Super Smash Bros. Fan... if this is your roster.
[COLLAPSE="Roster"]Mario series
- Mario
- Luigi
- Peach
- Bowser
- Bowser Jr.
Well, I will be honest... I have a bias favoring Toad but Bowser Jr. is a decent choice... as long as he does not end up a Bowser clone. At least you didn't add Waluigi or worse, Geno.
Donkey Kong series
- Donkey Kong
- Diddy Kong
- King K. Rool
This is perfect in my opinion. King K. Rool deserves to be in for being such an important character in the original Donkey Kong Country trilogy. If you had Dixie Kong paired with Diddy Kong here, it would be MORE THAN PERFECT in my eyes.
Yoshi series
- Yoshi
Perfect as is... but my inner fanboy kinda wishes that Yoshi would have Baby Mario riding on him a la Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island.
Wario series
- Wario
Perfect as is... but my inner fanboy also wishes that Wario would have moves from Wario Land games instead of made-up moves based on his WarioWare persona.
Zelda series
- Link
- Zelda / Sheik
- Ganondorf
- Toon Link OR Young Link
Perfect as is... though I prefer Toon Link over Young Link despite Majora's Mask being my #1 favorite Zelda game. Tingle would be an added bonus in my eyes.
Metroid series
- Samus
- Ridley
Perfect as is... personally, I could do without Ridley but where is Zero Suit Samus? Unless you meant that Zero Suit Samus is part of Samus and is still playable...
Kirby series
- Kirby
- Meta Knight
- King Dedede
Perfect as is. It does not need any more newcomers.
Star Fox series
- Fox
- Falco
- Wolf
Perfect as is... personally, I can live without Falco and I couldn't care less about Krystal.
Pokemon series
- Pikachu
- Jigglypuff
- Pokemon Trainer
- Mewtwo OR Lucario OR New Pokemon?
- Zoroark OR Victini
You know my inner fanboy wants Meowth to be that New Pokemon. LOL With that out of the way, which starters are you referring to for Pokemon Trainer here? 1st gen (same as Brawl), or 2nd gen from HeartGold/SoulSilver or 5th gen from Black/White? It is so hard for me to pick which ones I want for Pokemon Trainer... most of them have so much moveset potential! Victini could be interesting but personally, I would rather see it replace Jigglypuff as a new floaty-type Pokemon.
F-Zero series
- Captain Falcon
Perfect as is... though if F-Zero gets a new game, then I would rather see Samurai Goroh over Black Shadow simply because Samurai Goroh has been with the series since the beginning. The only reason why people want Black Shadow is to give Ganondorf's old moveset to him so Ganondorf could get a sword.
EarthBound series
- Ness
- Lucas
Perfect as is. It doesn't need any more newcomers, especially now that the series is dead.
Fire Emblem series
- Marth
- Ike
This is semi-perfect... I think Ike might lose his spot to Caeda or a future new Lord. I would not lose sleep if Caeda or Ike isn't playable.
Retro characters
- Ice Climbers
- Mr. Game & Watch
- R.O.B.
Perfect as is... but we could add some more retro characters...
Kid Icarus series
- Pit
- Medusa
This is okay, but if you had added Palutena along with Medusa, then the Kid Icarus series would be complete just like the Kirby series.
Pikmin series
- Olimar
Perfect as is.
Punch-Out!! series
- Little Mac
Perfect as is... it is very, very likely he will finally join the roster in SSB4 thanks to his Wii game.
Sin & Punishment series
- Saki Amamiya OR Isa Jo
Perfect as is... though I think Isa Jo will get in over Saki Amamiya because he is the protagonist of Star Successor. It is like Ness vs. Ninten.
The Mysterious Murasame Castle (one game)
- Takamaru
Perfect as is... I can see him getting in SSB4 as well because he had a guest appearance in Samurai Warriors 3. But he should be grouped with the retro characters...
I am noticing a severe lack of Starfy, a Golden Sun character (Matthew or Isaac), Mii, and a second retro character who is also a WTF unlockable character (
)... but other than that, this is pretty decent pure-Nintendo roster.
[/COLLAPSE]