Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!
You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!
I kind went in on this tipsy, So I made very bad decisions early on.
Why am I scummy? : ]Vote: ranmaru
I don't agree with your logic behind your posts. I think it's scummy.
Hmmm, not nervous at all. My playstyle is weird? : [ How is that?
Mhmm. See, thing is, I have been trying to create discussion the whole time, even before the game started.
Ah ok. No, how do I seem nervous? Can you refer to a post that shows a nervous expression? You seem to thinking I'm trying to teach scum how to appear town... You did notice me saying being reserved for too long might be scummy, but you didn't notice me saying that you could ALSO just be indecisive? This, could mostly be a null tell.
I never said "Make a list of 3 people you'd lynch". I said make a scum list. Plus, I wasn't even sure of my list, why would I lynch them?
No, I am always vocal. I will give my opinion to town, and then town can think amongst themselves about it.
No, I'm sure anyone regardless of alignment could ask an IC to post since both factions could be lost, not just town.
Meaning you agreed with him without questioning, correct? Try not to do that, it's dangerous for town.
Mhmm. The thing is, the scum can't really say anything hurtful to town because that would be an obv scum tell. Even so, it's two people out of 9. Would you think they would oppose the other 7 when it would come to cop/doc directing?
I agree, he is following X1, probably because he is an IC and The Good Doctor knows that X1 may be right, and not himself.
No, but he asked because he was unsure of what to do. That just seems null, neither town nor scum.
Do you know, if you are scum, and you vote me/state i'm scum, you could be either bussing me (why so early in the game), or clearing me as town. Why would scum target their own partner? (IC please explain bussing)
So you say I should have a problem? What other plans do you think I have?
No, I'm not trying to look town at all. From the beginning I have been trying to get discussion going. Also, you comment on The Good Doctor's Colors, but not mine? I used yellow green and red, he used red and pink. What is wrong with colors?:|... Thanks I guess?
Self-hammering is voting yourself when you are on L-1 when to end the game early.
As for these questions that are about people's standings on the game: I like to know what people think are the best options, so I can actually tell if they are keeping to their word.
Now for what I think about players in this game...
X1-12 - I'd like to believe he's town, but yeah, you can't have the world.
Top Ranger Skye - ?? I forgot she was in the game. Can you start talking? You've made one post since the game has begun.
The good doctor - I think if I had to shoot one person at this moment, it would be you. I don't like the way you play, and the colours are a bit... useless, to me. Also, putting yourself in the list makes me wonder if you're liable enough >_<.
July - Making a good effort.
-Joey- - Same as above.
Oki - You have a sharp eye, I agree mostly on your view with Ranmaru, but I'm not sure why you are telling everyone that's it's just a vote for pressure and you could easily be convinced to vote someone else. I mean, sharing thoughts is good, but not everything needs to be shared. This takes a lot of pressure of your only weapon.
Ranmaru - You try to look town a lot. I can't say that's a tell, because according to the Theory of Dourin, all newbies want to stay alive and play for as long as possible. Looking town sometimes helps your chances, or decimate them.
vote: Top Ranger Skye
2 questions next;
Question to everyone
-1) What do you think of the 'lynch all lurkers'-policy. It means killing players who post very little (content) on Day 1 or maybe Day 2, so we don't get stuck with them in the more vital parts of the game.
The cost of this is not being able to go for who we think looks scummy on Day 1 (on the other hand, you might catch a lurker scum.)
-2) To whoever reads this, this is both to see wether you skim posts or not, and to see your opinion at this moment. Can everyone post the answer to this:
If you -had to- shoot one person right as you read this, who would it be, and a reason would always be nice.
The colors are fine. Also, why are you glad someone feels the same way about me? Scum can also be inactive, we don't know that.
This is what I derived your advice being "Be vocal it will make you look like town. Lurkers or quiet ones look scummy" from. Taking another, more innocent sounding quote from that same post and writing a big paragraph to me arguing about semantics is not convincing me.
He has posted questions, and also a vote.
Why is post #50 a null tell? Dourin is "asking the right questions and instilling discussion" via post #50, the thing you are determining he is town because of.
On the contrary what do scum gain from moving away from RVS? All it does is confuses town and wastes time. Scum who were just lost would happily sit and watch as town run around in circles.
Bussing is where a scum player will push a lynch on their partner in order to gain more town cred (credibility) Its not usually something that happens early game because people tend to forget who pushed who's lynch, so the 'town points' they had gained are lost and also because most people only use it to get out of a sticky corner, or to gain what they can from the inveitable death of their scummate - both situations that do not often occur on D1. Its not something that needs to be worried about until someone dies and their flip is revealed (Mod posts their role and alignment)
Kk I understand that, and with that said it seems like the best thing to do is just try and get inactive players active so we can hear their opinions and actually get a read on them. I thought about it too much in terms of aimaf, where inactives get killed quickly, but I do see the difference here now.
It's fine, I was a bit confused myself. It's because it was under Game Specific, the last section of the rules.
No, I said Also, plus I had more reasons as to why you were wrong. So you seem to be misconstruing my meaning. I do know vocal is similar to voice, but it seems as though that is what you want my post to be saying. Those, are not my words.
I would never base that as a read. Oh ok. Are you defending Nabe?
Right, it's not like people ask to stay in RVS. How would noobscum know if they SHOULD stay or move away? Plus, it is up to the IC to help the noobs gradually move anyways.
The Good Doctor's first vote seemed to be late stages of RVS. But then, it seems apparent he wants to push for me after voting me many times. But since everyone is suspicious of me, he finds it ok to vote me anyways.
You say that you suspect X1 of misguiding others, particularly in respect to Dourin's alignment. What would a scum!X1's motive be in doing so? What do you believe Dourin's alignment to be, so far?
Actually your questions are related to the reason I asked Oki if she thought you and TGD could be scum buddies. From you and The Good Doctor’s interactions, it seems to me that you and TGD are not scum buddies, TGD put you at L-1 at one point and bussing at this point seems unlikely. Since you and TGD are both suspicious, a more viable option is that one of you is scum and the other is town, and that’s the conflict we are seeing between you two.
Well, I guess it's not really working out if Top Ranger Sky can't even get online.
All I can say is, don't sign up if you know you have stuff coming up and can't post?