot only made it in because of someone who spent every moment of their life just to farm votes for whoever you liked that we got from the ballot

 

[Hinata]

My ballot vote was Phoenix.

Then I voted for Yu Narukami.

Then I voted for Bayonetta.

Then I voted for a few other characters I don't remember.

 

[CaptainAmerica]

I voted a few times, but I made sure to vote each time from a different device or on a different network. Not that I thought it did anything, but I know I wrote something completely different each time. I even voted in the European poll when I was on vacation in Germany. That was fun: "Ich will Schiggy wieder haben. Glurak fehlt etwas ohne Schiggy und Bisaknosp."

I threw a few at Ridley, K. Rool, Midna, and of course the return of Squirtle. I still thought the fanrule about "must have been on a Nintendo console" was a real thing, so I didn't vote any third parties. Pity I never got to vote for my boy...

 

[Krankees]

I don't seem to remember who I voted for.
Yet why do I have the feeling young me voted for Goku?

 

[Cutie Gwen]

There was a problem fetching the tweet

Sakurai's just confirmed he'll be working on the game from home due to the virus

 

[King Sonnn DeDeDoo]

On the topic of the ballot, I voted for Snake. hearing Sakurai say that Snake was back due to popular demand felt so good.

There was a problem fetching the tweet

Sakurai's just confirmed he'll be working on the game from home due to the virus

im glad to hear that he’s taking the necessary precautions, sometimes Sakurai scares me with the amount of work he’ll put himself through even if it’s a detriment to his health.

 

[Cutie Gwen]

On the topic of the ballot, I voted for Snake. hearing Sakurai say that Snake was back due to popular demand felt so good.


im glad to hear that he’s taking the necessary precautions, sometimes Sakurai scares me with the amount of work he’ll put himself through even if it’s a detriment to his health.

Especially as he's a freelancer, meaning he gets less benefits than a regular employee

 

[Will]

Especially as he's a freelancer, meaning he gets less benefits than a regular employee

if i hear one thing about nintendo mistreating sakurai they going bankrupt personally

 

[Cutie Gwen]

if i hear one thing about nintendo mistreating sakurai they going bankrupt personally

Bro Nintendo doesn't let regular employees go on IV fluid

 

[Icedragonadam]

That's good for Sakurai and his health.

Although the chance for leaks have increased.

 

[Will]

Bro Nintendo doesn't let regular employees go on IV fluid

say no more

how do i bankrupt a company by myself

 

[Jomosensual]

I did a ballot vote for Brock Lesnar, Mike Tyson, and Nathan Drake. Younger me was kinda dumb

 

[Ben Holt]

I voted for Crash. But then Phil Spencer said that he'd let Banjo in Smash, so I changed my vote to Banjo.
For those that didn't know, only the last vote from a particular IP address would count.

 

[N3ON]

Man it sure is great seeing Bayonetta's fanbase all be considering one whiny dude when in reality she was a popular Smash suggestion on sites like tumblr and NeoGAF back during the ballot period. I'm going to now say that your favourite character who got im the ballot only made it in because of someone who spent every moment of their life just to farm votes for whoever you liked that we got from the ballot

The most ironic thing is all that time was dedicated to voting for a character that was decided pre-ballot. Therefore it's one of the most significant exercises in futility I've ever heard of. But I guess that's karma for trying to stuff the ballot to that extent.

 

[Guybrush20X6]

I voted for Crash. But then Phil Spencer said that he'd let Banjo in Smash, so I changed my vote to Banjo.
For those that didn't know, only the last vote from a particular IP address would count.

Did they confirm that? Sounds like a big problem to those who made their votes on public wi-fi.

 

[Ben Holt]

Did they confirm that? Sounds like a big problem to those who made their votes on public wi-fi.

IIRC, it was GameXplain that reported on that, but this was half a decade ago.

 

[Idon]

The most ironic thing is all that time was dedicated to voting for a character that was decided pre-ballot. Therefore it's one of the most significant exercises in futility I've ever heard of. But I guess that's karma for trying to stuff the ballot to that extent.

Persisting in meaningless efforts despite the futility of it all is everything SMT is about.

And in a similar vein, so is waiting for its next entry.

 

[Ben Holt]

Didn't Sakurai admit that the ballot was for Smash Ultimate?

 

[Idon]

Didn't Sakurai admit that the ballot was for Smash Ultimate?

His direct words were (paraphrasing, here) "The newcomers for Ultimate took heavy cues from Smash 4 DLC's ballot" and they "were surprised at how popular K. Rool was." Which doesn't deconfirm the ballot was used for Smash 4 whilst simultaneously confirming it was used to a certain extent for Smash Ultimate.

Besides, even if the ballot was rigged*, it's simply bad PR to say "yeah we lied, the character was already decided, and we're only taking into account those results now."
* which it totally was

 

[blackghost]

If lore importance mattered to Smash inclusion (so far there’s no evidence of that), we’d have Ghirahim as a playable character. He’s pivotal in the overarching story of Zelda.

Edelgard is arguably the most important character to the plot of Three Houses. Byleth is obviously the main protagonist, but the events of the story don’t really happen without Edelgard.

I’m not convinced being “important to the lore” matters when Smash is a crossover mascot fighter.

cant have both.

All of the characters in smash are important to their stories, they either are the protagonist, villain, or have massive story impacts (i.e. rosalina). I used to think three houses centered om edelgard but after playing all three (four) routes the story does center on byleth. There is a lot of background conflicts and plot that centers on byleth's birth and significance. edelgard is important but sje is not the center of everything.

three houses is like the fates series.until you do all the routes you do not have all the information about what actually happened in fodlands past, no matter which lord or rhea you choose to follow, byleth is important to achieving that goal.

 

[Al-kīmiyā']

Sakurai gets paid a lot of money to make games. Don't cry for him.

 

[Lamperouge]

I remember putting down a few votes for Ridley and Cloud during the Ballot, alongside a few other characters that I can't seem to recall ATM.

 

[Will]

I voted for .

Not , not , just . I always wanted Red to have his own moveset just based on what you can do in the Pokemon overworld.

 

[Ben Holt]

I voted for .

Not , not , just . I always wanted Red to have his own moveset just based on what you can do in the Pokemon overworld.

I came up with an idea for Red once. Imagine Joker with Arsene, but Arsene is permanent, but not as OP.

 

[Evil Trapezium]

All I voted for was Ice Climbers and Banjo & Kazooie... and Dr. Luigi...

 

[Mamboo07]

I didn't vote for no one back in 2014 and didn't know about the ballot thing. (This was before joining Smashboards way, way back.)

 

[Idon]

I voted for .

Not , not , just . I always wanted Red to have his own moveset just based on what you can do in the Pokemon overworld.

Sorry to say but they probably took that the wrong way, lol.

 

[ZephyrZ]

I voted for . I also really wanted to vote for , but I limited myself to just one vote.

I never dreamed that the entire team would come back. I always figured at that most they'd be seperate fighters.

If I had to vote for a newcomer it would have been Sceptile. Not to fill some arbitrary grass quota, but just because Sceptile is cool. He got in Pokken though so I'm satisfied.

 

[Diddy Kong]

Agreed. To be honest I wouldn't consider Banjo & Kazooe, Ridley, and King K. Rool to be a holy trinity in the first place because 1, King K. Rool support didn't really exist until the ballot, and 2, there are tons of widely requested characters, not just 3.

K.Rool support was wide spread way before the ballot. Stop lying. It existed as soon as Diddy got into Brawl. It's the very same fanbase. K.Rool was always a hugely requested character.

 

[Ben Holt]

K.Rool support was wide spread way before the ballot. Stop lying. It existed as soon as Diddy got into Brawl. It's the very same fanbase. K.Rool was always a hugely requested character.

I can second this. I was around under another account since Brawl speculation, and K. Rool was a popular request even in those days.

 

[HansShotFirst20]

Voted for Simon Belmont, Ridley, and Waluigi in the ballot. All things considered, I'm happy with the result.

 

[Diddy Kong]

Also I voted for K.Rool almost daily. I just now read they only count the last vote. I also voted a lot for Dixie Kong, Impa and Isaac. K.Rool was by far my most wanted however.