Carmen Sandiego and Style Savvy are two of my "never ask for anything again" picks, but I would also totally freak out if 2B, Estelle Bright, or a Soul Calibur character (especially Cassandra) got in. And if we're talking the pipest of dreams here: Kat. If Kat got in... I'm done. Nothing would eeever top that for me. But I'm the type of person who bought the season pass as soon as it was available. When it comes to Smash, I'm going to always get the DLC characters. It's a total steal.
Geez I get the Wii-u underperformed at a dramatic level but any more ports from it feel like just adding another mound of dirt on an already buried coffin. Though I would be fine with a XenoX port I suppose.
At this point all it would have left are Splatoon 1, 3D World and the Guest Characters in Mario Maker.
It'd also have Nintendo Land, Yoshi's Wooly World, Mario Party 10, Smash 4, Fatal Frame: MoBW, the Nintendo edition of Tekken Tag Tournament 2, its Wii backwards compatibility and Eshop collection, and its separate screen gimmick, which made games like Lego Marvel Superheroes and Hyrule Warriors more fun locally because each player had an entire screen to themselves. I'm glad that there are a lot of Wii U ports that people can experience for the first time, but it's also kinda funny because the Wii U itself was very solid and super underrated.
But yeah... please give us that Xenoblade X port, Nintendo!
1. Snom. If you can, I envy you.
2. Gen 8 Starters
3. Dixie Kong.
4. Fire Emblem Heroes protagonist with the gun that shoots FE characters
That's like the 3rd request of a cute little Pokemon I never heard of, but I can definitely make that work. The water Gen 8 starter is probably the most underrated of the three; the rabbit seems neat, IMO; the monkey is popular on here. I think Dixie has a lot of potential, so that'll be fun to make her as unique as possible. I'm just now realizing how much I want a FE character with a gun in Smash lol.
1. A space invader
2. Circus Charlie...
3. This one is hard, not due to the lack of characters but rather that there are a bunch of them. Maybe 2B, Arle, Kazuma Kiryuu, Amateratsu, Arthur, Dovahkiin, Ezio, Reiko Nagase, Chosen Undead, Jack Frost from the top of my head.
4. Adol from Ys, have little experience with the series but it is one of the most influential series among JRPGs, alternatively someone like Master Chief or Doomguy who are from an unrepresented genre are from a unique archetype as having several weapons but don't really care much about them
Space Invaders surprisingly has a lot to pull from, and a huge legacy to boot, so that'd be an honor. I already did Circus Charlie, but I could probably finish up the concept since I didn't post a complete moveset. Those are all good choices. I'd love to do one for Adol. I feel the same way about most of the shooter protagonists lol.
1. York (Deadly Premonition)
As someone who has York as their 3rd most wanted character in Smash and thinks would be the biggest WTF pick for DLC, I have no idea how he'd work in Smash with how limited the combat in the original game is. Granted, Deadly Premonition 2 could have a varied and different combat system than the original, but right now, it's hard for me to think of stuff York could do for a game like Smash.
2. Johnny Gat (Saints Row)
After playing a few Saints Row games, Gat's a cool character. The series may have jumped multiple sharks after the 2nd game, but I'd be down for Gat in Smash even when it won't happen. I just don't really want to think of his possible Smash moveset though cause I haven't played through every Saints Row game (or even Agents of Mayhem but I'm not interested in playing it unless it goes on sale for around $5 USD probably). I also want to bring up that he's playable in Divekick, so there's that.
3. Michael (Metal Wolf Chaos)
Alright this game is really stupid and would probably also fit with the 1st category, but it's the kind of stupid that I enjoy and would certainly love to see be in Smash as the FromSoft rep so that all Smash fans can enjoy the amount of times Michael screams RICHAAAAAAAAAARD.
4. A Streets of Rage character (Streets of Rage)
Streets of Rage 4 was announced in the Nindies, and even though Sidescrolling beat-em-ups aren't my thing, I think Streets of Rage would be a pretty cool franchise to add. I only say a Streets of Rage character because I don't really know anything about the characters in the games, so I'm curious as to who could rep the series in Smash if there's more than 1 protagonist.
OMG, I'm surprised York from Deadly Premonition wasn't brought up yet, but he somehow didn't cross my mind; great suggestion. Same for Johhny! I'm glad you brought awareness to Metal Wolf Chaos, because I had no idea that existed. This is a very solid list, and it even gives me an excuse to post a Blaze Fielding moveset.