Bomber Man is far more well-known than Joker or Bayonetta which are only recent flavor of the months. Bomberman has been around since the NES era. I believe what hurt Bomberman's chances was having three Konami characters already. Richter Belmont likely took Bomberman's place because he was easier to make in a short span of time as a basic clone/semi-clone of Simon.
Ummm...This is debatable. Bomber Man died for a good stretch of time and has been known for a high Quantity of games that practically no one remembers. Bomber Man has a legacy, but I don’t think it’s as big as you are making it as his franchise followed the COD route of making numerous games and overflowing the market. I don’t think BM is really a character that is well recognized anymore outside of the retro games / Nintendo community which are relatively small as a whole.
Belmont’s took priority as they were said to be ballot winners, something no one on this site really seemed to vote for proving that Smash Boards is not a good indicator of popularity, and that you need to step outside to really see the larger scale.
Also, while Bayonetta and Joker are niche, they are from growing franchises that have made huge splashes in recent years. Persona really changed RPGs and UI design when P5 hit. The game was also considered as an opponent to BOTW at the 2017 Game Awards, that should say something that a game is being set against Mario and Zelda’s best outings. Bayonetta on the other hand has pretty much dethroned Dante for the hack and slash genre while also being a big figure for female and LGBT representation in gaming. Feminists have gone to great lengths to bring the franchise to the forefront of discussion on how social issues are portrayed in games (for better or worse..).
I believe what is hurting Rayman is Nintendo's dislike for non-Japanese made IP. Same is probably true of Crash.
I don’t think this effects them anymore. Nintendo is more than willing to work with Ubisoft and we have multiple western IPs in Smash from Rayman to Shovel Knight. Honestly, Rayman and Crash stand a decent chance at DLC, especially since Rayman is on the battlefield stage in an ice shard.
IMO, I wish that I could have had Miles "Tails" Prowers over Joker. It kind of sucks that Street Fighter and Castlevania got two characters but the Sonic series still only has one. The Sonic series could arguable be the biggest of the third party franchises (I believe Final Fantasy may beat it but very few others beat the Sonic series in popularity/iconic status. It is the face of SEGA).
You right, Sonic should have had an echo (probably Shadow). Other than Pac-Man, Sonic is like the only 3rd party that I bet non-gamers know of. The rest of the line up is more community specific, unless we get Minecraft as that’ll be the 3rd main stream title.
Regarding Banjo-Kazooie, I believe he has one of the most popular threads on this website. Nuff said. Smash fans want him and he is still popular. That is why he has 500 strings of posts in his support thread.
Don’t trust this website as I highlighted with the Belmonts. K Rool and Ridley were huge regardless of website, and were YouTube’s babies. YouTubers were the ones really pushing them, especially Ridley.
The Banjo thread may be big, but I feel that it suffers from being an echo chamber of the same individuals. They also bully competition, which is coming back to bite them as Steve is finally growing big enough to tell them off and dethrone them. I’ve seen Banjo fans get mad that the Steve fans are trashing their character, yet beforehand one guy saying he wants Steve was met with the Banjo squad rolling up to talk down to them.
I also think the Bomberman and Cloud argument is silly. Both are iconic. Bomberman, however, is more of the face of a franchise. Final Fantasy has different characters in each game (typically) so there isn't a face to their franchise. I would have preferred Black Mage from FF1 on the NES over Cloud.
I cannot agree with this. Cloud is the face of the franchise, he’s the one character that even non-fans will recognize. He’s also a major force in spin-offs such as Kingdom Hearts. I get he may not be in every title, but his influence is too large to neglect.
You say this like Smash has characters with spotless track records. You need to ignore like 70% of Sonic's games at this point and Ice Climber's 1 and only game is considered "meh" at best.
1. Ice Climbers are Nintendo so who cares....
2. Sonic is still one of the biggest gaming icons out there. He was the mascot for an entire system and was able to go toe to toe with Mario in sales and marketing. Even now, Sonic is still kicking harder than any 3rd party in Smash and has new games every two years or so. Meanwhile Banjo is a game on a Nintendo console from 5 generations ago with a decently sized fan base, you cannot even compare the two in scale as Sonic will win out.